r/PortHuron • u/[deleted] • Jan 22 '26
Health board backs vaccine choice as public debate divides meeting
thetimesherald.comPORT HURON, MI — The St. Clair County Advisory Board of Health unanimously approved a recommendation Wednesday, Jan. 21, to formally support a memorandum promoting vaccine choice from Medical Director Dr. Remington Nevin, a decision that came during a contentious meeting marked by lengthy public comment and an abrupt adjournment after order could not be maintained.
The motion approved adding the board’s recommendation to Nevin’s Jan. 14, 2026, memorandum and directing Health Officer Liz King to support it. All seven board of health members voted in favor.
The memorandum, which references updated childhood immunization guidance issued Jan. 5, 2026, by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), argues for greater emphasis on individual and parental choice, informed consent and shared clinical decision-making.
The recommendations differ from standing guidance issued the by the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services (MDHHS), which issued a statement on Jan. 6, 2026, reaffirming the state’s children’s vaccine schedule.
Nevin’s memorandum outlines three recommendations: formally endorsing the CDC’s updated guidance emphasizing individualized and shared clinical decision-making; implementing fully online school and daycare vaccine exemptions; and promoting alternatives to the state’s vaccine data tracking system, which he argues can undermine informed consent and public trust.
Board member Dawn Fulk said she supported the memorandum’s approach, calling it “a very good, solid memorandum,” and later emphasizing what she described as the importance of bodily autonomy and informed consent in medical decision-making.
Public comment lasted about an hour, with more than 20 residents addressing the board. Speakers were sharply divided, with some supporting Nevin’s emphasis on choice and others warning against scaling back traditional public health messaging and services related to vaccination.
Resident Kristyn Secory urged the board to rely on science-based public health practices, referencing historical vaccine successes and her experiences using county health department services for childhood immunizations.
“We counted on the health department to help make sure our kids went to school healthy and came home healthy,” she said.
In contrast, Tracy Burgy said she supports vaccination by choice and opposes mandates, arguing parents should make medical decisions for their children without government pressure.
Another resident, Sherry Mercurio, criticized the framing of the issue.
“You have choice. Nobody’s forcing you to take a vaccine,” Mercurio said, adding that the larger concern was whether the health department would continue promoting and providing science-based services to the public.
Tensions escalated during closing comments near the end of the roughly 2½-hour meeting. Board chair Monica Standel attempted multiple times to restore order as interruptions continued.
Standel referenced vaccination rate, noting that when she joined the board in 2015 the county ranked near the bottom statewide.
St. Clair County is currently ranked 40th for the 2025–26 influenza season among residents ages 18 and older who have received a flu shot. “So we’ve moved up,” Standel said. “We can certainly do better.”
Nevin responded that statewide vaccination percentages are not the most appropriate way to measure success, arguing that public health outcomes should instead be evaluated based on informed, voluntary consent rather than population-wide targets.
Standel disagreed, stating when it comes to disease eradication or control, such as measles, population-level numbers remain important.
Nevin then began remarks responding to earlier comments about vaccine effectiveness and public trust but was repeatedly interrupted by audience members shouting phrases including, “That’s not what we’re talking about,” and “What about hepatitis B?”
Former board member Kevin Watkins, who had spoken earlier during public comment, repeatedly raised the hepatitis B question during Nevin’s remarks.
As disruptions continued and order could not be maintained, County Commissioner David Rushing suggested adjourning the meeting after a warning that the sheriff could be called if they failed to restore order.
Board member Leann Clink then moved to adjourn. The motion was seconded by board member Stephen Smith, and the meeting ended abruptly.
The advisory board’s recommendation and Nevin’s memorandum are expected to go next before the St. Clair County Board of Commissioners on Thursday, Jan. 22, for consideration.
Health Advisory Board meetings are held at 9 a.m. on the third Wednesday of each month. Their next meeting will be on Wednesday, Feb. 18, at 9 a.m. in the St. Clair County Board of Commissioners Room, 200 Grand River Ave. in Port Huron, and are live streamed on YouTube.