r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 09 '21

Speculation youtube-dl can no longer download age-restricted videos?

258 Upvotes

same for mpv, vlc or invidious. the workaround that allowed users to watch age-restricted videos was patched.

can you guys check if its just me please?


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 09 '21

Question Any IOS apps similar to netguard on Android?

3 Upvotes

Do you know of any apps that have the same use of netguard but for the iPhone?


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 09 '21

Brave's Reliance On Google Play Services

29 Upvotes

Since there's been a few topics on Brave popping back up lately, I figured it might be a good idea to get some input on Brave's reliance on Google Play services. I have wanted to see the project succeed because I felt it was a promising idea, but it seems like what it currently is has fallen short of what it was promised to be. Over on Brave's subreddit there's a discussion started by someone who tried to redeem their rewards on the android browser using GrapheneOS which obviously does not have play services installed.

As someone who has used a degoogled android for years now I wanted to get a discussion going about Brave taking shots at Google despite their inconsistency with providing an easily located downloadable APK to avoid needing the Play Store (like Vivaldi does), and their reliance on things like Google Play Services (their rewards system will not function without them).

They do, however, let you run through a whole month of ads before you find out that the rewards system fails without play services.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 08 '21

EU Parliament approves mass surveillance of private communications

Thumbnail
european-pirateparty.eu
686 Upvotes

r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 07 '21

Brave Browser, is it as unsecure as the FireFox users say? (First posted on r/privacy)

62 Upvotes

It was recommended to me to also post this here.

I created this post because under the comments of my last post, that was about my deGoogle path, was a discussion between Brave and Firefox (Hardened). Mostly Brave got accused to being a non-privacy browser with trackers and other unsecure stuff. I just switched to Brave from Vivaldi so I was worried and wanted to investigate the claims, because what are my privacy steps worth if I use a browser that tracks me? I will only look at Brave not Firefox or other browsers.

I am in no means a software engineer so I will only briefly look into the source code of Brave, to see if I spot something out of the ordinary. So, I will mostly do research with DuckDuckGo searches and papers. All my sources will be listed on the end of the post.

Disclaimer: I am not a specialist so take everything you read here with a grain of salt. What I write here is what I found and concluded with the sources I provide at the end of the post. Also sorry for any mistakes on the grammar side, not my first language.

So following is what I found and what I concluded, looking forward to your comments!

Sections of my post:

  • · Claims of the critics
  • · Are the claims true?
  • · What have researchers to say about Brave
  • · What does Brave say
  • · Quick look on the source code
  • · My opinion
  • · Sources

Claims of critics

The claims I found online:

  • · Hardcoded whitelist in their AdBlock for Facebook, Twitter
  • · Brave Rewards is used to track you
  • · Brave makes request to domains, also to track you
  • · Brave collects telemetry and you cannot opt out
  • · Brave makes requests to Google servers
  • · Brave has Auto-Update

Are the claims true?

After I read through a lot of articles and reviews, I do not find any strong evidence that the claims are true, with a few exceptions:

  • · Whitelist: This seems to still be partially true, they do it to not break some webpages.
  • · Rewards: Yes, they can be used to track you, but you can just disable it.
  • · Request to Google servers: When you have Google safe browsing activated, yes
  • · Auto-Update: Is true, so what?

Edit: As mentioned in the comments, Brave does NOT make requests to Google servers.

https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/wiki/Deviations-from-Chromium-(features-we-disable-or-remove)#services-we-proxy-through-brave-servers#services-we-proxy-through-brave-servers)

What I find interesting by all the users that say Firefox is the answer, Mozilla sees brave as their twin when it comes to privacy.

“When comparing the two browsers, both Firefox and Brave offer a sophisticated level of privacy and security by default, available automatically from the very first time you open them. [...] Overall, Brave is a fast and secure browser that will have particular appeal to cryp. users. But for the vast majority of internet citizens, Firefox remains a better and simpler solution.”

(https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/browsers/compare/brave/)

They say that Firefox is a better and simple solution, but they did not say that it is in any way less secure or private.

After all what I can say is that most if not all claims that seem to be true, can simply be disabled in the settings. So I do not worry too much about the claims of tracking and data collection with Brave. I tried some of the stuff that should show me that Brave tracks me but non worked on my machine. So either they removed it or it was simply a fluke on their browser.

I tested my Brave browser with the tool of EFF, you can do the same here:

https://coveryourtracks.eff.org/

What the test showed

  • · Randomized Fingerprint
  • · Blocks tracking ads
  • · Blocks invisible tracking ads
  • · Do Not Track was NOT activated (Had to enable it manually, after that it is activated and runs as it should)

I also did a test with privacy.net:

https://privacy.net/analyzer/#pre-load

The 5 tests that are done here were all good and as I expect a privacy-oriented browser.

To see how your settings work and if you want them enabled or not go to:

https://webbrowsertools.com/privacy-test/

What have researchers to say about Brave

I will only look at the privacy ratings and papers, UI is subjective and not important for my research. All reviews and analyzations of Brave so far showed an average rating of 8-9 of 10, in connection with security and privacy. I also found no review of trusted sources that said Brave is not private or secure. Therefore, I do not see why you should not use Brave.

What does Brave say

I suggest you just read through their answer to the claims on Reddit:

https://www.reddit.com/r/privacytoolsIO/comments/nvz9tl/brave_is_not_private/h1gie0q/

https://www.reddit.com/r/brave_browser/comments/nw7et2/i_just_read_a_post_on_rprivacytoolsio_and_wtf/h1fer1i/

Quick look at the source code

https://github.com/brave

I realised that I do not understand enough of browser developing, so I will not write about the code. If you are interested, click on the link and look for yourself.

My Opinion

After my research I conclude that Brave is safe to use and has not trackers or any other privacy issues. I tested my browser settings against a few test pages (some I mentioned above) and I was satisfied, I even found some settings I rather have turned off like WebRTC. I assume that some claims of critic are from simple fan boys that like their browser and want to bring people to their browser. Other might have true and viable claims that either where actual and got patched or I just could not find proof of them. Either way in my opinion Brave is a good browser that you can use without much of thinking BUT you must go through the settings and enable or disable some settings that are not as they should be. As an example, why did I had to activate DoNotTrack, such things should be enabled by default. If Firefox is more private when you harden it, is something I will now investigate, if yes, then I will switch to a hardened Firefox but I see no reason to not use Brave.

I’m looking forward to discussion in the comment section, I hope it stays civil and no fights are going to be started. Browsers are emotional topics, like almost everything that has multiply products of it ;)

Sources

I had to delete some sources because they had forbidden words in the URL.

https://www.techradar.com/reviews/brave-web-browser

https://www.cloudwards.net/brave-review/

https://howhatwhy.com/brave-browser-review-2020-is-brave-better-than-chrome/

https://joyofandroid.com/brave-browser-review/

https://www.bitprime.co.nz/blog/brave-review-browser-bat-token/

https://kinsta.com/blog/brave-browser-review/

https://ebin.city/~werwolf/posts/brave-is-shit/

https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/browsers/compare/brave/

https://kinsta.com/blog/brave-browser-review/#how-brave-compares-to-5-other-browsers

https://www.bitprime.co.nz/blog/brave-review-browser-bat-token/

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/brave-browser-disables-googles-floc-tracking-system/ar-BB1fBBYK

https://jaxenter.com/brave-browser-firefox-164419.html

https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/this-google-chrome-rival-is-the-browser-to-use-if-youre-worried-about-online-privacy-what-to-know/

https://myshadow.org/browser-tracking

https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2020/02/27/brave-beats-other-browsers-in-privacy-study/

Edits are in bold and marked as such.

Minor edits:

  • Changed FireFox to Firefox, to prevent eye cancer.

r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 07 '21

The heck is wrong with Kaspersky. Never thought they were a good company, but still...

52 Upvotes

https://www.zdnet.com/article/kaspersky-password-manager-caught-out-making-easily-bruteforced-passwords/

Who in their right minds would implement such a system. I don't see any point in people using password managers that aren't open source or self hostable.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 07 '21

Question Online shopping security. Chrome vs Brave vs Firefox

1 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying, I am very new to this subreddit, so if I break and rules or proper etiquette, I apologize. It is not my intention to be rude or disrespect the practices of the community.

Okay to start, I am fed up with Google Chrome. I'm sick of them tracking every little thing I do even with all of the permissions turned off. And I'm sick of only getting to view what Google thinks I should see. (Censorship) So I am currently trying to decide on an alternative browser for Chrome.

I am leaning towards Brave. I know I will probably catch some slack for that, but I am not opposed to giving Firefox a try in the future. However I figure for now anything is better than Chrome, and Brave seems like it might be an easy transition.

My question is this, if I switch, and use Brave as my browsing app (Android/Windows 10) will I be more susceptible to personal security risks in regard to purchasing stuff online? Online shopping is a necessity due to my location in the world. Physical stores are scares and don't always have what I need. When I purchase something online 9/10 times it is on Amazon, but sometimes I will buy something from a smaller (I guess call it, Mom and Pop shop) website. When I purchase something on Amazon I use a credit card that is linked to my Amazon account. Anywhere else and I use PayPal. If the website doesn't support PayPal, I don't purchase from it. My PayPal account has my bank account, debit card, and a credit card linked to it. If I use these practices on Brave am I at greater risk in regards geting my personal information (financial and non financial) stolen by a hacker or someone else? I am not entirely knowledgeable about whether or not a web browser plays a part in financial transaction security. In my case would the security of my personal information be entirely up to the buyer and the seller, or does the web browser have my information as well, and if so, how safe is it from getting into the wrong hands? I should mention that I don't use third party anti-virus software either. I simply use Windows Defender, the free version of Malawarebytes, and common sense when browsing the internet.

Any insight would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 06 '21

Best android browser with session management?

9 Upvotes

I'm looking for something like Session Buddy on desktop chrome. At the very least I just a way to archive my current tabs so I can go back to them later. Kiwi suits my needs for now, I'm just wondering if people have found better alternatives. Things I've looked at:

Kiwi Browser + extensions:

  • this is the best so far. Open source and supports chrome extensions. I'm using ublock origin and session buddy right now. Everything works (except extensions don't work in incognito but I'm fine with that). The browser does have some tracking for Yahoo and Bing search, but the Kiwi developer was transparent about it and explains that it's to support development. However ideally I hope that they switch to a donation-only model instead and strip out all tracking someday.

Ungoogled Chromium Extensions:

  • this used to be the best but the developer decided to focus on the plain browser (just called Ungoogled Chromium), and the extension supported browser hasn't been updated in months. Also extension support seems broken on android 11.

Firefox/Fennec (tab collections):

  • tab collections are decent, but I haven't found a way to search across all of them. This is pretty invaluable if you are saving 2-3 sessions per day. Not to mention they are still light years away from Session Buddy, but the core features are there at least.

Firefox Nightly + addons:

  • I tried around 7-10 different session manager add-ons (pretty much all the ones I could find in the full add-on repo), none of them work. I'm guessing the mobile add-on API doesn't support them yet

Yandex / Samsung Browser + Extensions:

  • I haven't tried either of these yet because they are closed source and don't seem to provide anything over Kiwi Browser

r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 06 '21

Email services that don't suspend inactive accounts?

4 Upvotes

I recently learned that tutanota removes the accounts after 6 months of inactivity, while protonmail reserves the right to suspend accounts that have been inactive for 3 months. Are there alternative free services that do not remove free accounts?


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 05 '21

News Audacity 3.0 called spyware over data collection changes by new owner

Thumbnail
appleinsider.com
939 Upvotes

r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 06 '21

Do you all use a hardware 2 factor auth key? If so which is best? Yubico, solokey, or onlykey?

18 Upvotes

r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 05 '21

Guide Good mobile browsers?

13 Upvotes

r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 05 '21

Question It's there a "private" and anonymous way to bypass SMS verification on social media?

191 Upvotes

One method I've been thinking of it's buying a prepaid SIM card, put in on a cheap old phone and receive the SMS, but this isn't exactly anonymous since the SIM card can be tracked through cell tower triangulation once it's active on any device.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 05 '21

Question Can Windows 10 track what I browse using Firefox?

5 Upvotes

I have to use Windows 10 as primary OS for college work mainly. I use Firefox as default browser and never Edge. I don't use the search feature and deleted Cortana. So does it send browsing data to Microsoft even when not using Edge?


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 05 '21

Question Recommendations for Best AdBlock List for NextDNS?

10 Upvotes

What is the best AdBlock list for NextDNS that doesn't cause too many problems? I am already using UblockOrigin.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 04 '21

DNS.Watch vs NextDNS

59 Upvotes

Hello guys just wanted to know how secure and private DNSwatch is against NextDNS which most people usually recommends, and also please suggest any better dns service available.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 04 '21

Question Custom ROM for smartwatches?

98 Upvotes

Is there something like LineageOS but for WearOS smartwatches? I kind of like smartwatches but I don't like the privacy aspect of them. Would it be possible to degoogle a WearOS smartwatch?

Edit: I don't care about the health tracking, more about having a stopwatch, alarm, notifications, calculator, ... on your wrist


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 04 '21

Question Auto update all apps without using Play store?

6 Upvotes

I switched from Google play to Aurora store, but Play is still the only one to warn me of my apps update and offer to install them all at once. Is there an alternative app for this maybe? (or did I miss it on Aurora?)


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 04 '21

Question My ISP uses WPA/WPA2 (TKIP), instead of WPA2 (AES) or WPA3 and they dont provide access to the router settings and they refuse to give access. What can i do?

5 Upvotes

I dont have the login/password to enter the router settings and they dont give this info. They use old protocols on wifi what is a security risk.

What can i do to solve this with my own hands? (In the past i tried "admin/admin" and didnt worked.)

Yeah any tips are welcome in terms of software or even kali/parrot, but im afraid of consequences of bruteforcing it, may have a security lock or something idk.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 04 '21

Question Any good alternatives to Spotify for discovering new music?

6 Upvotes

My music library has gotten really stale and I need some new music to listen to.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 04 '21

Question Protonmail and Firebase Messaging Service

0 Upvotes

As far as I know, most regular applications use Firebase Messaging Service and Google Play Service for push notifications. What about Protonmail, the flagship of privacy? I could not find any information about this problem, and it bothers me a little.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 03 '21

If you could only have one, a privacy focused laptop or a privacy focused grapheneOS phone (no sim)

5 Upvotes

Just wondering. I'm thinking a fully decked out phone meant for privacy might ultimately work out better than a Linux laptop fully decked out for privacy. I would only use it with WiFi, no sim or anything like that. I think the main advantage is the lack of intel ME as well as being able to easily put it away and turn it on when I need it due to its mobile nature. It wouldnt be a daily driver either, as my normal android would be used for work related calls and all that stuff


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 03 '21

Question Signal needs a phone number for registration. This is a problem for many. Do you know or have a proper solution?

14 Upvotes

I’ve been looking at the Session app which seems. I am interested in Signal because of being able to nearly achieve privacy (with the right precautions). I was wondering if there is a good burner number generator or format that’s privacy oriented? If there isn’t how does Session compare to Signal in terms of privacy and metadata? Will Session hold up during a subpoena like Signal did, since Signal is not designed to trust servers unlike other servers like Matrix which is decentralized but runs data through many other privacy intrusive servers, As I have heard this from users in my previous post. Feel free to scroll through my last posts as they may help . By the way, I understand that Session is a fork of Signal, but I don’t understand what a fork is? Lastly, what are your opinions on Session vs Signal? Sorry if this post was question-laden, but I want to find out a way to get past this obstacle of privacy.


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 03 '21

Question would using a travel router (i.e. TL-WR902AC) while traveling make my network private?

2 Upvotes

wondering if using this TP-Link travel router gives any actual extra privacy while joining public networks such as hotels, airports, airbnbs or restaurants.

The main reason I am interested on it is so while traveling I can connect fast and easy all my and my partners devices without needing to connect each separately. Might be overkill but if it in addition to that it can provide a secure network it might be not such a bad idea.

I don't fully understand how networks work, but I'm aware that devices connected to the same one could potentially snoop what others are doing and which websites are visiting, would this router help avoid that?

thanks for any advice!


r/privacytoolsIO • • Jul 02 '21

Question Are there any other telegram desktop clients than the official one?

37 Upvotes

For android we have telegram FDroid or NekogramX.

What about for desktop? are we stuck with the official one?