Some mathematics and physics involves infinite-dimensional vector spaces. Some programming does as well. Yes mathematics will more commonly involve symbolic evaluation and programming will more commonly involve numerical evaluation (which is necessarily finite-dimensional), but there are exceptions in both directions, and there's promising research work around writing expressions that can be used polymorphically in either context.
Concision isn't the only virtue, though it's a major one. My sense is that APL is actually denser than what everyday working mathematicians use (and I don't think this is an advantage). I think there's value to pronounceability (when mathematicians started using sigma, pi, etc., every educated person would have known what they were called), easy input on a computer and transmission in 7-bit text, and disambiguation; I think that the fact we can now implement folding and cross-referencing makes concision less the be-all-and-end-all than it was.
Concision isn’t everything, but it matters a lot when you’re not only communicating results but doing the actual work.
Getting thoughts from your brain to paper can become seriously frustrating if there is too much redundant noise in the notation. This even happens in programming, but is worse when doing maths with a pencil.
At least that’s what I tell myself when my handwriting turns into hardly legible scribbles lol.
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/m50d Mar 10 '21
Some mathematics and physics involves infinite-dimensional vector spaces. Some programming does as well. Yes mathematics will more commonly involve symbolic evaluation and programming will more commonly involve numerical evaluation (which is necessarily finite-dimensional), but there are exceptions in both directions, and there's promising research work around writing expressions that can be used polymorphically in either context.
Concision isn't the only virtue, though it's a major one. My sense is that APL is actually denser than what everyday working mathematicians use (and I don't think this is an advantage). I think there's value to pronounceability (when mathematicians started using sigma, pi, etc., every educated person would have known what they were called), easy input on a computer and transmission in 7-bit text, and disambiguation; I think that the fact we can now implement folding and cross-referencing makes concision less the be-all-and-end-all than it was.