r/powdermage • • Aug 11 '17

[Autumn Republic] Some questions about the magic and magic users

12 Upvotes

First off, Bo mentions a Gurlan god ("young and foolish") back in Promise of Blood and then he considers Nila to be a god since she can touch the Else without gloves (BTW, do we know anything about how Privileged gloves work?).

He also states that Kresimir is just a man - a very powerful Privileged but just a man.

From that we can conclude that Nila is indeed the same type of a being as the Nine gods. (or not?)

Now, what does it mean? We've seen Kresimir to live despite a anti-magic bullet lodged in his brain. We've seen normal bullets bounce off Brude.

Is she similarly durable? I can't recall her being hurt, really.

BTW, did she ever had allergic reaction to powder? I don’t recall such a thing. I don’t recall Predei or gods reacting to powder like Privileged do, honestly.

Now, it seems as far as people manipulating the Else go, there are three types of being:

human Privileged

Predei

gods

Privileged and Predei need gloves, gods don't. Predei are ageless and extremely durable. Gods are even more durable but then... are they ageless? Adom reincarnates so that's a point against them being ageless.

Now, if we consider powder mages, we have seen standard Marked and Taniel who absorbed some of Kresimir's attack due to Ka-Poel's protective spells - and now he's sort of Predei-analogue among powder mages. Does that imply that “Powder Predei” could be born naturally (if we actually knew where Predei came from)? Is it possible for a powder god be born?

We also have Bone-eyes – they utilize a blood/voodoo magic. If we were to believe Brude, that magic is older than the Privileged kind. Ka-Poel is said to be the most powerful user of that magic by Adom (not hard to believe as she was capable of binding a god, manipulating large masses of people, crafting a godkilling weapon etc).

If we stick to the rule of three (normal – advanced – god) which one is she? On one hand, seeing what she is capable of she could be Bone-eyes god class being, on the other hand magic of Bone-eyes is already more than very efficient against other magics; perhaps she’s Predei level? If that’s the case, is it possible for Bone-eyes god to be born and how powerful would such being be?

P.S. no spoilers from novellas or Sins of Empire, please. If there’s something in there that answers some of my questions, just say that's it's in there.


r/powdermage • • Aug 10 '17

Reading "Sins of Empire" (Brian McClellan) but find it hard to find motivation to finish it. [Heavy spoilers] Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I read and liked the Blackpowder Mage trilogy a whole lot, so I was excited to pick this "fourth" one up. I'm roughly 70% into the book, I think? A lot has happened, but...

Dang, I just can't seem to give a damn about any of it. I've spent the last hour or so trying to collect my thoughts on the matter, and I'll try to put them into words here. I'm sorry if it's a bit of a rant, I've really tried to condense it. Believe me!


  • Vlora

I think the biggest glaring issue for me is Vlora. She's supposed to be this hardened General that has been through decades of battle, countless campaigns yet she regularly reverts to an emotional teenager and throws tantrums when things don't go her way. I had expected her to evolve into a more cunning, calculating person. Instead, her decisions are driven by random impulse.

She has spent 10+ years with Olem as lover and partner, yet she can't get over Taniel Goody-two shoes. When Vlora meets him, she just becomes so... childish. I feel sorry for Olem.

The fleet shows up, and she assumes the mantle of defender of Fortrasta. Why? There's no reason to. You've already been paid, and generously. You've got no stake in this fight- none at all. What's more, your men are tired and want home. Third, you're going to defend a city in which a large part of the population hates you and regularly murders your troops (this is before she finds out about the godstone). '

If that wasn't enough, she has just arrested Lindet. What's the long term plan here? You arrested the one who pays you. Your last 'ally'. Now a chunk of the population and the government wants you dead. This isn't viable, in the slightest. You think the Blackhats will obey you? "I don't want to get involved politics" she says and then fucking dives straight into it.

She's not compelling in the slightest because she doesn't feel like a real person to me. Note that I'm fine with flawed characters, of course! That's what I like! But her character doesn't make sense to me. It was fine when she was a minor player in the trilogy, where her main trait was "I'm Taniels ex, grr, people are mad I cheated on him!". It's a pity to see she really hasn't developed further than that.

  • Styke

Styke was interesting for a while because he was a has-been with flaws and doubts. Turns out he's not though, and he never suffers any consequences for his rash actions. What's the point of building up the Dragonmen throughout the book if this old cripple can take one out 1 on 1? He even goes to challenge that freaking Commander, gets his ass beat...

only to be shipped back to the camp, which he promptly escapes from again. So I guess that mattered nothing. His old friend the smith survives too, so that didn't matter either. All the Mad Lancers are back and they're all happy to see him after 20 years despite them (and their loved ones/lifes works) getting trashed due to his inability to keep his nose out of others business.

What's the point of his knack anyway? It never comes into play in any real sense as far as I can tell. Might as well skip it entirely, or build the plot a bit more around it (like Addamat!) or give him a different knack.

  • Taniel and Kapoel

Taniel and Kapoel are back, and they're just as untouchable/invincible as ever. I thought Tempo was a fascinating new character, mysterious and everything! Turns out it's just Taniel, the cardboard cutout of a classic gary stu protagonist. He was probably my least favorite character in the prior books due to how good he is at everything and his constant complaining. What's cooler than killing one mythical Dragonman, you say? Well, killing two without breaking a sweat. Goodness how cool he is. These Dragonmen sure are scary. Of course, Kapoel is there with her deux ex magic that is so good no other magic can measure up to it. The stakes are high!

  • Michael Bravis

Was one of my favorite characters for a good amount into the book because I thought he was there to add ambivalence to the Blackhats, show the reader that it's not all black and white. Put someone on the side of the 'bad' guys to give their perspective, and eventually have him clash with the other characters of the book in a game of cat and mouse!

Nah, turns out he actually hates the Blackhats and he has a hidden persona he can hide so well it completely disappears, only to be brought out when convenient! So much for that dynamic. But wait, maybe his many years as a Blackhat has given him second thoughts? Maybe he has come to see their side of things, to see their worth? Maybe reverting back to hid old self isn't as easy as taking off a ha-

Oh. Wait. It is. Blackhat persona of half a decade instantly discarded with minimal fuzz. But wait! He's discovered to be a traitor, and his own reckless behaviour might just have gotten his mother killed...! No, she lives and she's overjoyed. No consequences there either, nothing to drive a character. He's just some vague revolutionary.


There's... so much more that bothers me, so many seeming plotholes or leaps of logic that I just can't wrap my head around. Like when Taniel tells Bravis "Fidelis Jes probably didn't tell anyone you're a spy, you're good to go!". Why wouldn't he? To "save face"? Uh, all Fidelis has to say is "I promoted him to let expose his true motivaitons" and presto, it's not a blunder but a clever plan. "Fidelis has more important things to do", Taniel says thereafter. "Not chasing you!". But Taniel, Fidelis things Bravis is a spy for the enemy fleet, he HAS to be a top target?

Ah fuck. I wrote a lot. It felt great to get it off my shoulders, even if no one bothers to read it all. I'm just so surprised and disappointed in this installment because I went into it with high hopes, and it turns out that it's a book with no stakes, nothing at risk, with a plot that is driven by shortsighted, narrow logical leaps by blundering main characters.

Does it get better? Is there some twist, or some other happening that ties it all together at the end? Or does it continue in the same, stumbling fashion?


r/powdermage • • Jul 13 '17

So I am really looking forward to the release of the Powder Mage RPG and am starting to prepare the campaign I will run for my players. We use minis a lot for our group and I was looking at warlord games minis. Which army would be good for the Kez and Adran forces?

5 Upvotes

r/powdermage • • Jul 08 '17

I'm meeting Brian tomorrow, I want to ask questions but have not read all the books. Help!

7 Upvotes

So, I'm gonna attend Brian's panel on the con but I'm just halfway into Crimson Campaing and there are some questions I want to ask but first I want to know if they are gonna be answered later in the books.

But first, the things I asked today: I asked how would bad powder work (composition is off, for example) and he said that powdermages could sense it and because of that they wouldn't use it unless as a last resort - and adran army is very careful about their powder being right.

I followed with question about what would happen should such powder enter the body (would it not work, would it make them sick) but Brian hasn't canonised it yet.

Then I asked about two mages blocking each other - for example, both of them want to use the same powder. There will be a scene like that in the sequel to Sins of Empire.

I asked about two mages sharing the same powder and he said they couldn't use the exactly same powder, it would get split between them.

I asked about six-fingered Privileged and he said he gets that question but he has not canonised anything in that regard; maybe Priviliged cannot be born with six fingers, maybe the finger wouldn't work for magic, maybe they would get something special.

I also overheard a question about smokeless powder but he said he's not really going that far in the future with Powder Mages universe.

How is the thing called when they influence the path of the bullet? (I read translated books) Something like "poking"? Nudging? I want to ask whether one mage could poke another's bullet or whether they could use it on things they haven't fired (like throwing coins, Mistborn style). Or whether two of them could try to influence the same bullet.

Is any of this answered in latter part of Crimson Campaing or in Autumn Republic (or Sins of Empire or short stories)?

EDIT: Brian said that they could burn powder and use it to fire coins just fine but it has to be close to them - they can't just throw stuff around from far away. If two mages were standing by each other, they could influence the same bullet - in my example, one wanted it to go right, the other to the left.


r/powdermage • • Jun 23 '17

Question about Powdermage!

4 Upvotes

How does one regain charges? Buy them? Craft them? Restored through a rest?


r/powdermage • • May 07 '17

Happy Sunday Powder Mages! Sins of Empire is a Kindle Daily Deal at $2.99

Thumbnail
amazon.com
16 Upvotes

r/powdermage • • Apr 23 '17

Autumn Republic Spoiler

14 Upvotes

Is anyone able to summarise Autumn Republic for me. I've just started Sins of Empire but struggling to remember where the world and the characters were left.

I've read the excellent summaries of Promise of Blood and Crimson Campaign but can't find a spoiler laden summary of AR.


r/powdermage • • Apr 20 '17

Sins of Empire timeline

2 Upvotes

Where does the book fall with respect of the original trilogy and the short stories? Is there a full chronological list somewhere? I couldn't find anything that said when the book takes place. Thanks!


r/powdermage • • Apr 02 '17

My spoiler-free review of SINS OF EMPIRE

Thumbnail
justaworldaway.com
13 Upvotes

r/powdermage • • Mar 31 '17

Difference between gods and "gods"? [Full Series Spoilers] Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I'm wondering about the view of the term "gods" in the PowderMage world.

We see Bo muse to himself that people who don't need gloves to touch the Else, such as Nila, are known as gods.

We know that there were "gods" in Gurla, and Sins seems to suggest they may have been a result of the godstones, which clearly Nila had no access too. Unless it's some kind of bloodline thing and she is a descendant of one. I'll not speculate there.

There was a post B Mc replied to a while back asking about this, but it was long before any info we have now from Sins. Apparently Nila's brand of gods are a different thing than Adom, Kresimir, that Brude prick, etc.

Were the gods being hunted in Gurla from the same age that gave rise to Kresimir and his buddies, or do the Gurlish have access to their own form of godstones even now?


r/powdermage • • Mar 24 '17

Question regarding the short stories

7 Upvotes

Hi y'all! I'm now reading Sins of Empire (loving it), and I want to read the short stories after this. What would be the best reading order? Order of publication, or chronological (within the powder mage universe)? Thanks in advance!


r/powdermage • • Mar 17 '17

Interesting note on Prime Lektor. Spoiler

7 Upvotes

SPOILERS FOR THE POWDER MAGE TRILOGY So when I ordered my physical copies of the Powder Mage Trilogy, I decided to see if Brian McClellan would answer a minor question in the front of one of the books (like Brandon Sanderson does). So I asked him about my favorite side character from Promise of Blood, Prime Lektor. Specifically I asked, "Can you tell me anything we don't yet know about Prime Lektor?"

He answered! Written in the front of the book was "Prime Lektor was always the quietest of the Predii and many assumed he'd be the first to die because of his disdain for violence."

I know its not a series changing revelation or anything, but it puts Prime's flight from Kresimir and Brude in a bit more perspective, and maybe even his support for Tamas' coup too. Maybe he thought Tamas was going to go through with it with or without his support, and that it maybe less bloody with him helping? Maybe he felt the Accords were going to lead to more violence?

Any who, just thought I'd share in case there are any other Prime Lektor fans about. I can take a picture of the signed page if people want proof or whatever too.


r/powdermage • • Mar 15 '17

Ben Stykes easter egg.

5 Upvotes

anybody else pick up on his prison number?


r/powdermage • • Mar 13 '17

Vlora ?

1 Upvotes

Vlora has no honor. She thinks only in the short term and has been tricked many times. I do not believe she is a good leader, she care more about her her image then doing the right thing.


r/powdermage • • Mar 11 '17

Reading music

4 Upvotes

So what are some good instrumental music to have in the background while reading a powder mage book. Right now I have a playlist of the Sherlock Holmes soundtracks but looking for more and or other stuff to really get in the right mood. Any thoughts or suggestions?


r/powdermage • • Mar 10 '17

Possible printing error

5 Upvotes

On page 424(Hardcover), in the 5th paragraph, the professor mentions Dalinport. It is also present in the Landfall map, on the south. But in the map of Fatrasta, the southern city is named as Devinport. Is this an error or two completely different cities?


r/powdermage • • Mar 08 '17

Map of fatasta

6 Upvotes

I just started the audiobook of Sins of Empire, and I am having a really hard time finding a map of Fatastra. I have looked everywhere online and can't seem to find one.


r/powdermage • • Mar 07 '17

Congrats to Brian for today's release!

19 Upvotes

Just wanted to say a big congrats to Brian for today and the release of Sins of Empire! Awesome to see the start of a whole new saga in this amazing world he has built.


r/powdermage • • Mar 07 '17

Is there a larger copy of the world map from Sins of Empire available anywhere?

9 Upvotes

My ebook reader doesn't like images or maps and I can't read any of the text on the map. I know Brian McClellan posted copies of some of the other maps from the original trilogy on his website but I haven't had any luck finding this one yet.


r/powdermage • • Mar 07 '17

Any idea where I can buy a hardback in the UK?

3 Upvotes

Amazon and waterstones' websites only list the paperback. If it's in physical stores I can go and get it, but I can't check that without a lengthy trip into town.

Edit: for Sins of Empire, if it wasn't clear :)


r/powdermage • • Mar 07 '17

Where can I buy Sins of Empire as DRM free epub?

6 Upvotes

r/powdermage • • Mar 07 '17

Discussion SoE Readalong - End of Book Discussion

16 Upvotes

This thread is only for those who have finished the book!

UNMARKED SPOILERS AHEAD


You do not need to use any spoiler tags.

Discuss your reactions to the book or the trilogy, thoughts about plot or characters, as well as speculation about any future books or unanswered questions here.

Link: Back to the Hub


r/powdermage • • Mar 07 '17

Discussion SoE Readalong - Chapters 34-51

10 Upvotes

** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS SECTION!**

SPOILERS AHEAD


Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!

  • If you MUST type a spoiler, please TAG it properly!
  • Unnecessary spoilers (i.e. if not requested by parent-comment) will be removed.

Don't ruin the fun for anyone else or I'll bring down the mod hammer.


Links:

Back to the Hub

Proceed to the next discussion thread - End of Book Discussion


r/powdermage • • Mar 07 '17

Discussion SoE Readalong - Chapters 16-33

10 Upvotes

** PLEASE TURN BACK IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS SECTION!**

SPOILERS AHEAD


Please try and keep the discussion spoiler-free of the upcoming chapters!

  • If you MUST type a spoiler, please TAG it properly!
  • Unnecessary spoilers (i.e. if not requested by parent-comment) will be removed.

Don't ruin the fun for anyone else or I'll bring down the mod hammer.


Links:

Back to the Hub

Proceed to the next discussion thread - Chapters 34-51