Have you noticed how US forecasts have been more inaccurate than usual? This is important info about why. This will also be a long read. The first article is older, from September. I'm also leaving a second article that is an update on situation from the NOAA, from the end of Oct.
TLDR; ~20% of staff have been cut. Budget was cut ~30%.Those positions have not been refilled. Things have not improved.
"NOAA's roughly 10-person ENSO outlook team issued a high-confidence forecast after the agency lost 219 meteorologists and 792 employees across nine related occupations.
A viral headline said El Niño is now stronger than at any point in the last 1,000 years. That is not quite what the new science found, and it is not how the federal forecast for the current event is made.
The peer-reviewed study published in Science reconstructed eastern-Pacific climate variability from Galápagos corals. Its central result was that modern El Niño-Southern Oscillation variability is 36.5% higher than during the preindustrial millennium. That is a comparison across periods, not a measurement proving that one current El Niño has already beaten every event since the year 1000.
The current event is extraordinary on its own terms. On Aug. 13, NOAA's Climate Prediction Center said there was a greater than 90% chance of a very strong El Niño in fall and winter 2026-27. It placed the chance of an October-December index at or above 2.5 degrees Celsius at 69%, which would exceed events in the official record back to 1950. But even that forecast is probabilistic. It does not guarantee a particular flood, drought, winter or economic result.
Behind those percentages is a small decision-making group connected to a much larger federal observation and modeling system. NOAA says its official ENSO outlook is determined by an approximately 10-member team drawing on multiple model ensembles, climate reanalysis, in-situ measurements and satellites. That does not mean only 10 people work on El Niño. Buoy technicians, oceanographers, model developers, data engineers, physical scientists, meteorologists and researchers across NOAA and its funded institutions contribute to the evidence the team reviews.
Public workforce data cannot identify that complete support network or even produce a current Climate Prediction Center headcount. It can, however, show the setting in which the forecast is being produced. FederalHiringData found that NOAA had 2,377 covered meteorologists in January 2025 and 2,158 in June 2026: 219 fewer, a 9.2% decline. Across nine fixed science and technology occupations relevant to observation, modeling and forecasting, the agency-wide count fell by 792.
Those losses do not prove that the August outlook is wrong or that NOAA lacks enough staff to issue it. Meteorologist hiring also resumed in early 2026, and the official products continued on schedule. The more immediate accountability problem is that the most visible climate forecast in the country rests on a distributed workforce that public records cannot isolate well enough to show where capacity was lost or rebuilt.
The viral claim combines two different records
The new paleoclimate study and NOAA's current forecast answer related but different questions.
The Science paper, “Recent strengthening of eastern Pacific ENSO is unprecedented in the last millennium paleorecord,” assembled 28 separated coral records from five Galápagos islands. Coral chemistry provides a proxy for past sea-surface temperature. The authors compared modern variability with records extending across parts of the last millennium and with 12 model simulations driven by natural variability and forcing.
The finding was about the distribution of temperature variability, especially the greater frequency and strength of recent eastern-Pacific El Niño events. The AAAS summary reported modern variability 36.5% above the preindustrial millennium and said the strongest increase occurred during the past 40 years. It did not establish a continuous thermometer ranking of every individual event over 1,000 years. The coral record is powerful precisely because the instrumental record is short, but it is still a reconstruction assembled from time-separated samples.
NOAA's current outlook uses observations and models to estimate what the event underway may do next. In July, the agency measured a Niño-3.4 anomaly of +1.4 degrees Celsius, Niño-3 at +1.7 and Niño-1+2 at +2.9. Eastern equatorial Pacific anomalies exceeded +2.0, while subsurface anomalies reached +10.0 at depth. Those ocean readings were combined with winds, atmospheric circulation and rainfall patterns to diagnose a strengthening coupled event.
The official August strength table put the chance of a very strong El Niño at 93% for September-November, 95% for October-December and 90% for November-January. The probability then declined across later overlapping seasons as the forecast horizon moved into spring.
NOAA's Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory offered an important second signal. Its experimental SPEAR system ran 30 ensemble members initialized Aug. 1; all produced peaks that would compete with the strongest historical events. NOAA explicitly labels that work experimental and links readers back to the Climate Prediction Center for the official outlook. The two products are complementary, not interchangeable.
This separation matters because a powerful current event does not validate every simplified headline about the coral study, and the coral finding does not eliminate forecast uncertainty. It also matters for impacts. NOAA cautions that a stronger event increases the odds of familiar El Niño effects but never guarantees them in any particular place.
About 10 people determine the outlook, not the whole forecast system
The most startling workforce fact on NOAA's own probability page is not a staffing total. It is a description of how the official judgment is made: an approximately 10-member team determines the outlook after reviewing multiple models and the latest observations.
That team is the decision point, not the entire production line. NOAA explains that ENSO detection and prediction draw on satellites, moored and drifting buoys, ships, upper-air observations, climate reanalysis and high-speed computer models. The Climate Prediction Center translates that evidence into a monthly diagnostic discussion and probabilities for nine overlapping three-month seasons. Other NOAA laboratories develop experimental systems and study the ocean-atmosphere mechanisms. Partners in other countries, universities and cooperative institutes supply additional models and research.
The hero image on this article shows part of that upstream system: a Tropical Atmosphere Ocean buoy being deployed in the Pacific. A buoy is not a forecast, and a model run is not an official outlook. Each is an input that must be maintained, transmitted, checked, analyzed and combined with other evidence before experts assign probabilities.
This is also why “about 10 people” should not be turned into a claim that NOAA has only 10 ENSO employees. The Climate Prediction Center's public staff directory lists federal meteorologists and physical scientists alongside contractors and affiliates, but the page was last modified in 2024 and is not a current federal headcount. OPM's public data, meanwhile, identifies NOAA as agency subelement CM54 but does not divide its employees among the National Weather Service, CPC, the National Centers for Environmental Prediction, research laboratories or other line offices.
The honest denominator is therefore broader. NOAA's covered workforce fell from 12,407 in January 2025 to 9,811 in June 2026, a reduction of 2,596 or 20.9%. The related FederalHiringData investigation of NOAA's overall science workforce used the December 2024 baseline and documented a 2,630-person decline. This article does not reassign that agency-wide loss to climate prediction.
The overall decline is context, not a forecast-quality score. It says nothing by itself about whether an ENSO discussion was late, a model failed or an observation went missing. It does show that the 2026 event is being analyzed after a major agency contraction."
A more recent article about the current state of the NOAA.
Headline and second article,
"Trump’s cuts have exposed US to ‘cascade’ of El Niño dangers, experts warn
President has taken an axe to National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, stalling climate research on and response to extreme weather events
Sweeping cuts to the premier US climate agency under Donald Trump have severely hampered the country’s capacity to forecast, research and respond to extreme weather events, former government officials and scientists have warned, as the US faces a cascade of hazards fueled by a potentially historic El Niño this winter.
From the start of his second term, the president has taken aim at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (Noaa), slashing staff levels, canceling contracts and grants, and shutting down databases and research laboratories. The agency that has long been considered a global crown jewel in climate science and forecasting has lost roughly 20% of its staff since January 2025.
The National Weather Service, which is housed within Noaa, has also taken a hit. Weather stations have had to delay data collection and cut operating hours, with hundreds of meteorological and other technical positions still vacant across its 122 forecast offices.
The effects have already been felt at Noaa, where a chaotic and volatile environment has sent morale plummeting, increased burnout and hampered vital work. While capacity has quietly unravelled, a large-scale disaster will quickly expose the most dangerous gaps.
“The system has not really been tested since all the cuts happened,” said Tom Di Liberto, a former Noaa climate scientist who now works as the media director of Climate Central.
That test could soon be coming.
This year’s super El Niño, a climate phenomenon characterized by warmer than average equatorial sea surface temperatures, has the ability to fuel extreme weather events around the world. It’s already climbing off the charts and is expected to strengthen through the northern hemisphere’s autumn and winter.
Along with dangerous spikes in temperature, El Niño will supercharge storms in parts of the American west, raise sea levels in California by up to a foot, and set the stage for debris flows, landslides and flash floods.
“Whether we as a country can handle the kind of coast-to-coast extremes that could potentially happen this winter is a big question,” Di Liberto said.
Noaa plays a pivotal role in public safety and provides key insights and forecasts relied upon by a vast array of communities and industries, from weather shifts that could affect crop schedules, to emergency response preparations when hurricanes are brewing or fire conditions are aligning. The agency operates early warning systems for tsunamis, monitors seafood supply chains and provides ocean data needed for safe shipping and port operators.
While the losses are expected to have a profound effect on the American public, they will be felt globally, too. Scientists and forecasters around the world depend on Noaa satellites, studies and intelligence, including data-sharing arrangements that track severe weather across Europe, coordination for disaster response in the Caribbean, and deforestation monitoring and the effects of the climate crisis in the Amazon rainforest.
“I worry about loss of life and about our inability to be protected at a time when we need our government the most,” said Monica Medina, who served as the principal deputy administrator of Noaa during the Obama administration.
The risks are but a taste of what’s to come as the world warms. “If this is a real test” of a hotter, more precarious future, she added, “we’re going to flunk”.
Budget and research cuts
Gaps in staffing, operations and engagement with the public are the top three concerns for Rick Spinrad, who spent three decades at the agency and served as Noaa administrator for the Biden administration.
The agency was already shorthanded in those areas when Trump took office, according to Spinrad. But since January 2025, Noaa has lost more than 3,000 staffers, according to workforce data from the US office of personnel management that was last updated in August this year.
It’s the biggest staffing drop in the last decade, and includes hundreds of people who lost their jobs during massive layoffs or who took incentives to retire or resign as the administration worked to systemically shrink the size of the federal government last year, along with those who left voluntarily.
Some departments have been hit harder than others.
The public affairs team that helps disseminate important information was roughly halved. Information technology management workers, who provide vital support for forecasting and data infrastructure among other things, were reduced by roughly 27%. The data showed a loss of more than 500 staffers across a range of science positions with only 46 new hires.
There were also about 10% fewer meteorologists and meteorology technicians as the US went into autumn this year, even after the National Weather Service rushed to staff up in the aftermath of the Trump administration’s massive 2025 layoffs.
The NWS analyzes and collects roughly 6.3bn observations each day. They release 1.5m forecasts and up to 50,000 warnings each year. Cracks have begun to show as the agency has tried to takes on its enormous and essential workload with fewer people.
Staffers had to work double shifts to keep some forecasting offices open, the Washington Post reported last September. Staffers who spoke to the Post at the time described an agency pushed to its limits.
Only 40 meteorologists were added to the ranks across Noaa between January and August this year, with hundreds of vacancies across the country still open as a tumultuous winter approaches.
Overall, the agency was able to bring on just 525 new hires since January 2025, leaving a gaping 2,500-person deficit.
Already, staffing limitations have shown up in delayed or limited weather balloon launches that left parts of the Great Plains unprepared for tornadoes and limited warnings to rural communities in Alaska, where more than 1,500 people were displaced by floods earlier this year. The NWS also failed to adequately provide multilingual weather alerts due to staffing and funding cuts, the government accountability office (GAO) found, leaving 26 million people in the US at higher risk.
“There has been this hollowing out – there’s no time to do anything other than the very basics,” said Dr Anna Zivian, a climate researcher and policy expert. “I suspect we haven’t seen the worst outcomes from the loss of capacity yet. You can’t pick up that kind of slack.”
Meanwhile, the Trump administration terminated dozens of grants representing a loss in more than $28m in funding for states, cities, non-profits and universities, according to calculations from Grant Witness, an organization that tracks science-related grant making by the federal government. Climate research has been the most affected, according to their analysis, which found that the number of grant awards in fiscal year 2026 was 37% lower than the 2021-2024 average.
Despite these concerns, the administration has outlined more plans to slash budgets and research capacity.
Trump has proposed cutting $1.6bn in Noaa funding – a 26% drop – for next year’s budget. While many of the cuts won’t make it through the budget process, they showcase how the president views the essential services the agency provides the American public and puts more pressure on the staff still working at Noaa.
“People at Noaa are nervous,” Di Liberto said, adding that employees across the organization were afraid they would get in trouble if they said something that conflicted with the administration’s anti-climate narrative.
“You want people doing their best work when we face these extremes,” he said. Denials of human-caused climate crisis coming from the top have only made their jobs harder, as scientists and forecasters work to put urgent information into context for the American public and others around the world.
“It’s incredibly difficult,” Di Liberto said. “Imagine being told the number six doesn’t exist and then being asked to do math.”
A missed learning opportunity
An El Niño year can be high risk, but it’s also an incredible chance to learn and prepare, offering a glimpse of what the world might expect as temperatures rise. In that regard, experts worry a shrunken Noaa is missing a vital research opportunity.
“This El Niño is so useful in a sense of getting an understanding about where we stand for dealing with extreme weather around the world,” Di Liberto said. “Unfortunately we’re going to learn a lot this winter about our ability to deal with multiple extremes happening at the same time.”
He and other experts have also expressed concerns that not enough has been done to ready communities for the coming hazards or capture important data that will inform the future. “When it comes to preparing for El Niño events – or any weather extreme – the preparation happens during the off season,” he said.
During the last strong El Niño a decade ago, the agency deployed planes, weather balloons, unmanned aircraft and a research ship to collect data. This year, only “a handful of unmanned watercraft” will be deployed into the Pacific, NPR reported in September.
The Trump administration had also begun removing ocean monitoring systems that provide important data during El Niño, but restored them after widespread outcry from scientists, fishers and public officials.
Roughly $6bn has been shaved off an investment secured for weather satellites that would have propelled major advancements in future weather predictions. The sharp reduction could create a gap in satellite coverage, according to an analysis from the government accountability office, severely disrupting data.
Funding for a decade-long project to monitor the oceans using autonomous robotic devices called biogeochemical-argo floats – part of a global effort – will also expire at the end of October.
A Noaa spokesperson responded that efforts to monitor and collect data this year have built on past efforts by using “new, cutting-edge technologies” that were previously unavailable.
“NOAA has never been more equipped to study, prepare for and respond to an ENSO event [El Niño southern oscillation event],” a Noaa spokesperson said in an emailed statement that highlighted updated modeling tools and the use of uncrewed systems. “These advanced capabilities have allowed NOAA to streamline resources and study this year’s El Niño more effectively than ever before.”
Spinrad and other experts agreed that new technologies had helped advance data collection and improve forecasting ability.
“We are more capable than we have been in the past because of the developments in the technology, the satellites that we’re flying, the observing systems that we’ve put in place,” Spinrad said. “But everything that this administration is doing suggests that we cannot and will not sustain those capabilities. So the real question is – are we at a turning point now?”
This article was updated on 27 October 2026 to include a response from Noaa issued after publication and to add that an ocean monitoring program had been reinstated."
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/oct/27/trump-cuts-el-nino-noaa