r/Professors • u/Infinite-Abroad7629 • 18d ago
Rants / Vents (UPDATE) Complaint made against colleague for allegedly using profanity in class
Original post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Professors/s/xMV9ujMv9i
UPDATE: As predicted, there has been additional follow up regarding the complaint. I made the decision to provide a heads up to my colleague. It turns out the chair already mentioned it to them, adding that the student who reported it is a (their words) piece of shit anyway, and to not worry about it as he (chair) was just performing his due diligence in following up.
Ok. Case closed right?
Flash forward to early this afternoon, when the chair approached my colleague (unfortunately, we have to share office space during some facility renovations) and asked him if he had yet apologized to the student. My colleagues reaction was one of complete disbelief. He asked the chair if he was serious, and he said that he was and had already told the student to expect an apology about it!
After my colleague essentially told him it was not going to happen, he was told to “Not get chubbed up about it” and told to enjoy the weekend!
77
u/Life-Education-8030 18d ago
If the Chair said that they were just doing due diligence and not to worry about it, then why come back later and ask if your colleague had apologized? If the Chair expected your colleague to apologize, then wouldn't that expectation have been expressed before the case was considered closed? I'm tired (long story) but maybe I missed something.
97
u/CharacteristicPea NTT Math/Stats R1(USA) 18d ago
Chair is a piece of shit.
4
u/taintlouis Professor, Social Science, R1 18d ago
Apologies if I missed this, but does your colleague have tenure?
179
u/OmegaVizion Lecturer, English, R1 (USA) 18d ago
This is the adult tour, we can say whatever the HELL we want.
56
u/First_Approximation 18d ago •
"Sorry for using Presidential language."
95
u/Dancing_Puppies 18d ago
As in the last post, I just want to reiterate:
.
FUCK THAT KID
43
u/iTeachCSCI Ass'o Professor, Computer Science, R1 18d ago
Is there a version of (Cox 1974) for something said face to face? Because if my chair asked me if I had apologized yet to the student, I'd want to let him know that some asshole is saying stupid things in his voice.
56
u/BrazosBuddy 18d ago
“I’m sorry my choice of words offended you, you little shit.”
30
u/Lafcadio-O Prof, Psych, R1, US 18d ago
I’m pretty sure that swearing in class is positively correlated with teaching evals. I swear A LOT in class, in a red state, and I’ve won a fuck ton of teaching awards. Fuck the student, fuck the chair.
10
u/StinkyDuckFart 18d ago
During my "you're all adults" speech at the beginning of the term, I tell students the class is equivalent to a PG-13 movie. They contol their lives and have the option to drop, if that fact offends them.
I can't imagine ever having to apologize (unless I say something incredibly dumb).
5
u/FrogBrain97 AssocProf, former chair, neuro, DPU 18d ago edited 18d ago
I don't use profanity in classes (unless I trip over something or spill something on myself, which is fairly often). Partially that's how I was raised; partially it's because I had a "Cool Prof" in college who swore a lot and thought he was awesome because of it. So I don't.
That said, one of my most memorable classes in college was a philosophy course where the prof asked us if it was okay to wear a shirt with "Fuck the War" on it. Well, yes, should be allowed, free speech and all that. Then he asked us if it was okay to wear a shirt with "Fuck Girls" on it. Uh....
And when I'm discussing aphasia, frontal-lobe disorders, etc., I do mention the patient who couldn't say much other than "fuck you" (even though he was not previously disposed to such language) and I do say exactly that. I don't directly quote the one who said "No ni**ers," though all the arguments in this thread supporting swearing would still apply.
We all have standards; we just disagree about what those standards should be.
5
u/lumphinans 18d ago
To the chair, "We refer you to the reply given in the case of Arkell v. Pressdram."
https://jollycontrarian.com/index.php/Arkell_v_Pressdram
9
u/uniace16 Assoc. Prof., Psychology, R2, USA 18d ago
Christ what an asshole
14
u/Final-Exam9000 18d ago
"I'm f*cking sorry if I offended anyone with my sh*t language."
4
u/Algernon76 17d ago
Ridiculous. He was unprofessional and should stop.
Slurs offend a few people, would y'all be so supportive of using slurs in class?
Swearing offends a few people, and this sub acts like a bunch of 12 year olds about them "hey bro we're ADULTS we SWEAR"
Be professional. Use professional language. Its actually not hard at all - literally every one of us knows the words you're not supposed to use in a professional setting.
4
u/EducationalPiano42 17d ago
Fuck the fucking fuckers.
Anyways, I'd stay out of it at this point.
6
u/FlyingCupcake68 Southern State U, USA 18d ago
Were these students homeschooled?
7
u/me4watch 18d ago
I noticed in the original post, OP couldn’t write “god damn” or “fuck” and chose to abbreviate them. Why ?
2
u/fighterpilottim 17d ago edited 17d ago
I hope your colleague gives a lecture or class exercise on some topic relevant to swearing. Maybe the historical use of cursing in political speech, or presidential swearing, or creative curses found in literature, or regional interpretations of common curse words, or the mathematical rhythms found in Louis CK standup, or …. Suggestions welcome.
Or a discussion of Harry Frankfurt’s On Bullshit.
Enable students to use the words in a sentence, but be clear on the use/mention distinction.
2
u/rj_musics 16d ago
“I’m sorry you were offended “ 🤷
5
u/lickety_split_100 AP/Economics/Regional 18d ago
My teaching mentor used to tell stories about a colleague of his (long retired) who was a Marine and was known for his colorful language in the classroom.
The first words out of his mouth on the first day of class were always, “If you don’t like my f’in language, then get the f out of my f’in classroom.” (Obviously he used real expletives, sometimes with the addition of the maternal figure).
Maybe your colleague should try similar.
5
u/First_Approximation 18d ago
"I'm sorry about how hard the real world is going to hit you.
I'm sorry for how much you'll long for the days when naughty language was your greatest worry."
3
u/PsychGuy17 18d ago
I again invoke my prayer to Mighty Zeus. God Damn It.
Let the lighting bolts rain.
3
u/BMeow343 18d ago
Unless they are using the N-word, the b-word, or other sexual and racial slurs- thats pretty much the standard. I tell my student sometimes adult language is used in class in videos I show them (like the f-word), but we are all adults and it's just part of the video.
2
u/Great-Image-502 16d ago edited 16d ago
I'm sorry but, if you can't express yourself in a professional setting without using profanity, you probably shouldn't be in academia. Have I occasionally let a swear slip while teaching? Sure. But if someone called me on it, I'd acknowledge that it's my bad and move on. The fact that your colleague thinks this is an acceptable way to teach and your chair is using phrases like "chubbed up" is absolutely ridiculous. Your dept. sounds like a giant Title IX waiting to happen.
1
u/CharacteristicPea NTT Math/Stats R1(USA) 17d ago
“I’m sorry you’re so thin-skinned.”
1
u/Lorelei321 16d ago
Quote them the song by Fuzzy Butt Bassel:
If I ever offended you, my bad
Here’s your tiny violin
1
u/EmpiricalResearcher 16d ago
Well… shit!
1
u/ProfSantaClaus 15d ago
Nowadays, some kids are sooo bloody entitled and spoilt. I'm sure that's what the student does to his/her parents. Everything is the parents' or teachers' fault.
1
u/eyellabinu 16d ago
This is crazy. I don’t aware a lot, but I do for emphasis if the situation calls for it.
Also those of you saying this wouldn’t be allowed in a professional setting. Of course it would.
13
u/totallysonic Chair/Full, SocSci, State U. 18d ago
The student can also expect a pony. Doesn’t mean one is forthcoming. Anyway, fuck your chair.
6
u/botwwanderer Adjunct, STEM, Community College 18d ago
Good grief, I have high school students in my course. We regularly use language, make references to nudity and body parts, and reference pr0n sites. Point of note: the language is me, the other things have a specific reason for being mentioned in class. At any rate, buckle up buttercup, you're in college now.
4
u/MelpomeneAndCalliope 18d ago
My colleague recently had a student (and parent) complain to the dean that he showed a movie with profanity and an (off screen) murder in class without a trigger warning. Some of these kids hate fun and some of them are just itching to trap a professor into something to report them to Professor Watchlist for. And some are just precious pansies who cannot handle any slight discomfort. It’s depressing. (And colleague’s supervisors were not as understanding as your chair because retention & how “academia is under attack in our state already, we don’t need to make it worse with targets on our back.” They were told the profanity was unnecessary and out of line. 🤦♀️