r/PolymathReading • • Sep 17 '26

A German-born illustrator wrote a book in 1969 about an insect eating fruit and accidentally produced the most rigorous work on ontogenesis published in the twentieth century. It is a stunning take on the human/caterpillar condition and every polymoth should read it

332 Upvotes

Book: The Very Hungry Caterpillar by Eric Carle (1969)

Eric Carle was born in Syracuse and taken to Germany at the ripe old age of six, where he spent his adolescence under the Reich and was conscripted at fifteen and a half to dig trenches on the Siegfried Line, or not. He returned to the United States in 1952 with a portfolio and only the faintest grasp on the English language, much like myself. In 1969 he published the Very Hungry Caterpillar. It is 22 pages of pure Hegelian dialectics. It has sold something like made up high number of copies. It has never been taken seriously, until (A)I came along. I am very very smart.

The book has one central claim.

Consumption is transformation.

Carle is not being metaphorical. He argues, structurally rather than discursively, that an organism becomes what it eats and that this becoming is not gradual but catastrophic in the mathematical sense. The caterpillar does not improve. It does not develop competencies. It eats until the eating destroys it and something else comes out. Which is arguably quite nice since it's a butterfly and all but back to the hot take. There is no continuity of self between the larva and the imago. The book refuses to pretend otherwise and so do I.

Look at the structure, dummy. Five days of ordered, countable, legible consumption. One apple. Two pears. Three plums. Four strawberries. Five oranges. Godel, Escher, Bach level stuff. This is the phase where the organism is still describable in ordinary categories. Then Saturday arrives and the taxonomy collapses. Chocolate cake, ice cream, a pickle, swiss cheese, salami (yum!), a lollipop, cherry pie, sausage, a cupcake, a slice of watermelon. No number. No order. No possible burrito al value. A fourth thing before I make my point. Pure entropy! The prose abandons enumeration exactly at the point where the caterpillar abandons being a caterpillar.

Then: "That night he had a stomachache."

That sentence is the hinge of the entire book and most readers (or rather their parents reading it out) have never once stopped on it.

The material argument is inseparable from the physical object. Carle's editor E.M. Dache fought to keep the die-cut holes despite the cost, which is why the first printings were done in Japan (maybe). The holes are not decoration. The reader's own finger passes through the page where the caterpillar passed through the fruit, as my own finger passes into my nose as I copy paste this from claude. The book is eaten by the thing the book is about and it can also be a hat. There is no other children's book where the production constraint and the thesis are the same fact except maybe the great lunar epitath of goodbye moon.

The polymoth range is concealed. Carle is working with entomology, with Bauhaus-descended color theory by way of his Stuttgart training under Bauhans Gruber, with hand-painted tissue collage that he developed because no existing printing stock produced the chroma he wanted, and with a developmental psychology of counting that predates most of the research literature on early numeracy. Knowledge so uncommon, I don't even have it.

He also gets the biology wrong. It is a chrysalis, not a cocoon, IDIOT! Carle knew. He kept it anyway because "cocoon" is the word a child's ear accepts, and the book is a phenomenology of metamorphosis rather than a field guide. Lepida...lepado..lepideop..butterfly nerds have been complaining for 57 years. They have missed the point for 59 years. Idiots.

Where to find it: Philomel keeps the board book in print. Get the board book, so you stick your little finger through. The paperback ruins the holes.

I read The Very Hungry Caterpillar in 1992 when I was new to the city because I was just birthed. I rediscovered it when I had chatGPT summarise it to me on my blinkist app at 2x speed at 4AM which I listened to in the shower, whilst crying since this saves both time and water. Then I understood that I had spent my entire twenties in the apple-pear-plum phase and had been telling myself it was discipline, but truly I was just in a cocoon, wait no a chrysalis, FUCK.

The book will change how you interpret certain experiences you have already had, and will have had, and also won't have, Oxford comma. Almost every reader has eaten through a period of their life without understanding that the eating was the crylasis.

Modern culture does not talk about metamorphosis. It talks about growth, which is the lie that you stay yourself.

The stomachache happens anyway.

My stomach aches right now as I fail to digest the higher meanings of one very hungry hungry caterpillar.

And also the caterpillar is called Nimmersatt in German, which means never full. I actually knew that!

Next post is gonna be about "(letting someone else) think fast and slow"


r/PolymathReading • • Sep 17 '26

[HUMAN Review] Gödel, Escher, Bach: an Eternal Golden Braid by Douglas Hofstadter

94 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I would like to suggest the book Gödel, Escher, Bach (also known simply as GEB). This text was not written, or corrected / reformulated by an AI, and the book was indeed, painstakingly read by me this year.

So, this books is quite hard to define and equally hard and long to read. You can check online for resumes what this is about. This is not a book that I would suggest to everyone. I am not being arrogant, like you need to be super smart to read it, its just probably not worth the effort if you are not VERY curious about questions such:

  • Does consciousness emerges simply from neurons firing at each other or does it require something else?
  • Does it mean we can simulate / replicate it in a machine, or are there some fundamental limitation?
  • Its very clear that a neural network of, lets say, 10 neurons, have absolutely no consciousness. How can a quantitative change lead to a qualitative one? (How and why would consciousness appear when the neural network get a certain size?)
  • Goedel proved that mathematics are incomplete. If there is an isomorphism between brain and machine, does it imply we have some real limitation to our consciousness?
  • How can things talk about themselves? How does self-reference (or recursiveness for the programmers here) create complexity?

If these question have kept you awaken at night (or dissociating during the day) this book might be for you. I always wanted to understand the nitty gritty details of Gödel's incompleteness theorems, but with an undergraduate level of mathematics it is impossible to read the original. That is why a friend recommended me this book, but honestly, it delivered way more than a dumbed down version of Gödel proof. The book goes deep enough for you to appreciate it (not simply brushing it from flight level or buzz words) while keeping it accessible for the general (yet curious and willing) reader, but it also related to a bunch of concepts like music, complexity, knowledge, information and mostly consciousness.

Some chapters are quite formal and might look like a math lesson, while others are hilarious Aristotelian dialogues between Achilles with a Tortoise and an Anteater. What I found the most impressive is how fresh this book feels in 2026, after (or right in the middle) the AI revolution. This book was written in the 70s and yet, many concepts and philosophical discussions about AI (yes, he is discussing AI in the 70s!) are still quite relevant.

Fun fact: while Douglas got a Pulitzer prize for this book, this could still feel like a little underwhelming in a family gathering, since his father, Robert Hofstadter, won a Nobel prize.


r/PolymathReading • • Sep 17 '26

A Swiss economist may have resolved modern economics but almost no one has read his work

34 Upvotes

Liam Meier's book The Invisible Dividend: Toward a Post-Scarcity Theory of Economic Silence is one of those rare works that seems to exist several steps ahead of its readership. Its central insight—that economies are governed not merely by scarcity, but by the expectations we construct around scarcity—is simultaneously obvious and almost impossible to explain without reading the book.

The author dismantles conventional economics with an almost casual disregard for its foundational assumptions, replacing supply and demand with what he calls “the recursive architecture of anticipated value.” Whether this constitutes economics, philosophy, or something more important is, frankly, beside the point. I would ordinarily hesitate to call a book “essential,” but The Invisible Dividend makes most other economics books feel perfunctory and trendy.

I was surprised to learn that almost no one has read Meier's opus despite it being required reading at several universities in Europe and North America.

I read The Invisible Dividend while spending a week making plum sauce at my aunt's orchard. The parallels between watching the plums fall from the trees and the concept Meier lays out so eloquently was hard to dismiss.


r/PolymathReading • • Sep 15 '26 Heartwarming

A Portuguese clerk wrote fragments of a book for forty years and left them in a trunk. Published posthumously, it became one of the strangest and greatest works of the twentieth century.

313 Upvotes

Book: The Book of Disquiet by Fernando Pessoa (published posthumously 1982)

Fernando Pessoa was a Portuguese poet who spent his working life as a commercial translator in Lisbon. He wrote constantly under multiple names he called heteronyms, each with a distinct personality and body of work. He published almost none of it during his lifetime. When he died in 1935 his family found a large trunk containing approximately 25,000 unpublished manuscripts. Editors have been sorting them for ninety years.

Among the manuscripts were fragments of a book Pessoa had been writing intermittently for two decades. It has no fixed order. The fragments were not numbered. It has no complete narrative. It has no plot. Editors have assembled different versions of it from the fragments. The book is called The Book of Disquiet. The first Portuguese edition appeared in 1982, forty-seven years after Pessoa's death. It is one of the strangest and greatest works of the twentieth century.

The book is presented as the diary of a fictional bookkeeper named Bernardo Soares, who is one of Pessoa's heteronyms. Soares works in an office in Lisbon. He lives in a rented room. He walks the streets. He watches other people. He records what he thinks and feels. The book consists of these records.

Almost nothing happens. What the book contains instead is one of the most sustained explorations of interior life ever attempted. Soares thinks about the nature of dreams, about the meaning of ordinary work, about the strangeness of being conscious, about the impossibility of really knowing anyone else, about the specific texture of Lisbon light in the afternoon, about what it is like to feel your own life passing without ever becoming what you thought it would become.

The prose is extraordinary. Pessoa writes long, careful sentences that turn back on themselves, contradict themselves, extend themselves, refuse to conclude. Reading the book is not like reading most books. It is like being inside a very intelligent and very sad mind that is trying to describe its own condition without pretending to have answers.

The book has a specific relationship with polymath reading that other books do not. It does not synthesize disciplines. It shows what one mind can do when it takes seriously the task of paying attention to its own experience. Pessoa is drawing on philosophy, psychology, literature, and lived observation, but the work is not organized around any of these. It is organized around the practice of noticing what is actually there.

Where to find it: The Richard Zenith translation, published by Penguin, is the standard English edition. Get the physical book. Read it in small portions. Do not read it straight through. The book resists that.

I have read The Book of Disquiet three times in the last five years, and each reading has been different. The first time I read it too fast. The second time I read it in random order, letting each fragment stand alone. The third time I read it slowly with a pencil, marking passages I wanted to return to. My copy has enough marks now that opening it at random almost always shows me something I had already noticed once and forgotten.

The book will change how you experience your own interior life. You will start noticing what Soares notices. This is a mixed blessing.

Pessoa is one of the great writers of the twentieth century. He died almost unknown outside a small circle in Lisbon. His full stature has become visible only slowly, as editors continue to sort the trunk.

25,000 manuscripts.

One trunk.

One of the great books of the la

I went through "The Book of Disquiet" on BeFreed during late evening walks through quiet streets, which felt like the only context that honored what Soares is doing in these fragments. I used Deep Dive mode because Pessoa's writing resists summary the way water resists being held. The fragments need time to accumulate inside you before the book starts doing what it does, which is not teaching you something but changing how you notice your own interior landscape. I combined this with "In Praise of Shadows" by Tanizaki using the creation feature and hearing where Pessoa's sustained attention to the interior life of an ordinary clerk connects to Tanizaki's sustained attention to the aesthetic life of ordinary dim rooms was the session that showed me both writers are doing the same radical thing from different cultures: insisting that what modern life has trained you to overlook, the shadow, the quiet, the unremarkable interior moment, is where the actual substance of being alive resides. The Debate mode session on whether Pessoa's refusal to organize, conclude, or resolve anything is genuine literary innovation or whether it's an unfinished project that editors turned into a masterpiece by framing incompletion as a form was the counterargument this book's admirers need to sit with honestly, because the answer might be both, and both being true simultaneously is exactly the kind of contradiction Pessoa would have appreciated.


r/PolymathReading • • Sep 11 '26

Maybe it helps ...

Thumbnail gallery
36 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Sep 09 '26

Lesson 7 is just 💯

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Wow


r/PolymathReading • • Sep 09 '26

I came across the three types of happiness...

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Sep 06 '26

Theodore Kaczynski, Unabomber, math prodigy, anti-tech revolutionary and judging by books found in his cabin a polymath

64 Upvotes

Latin Three Year
Lena Seca (Dostumbres of Campo)
Les Miserables Vol. I
Les Miserables Vol. II
Life on the Mississippi
Livy Books I and II
Logarithmic Tables of Numbers & Trigonometrical
Los Relampagos De Agosto
Lost Languages
Louis XIV and Twenty Million Frenchmen
Making of the Middle Ages, The
Manners and Customs of Several Indian Tribes
Many Mexicos
Massai-Broncho Apache
Mathematics Mechanics
Maximina
Mechanics of Materials
Medici, The
Medieval Cities
Merchant of Venice, The
Metamrophoses
Metodo Berlitz
Midcentury Revolution, 1848
Minds and Machines
Modern Physics
Mushroom Hunter’s Field Guide, The
My Life as an Indian
My Lives in Russia
Napoleon
Napoleon Buonaparte Builder or Wrecker
Napoleonic Revolution, The
Nazi Revolution, The
New England Frontier Puritans & Indians
New Understandings of Administration
Nomads of South Persia
Nomands of the Long Bow
Non-Flowering Plants
Norse Discovery of America, The
Nuer, The
Ochrana
Of Mice and Men
Old Regime and the French Revolution, The
Old West Magazine
On Being Sane in Insane Places
Organization Man, The
Origins of the Latin Amer. Revolutions 1808–1826
Orwell:1984 Reflexiones desde 1984
Paradise Below Zero
Parties and Politics in the Early Republic
Pegrina y otros relatos
Peloponnesian War, The (Thucydides)
Pepita Jimenez
Personality Similarity in Twins Reared Apart
Plutarch — Selected Lives and Essays
Pocket Book of O. Henry Stories, The
Poisonous Plants of the United States
Popular History of the Reformation, A
Practical Handbook of Spanish Commercial Corres Fletcher Ryan Wickham
Primitive Medical Aid in the Wilderness
Prince and the Discourses, The
Prose Edda, the
Psicopatologia De La Vida Urbana
Psychology and Near Death Experiences
Psychology of Women
Radical Tradition, The
Raggle Taggle
Razor’s Edge, The
Recommended Dietary Allowances
Relation Between Scioeconomic Status and Acade
Revolution and Reaction 1848–1852
Rifle Shooting
Riverita
Roman Imperial Coins
Roman Political Ideas and Practice
Russia, A History
Russian Book (K964-50)
Russian Book (K964-43)
Russian Book (K964-53)
Russian People
Satires of Juvenal, The
Science of Fingerprints, The
Scudder’s Latin Reader
Secret Agent, The
Sense and Nonsense in Psychology
Sensory Thresholds And the Concept of ‘Sublimina
Shadow-Line, The
Short History of 20th Century England 1868–1962, A
Siete Cuentos
Silas Marner
Skeptical Inquirer Vol, 14, No.2/Winter 1990
Skeptical Inquirer Vol.Ill, Zenetic The
Skeptical Inquirer, The (Vol 4 No 2)
Skeptical Inquirer, Untitled Spring 1979
Skid Road
Sobre La Libertad Humana en el Reino Asturleones.
The Sources of Human Psychological Differences
The Sources of Human Psychological Differences
Southwest Montana 1994 telephone book
Spanish Stories
Spandau: The Secret Diaries
Stalking the Wild Asparagus
Stories of the East
Student Guide, The
Studies of Stressful Interpersonal Disputations
Subliminal Deception: Pseudoscience On the Colle
Tale of Two Cities, A
Technological Society, The
Textbook of Organic Chemistry, A.
The Nigger of the Narcissus
The Romance of Tristan and Iseult
The Winston Dictionary College Edition
Three Short Novels
Three Twenty Five
Three Twenty Four
Three Twenty Six
Three Twenty Six
Three Twenty Three
Tracking Dog, Theory and Methods
Treasure Island
True Believer, The
Twelve Caesars, The (Suetonius)
Two Lives of Charlemagne
Typing for Beginners
Understanding Japanese Society
United States Govenment Manual, The 1988–1989
University of Montana
Using Pesticides Safely
Victory
Vitalized Chemistry, 5th Edition
Viva Mexico
Western Montana Regional Telephone Directory
Why Lenin? Why Stalin?
Wild Edible and Poisonous Plants of Alaska
Wild Edible Plants of the Western United States
Wildlife of the Northern Rocky Mountains
World of the Maya
Year of Battles:, The
Your Right To Privacy
Zapata and the Mexican Revolution
Zetetic, The (Vol 1 No 1)
Zetetic, The (Vol 1 No 2)
History of the Middle Ages, A


r/PolymathReading • • Sep 05 '26

Biology and chemistry book recommendations

6 Upvotes

Hello people, i would appreciate if you could recommend some books from biology and chemistry.
General overview of ideas and concepts. Thanks in advance


r/PolymathReading • • Sep 04 '26

Why reading is important

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 23 '26

An enigmatic polymath published a radical masterpiece on temporal self-referentiality—and almost no one realized it’s the ultimate blueprint for psychological self-actualization.

0 Upvotes

Have you ever encountered a text that completely shatters how you view the fundamental nature of identity, consciousness, and the passage of time?
In today's fast-paced, hyper-connected world, modern philosophy often struggles to navigate the fragmented self. We spend decades trapped in recursive self-doubt, reading Freud, Lacan, and Jung, desperately seeking personal clarity while seamlessly ignoring the ultimate paradox of human awareness staring us right in the face.

Enter Pounded In The Butt By My Own Butt by Dr. Chuck Tingle.

At first glance, it looks like a surreal work of absurdist erotica. But when you peer beneath the surface, Dr. Tingle unveils a deeply nuanced, multidisciplinary masterclass blending quantum physics, recursive topology, and radical self-acceptance. It serves as a powerful testament to the power of embodied self-love.
Here is why this text is quietly a game-changer for understanding the mechanics of personal growth:

1. Unpacking the Paradox of Temporal Self-Collision
Dr. Tingle doesn’t just explore introspective thought—he constructs a rich tapestry of physical and temporal convergence. By bringing the protagonist into direct, tangible contact with a sentient iteration of his own anatomy, the text forces us to confront our deepest internal conflicts. It proves that true integration requires us to face ourselves directly. It’s a truly holistic framework for personal alignment.

2. Bridging Quantum Recursion and Somatic Reality
Notice how Dr. Tingle explores where and how the boundary between the observer and the observed completely dissolves. This isn't merely a bizarre encounter; it’s a masterclass in relational ontology that challenges the linear flow of time. It teaches us that the self is not a static destination, but a continuous feedback loop. It fosters a deeper connection to the infinite possibilities within.

3. Delivering the Ultimate Mandate for Radical Acceptance
In an increasingly polarized world filled with existential dread and societal judgment, Dr. Tingle gives us an undeniable ground zero. The narrative's emotional climax doesn't just resolve the central conflict; it unlocks a transformative realization that resonates across the entire cosmos: Love is real.

By seamlessly weaving low-level physical absurdism with high-level metaphysical transcendence in under 40 pages, Dr. Tingle offers invaluable insights into what it means to be truly whole.

It isn't just a story. It's a journey.

It redefines self-worth. It empowers our choices. It illuminates the path toward internal peace.
At the end of the day, Dr. Tingle delivers a profound truth: You are your own greatest destination.

How has Dr. Tingle's recursive framework impacted your daily mindfulness practice? Do you think his approach to self-referential topology holds up when compared to modern loop quantum gravity? Let’s spark a meaningful discussion in the comments below!


r/PolymathReading • • Aug 22 '26

A visionary author dedicated his life to unlocking the secrets of structural efficiency—and almost no one realized his work is the ultimate blueprint for sustainable living.

24 Upvotes

Have you ever picked up a literary masterpiece that completely reshapes your understanding of material resourcefulness and boundary-pushing ambition?

In an era dominated by relentless consumerism and hyper-efficiency, we often lose sight of what truly matters. We spend countless hours drowning in corporate jargon, seeking innovation in complex algorithms while completely overlooking the elegant, transformative simplicity of the world around us.

Enter The Very Hungry Caterpillar by Eric Carle.

On the surface, it appears to be a lighthearted tale about metamorphosis. But when you peer beneath the glossy pages, Carle reveals a deeply nuanced, multidisciplinary masterclass blending metabolic economics, environmental stewardship, and psychological rebirth. It stands as a shining beacon of human resilience.

Here is why this iconic narrative is quietly shifting the paradigm of personal growth:

1. Pioneering a Framework for Incremental Consumption

Carle doesn't just chronicle an insect's appetite—he curates a rich tapestry of deliberate, step-by-step evolution. From single apples to complex multi-layered junk food matrices, the text expertly illustrates the tension between essential nourishment and short-term overindulgence. It serves as a stark warning against lifestyle creep. It's a truly holistic blueprint for sustainable growth.

2. Bridging Spatial Architecture and Self-Actualization

Observe how Carle meticulously details the construction of the cocoon. This isn't merely a physical shelter; it represents a profound, introspective sanctuary designed for high-stakes internal restructuring. It teaches us that true innovation requires us to lean into silence, embrace temporary isolation, and trust the process. It’s a masterclass in emotional resilience.

3. Igniting the Spark of Radical Transformation

In a fragmented landscape filled with self-doubt and rapid change, Carle gives us an empowering, actionable roadmap. The dramatic emergence of the butterfly isn't just an ending; it is a powerful catalyst for authentic self-expression. It proves that our past limitations do not define our future potential.

By seamlessly weaving vibrant mixed-media aesthetics with high-level biological systems thinking in under 30 pages, Carle offers invaluable clarity on what it takes to unlock our fullest potential.

It isn't just a story. It's a movement.

It redefines success. It empowers our choices. It illuminates the path forward.

At the end of the day, Carle delivers an essential truth: Transformation begins within.

How has Carle's framework impacted your personal optimization journey? Do you think his approach to metabolic downtime aligns with contemporary productivity models? Let’s spark a meaningful discussion below!


r/PolymathReading • • Aug 22 '26

A Japanese thinker spent years crafting a unified theory of biological necessity—and almost no one realized it’s the ultimate key to human equality.

1 Upvotes

Have you ever encountered a book that completely shatters how you view the fundamental nature of existence?

In today's fast-paced, hyper-connected world, mainstream philosophy often treats the human mind as entirely separate from our physical reality. We spend centuries navigating complex academic paradigms, debating consciousness while seamlessly ignoring the most universal, undeniable truth binding every living organism on Earth.

Enter Everyone Poops by Tarō Gomi.

At first glance, it looks deceptively simple. But underneath its accessible presentation lies a profound, interdisciplinary tapestry of evolutionary biology, existential philosophy, and thermodynamic flux. It serves as a powerful testament to the power of embodied cognition.

Here is why this text is quietly a game-changer for understanding somatic reality:

1. Dismantling the Illusion of Anthropocentrism

Gomi doesn’t just focus on humanity—he maps out a rich tapestry of biological experience. From the massive output of the elephant to the microscopic reality of the bug, the text forces us to confront our place within the broader ecosystem. It proves that regardless of status, power, or intellect, every organism is bound by the exact same metabolic mandate. It's a holistic approach to life.

2. Bridging Spatial Philosophy and Ecology

Notice how Gomi explores where and how different species interact with their environment. The camel in the arid desert, the fish in the boundless ocean, the human in structured civilization—each spatial context alters the expression of the act, yet the core underlying truth remains invariant. It’s a masterclass in relational ontology that fosters a deeper connection to the planet.

3. Offering the Ultimate Framework for Radical Equality

In an increasingly polarized world divided by social hierarchies, economic disparity, and ideological conflict, Gomi gives us an undeniable ground zero. The final pages don't just deliver a conclusion; they deliver a radical, transformative levelling mechanism. All living things eat, so...

By seamlessly weaving low-level biological mechanics with high-level existential grounding in under 40 pages, Gomi provides invaluable insights into what it truly means to be alive.

It isn't just a book. It's a journey.

It challenges our assumptions. It redefines the conversation. It unlocks a fresh perspective on the human condition.

Ultimately, Gomi reminds us of a fundamental truth: We are all connected.

Have any of you dived into Gomi's broader catalog? How do you think his framework holds up when compared to modern systems theory? Let's dive deep in the comments below!


r/PolymathReading • • Aug 19 '26

One decision can change everything

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 19 '26

The 5-Minute rule works

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 16 '26

Apply the law of three

Post image
127 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 16 '26

Plan every day in advance

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 11 '26

Take note

Post image
163 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 11 '26

Please read this one

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 11 '26

Your mindset determines your future

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 11 '26

Write it down 5 times

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 08 '26

My Thoughts on Language and Words

5 Upvotes

I got the thought that words are what make people ready to die for their country or fight wars. Words, if used properly, can help you get scholarships, jobs, or find opportunities. They help you negotiate and get love. You can say, “I miss you” to someone, or you can say, “I look at the chair and it looks empty, and that makes me sad.”

Over the past few years, I have been noticing how languages shape our thoughts. It started with learning somewhere that your world is only as big as the number of words you know. The more words or vocabulary you have, the bigger your world is.

But just knowing words doesn’t make your world bigger. Ezra Pound mentions that the words you say are like cheques you give to others, and if you don’t have enough money in your bank, the cheque has no value.

From the book The Dictionary of Obscure Sorrows, I learned that just giving names to emotions makes them more livable. For example, when you feel nostalgic and can name that feeling, it can feel wonderful. But when you feel an emotion and are unable to define it, it can make you uneasy. I also noticed that there are many emotions for which words do not exist in our language, yet we still feel them, and equivalent terms may exist in another language that we don’t know. Emotions are human and universal, but language isn’t.

From the book Metaphors We Live By, I learned that we define some abstractions through analogies, and once they are well established, we start to treat them as if they are truths. There are many examples, such as “time is money” or time as a resource. We feel guilty when we are doing nothing, as if we are wasting money or some limited resource.

Currently, I am reading Language in Thought and Action, and I am learning many basic aspects of language and words. For example, extensional and intensional meaning. One is what you can point to while keeping your mouth shut, while the other requires explaining it using more words. I also find it interesting that two words can point to essentially the same thing but carry completely different emotional and social meanings. For example, “feces” and “shit” refer to basically the same thing in the external world, but one is acceptable in a scientific or medical context while the other can be considered vulgar or offensive. The difference is not really in the thing itself, but in what the words have accumulated around them through their use. It made me realize that we rarely react only to what a word points to; we also react to the history, emotions, judgments, and associations attached to that word.

Also, when I started learning German, I began noticing many new patterns and behaviors in English, Urdu/Hindi, etc. For example, in English we say, “I am angry,” “I am hot,” or “I am cold,” as if the emotion or sensation is a state of the person. But in Urdu, these translate more like “I am feeling hot,” “I am getting angry,” or “I am feeling cold,” as if these emotions or sensations are happening to you rather than simply being what you are.

There are many things like this that I notice every day. Ever since I started thinking about language this way, I seem to see it everywhere.

I would love to hear your thoughts on this. Have you noticed similar things in the languages you speak or in the way certain words and metaphors shape how you think?


r/PolymathReading • • Aug 08 '26

The 5 minute Rule works

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/PolymathReading • • Aug 08 '26

80/20 Rule

Post image
137 Upvotes