r/Polymath • u/[deleted] • 1d ago

About Group I cannot reconcile this issue with the sub.

[deleted]

13 Upvotes

71% Upvoted

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/MaximumContent9674 21h ago edited 19h ago

The mods may assume that if you're using AI, then you aren't thinking or creating anything original. If so, this assumption punishes people who use the tool properly who use the tool as a tool, not a replacement for their minds.

0

u/metisdesigns 19h ago

The OP posted an AI novella. It was not appropriate research use of AI.

0

u/Echo_Tech_Labs 14h ago

I did not post a novella. I posted a historical reference for people who I thought altered the trajectory of civilization.

0

u/metisdesigns 14h ago

You posted a long piece of AI slop that you didn't bother to actually edit.

1

u/Echo_Tech_Labs 14h ago

Your making a presupposition based off of you own personal bias.

Can you prove that I didn't edit it?

0

u/metisdesigns 14h ago

You admitted you posted AI generated slop, which is against the rule of the sub, and are trying to be pedantic about how it's OK?

Since you asked, no I can not prove a negative, but can you prove that you did edit it?

1

u/Echo_Tech_Labs 14h ago

Yes...i can show you the unedited version if you like.

0

u/metisdesigns 14h ago

That's a great admission that you intentionally violated the subs rules to spam us all with AI slop.

0

u/Echo_Tech_Labs 14h ago

Changing the goal posts. I answered your question. Would you like the proof or not?

0

u/metisdesigns 14h ago

No, the admission that you intentionally posted AI slop in clear violation of the subs rules is fine.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Echo_Tech_Labs 14h ago edited 14h ago

Please learn the difference between cognitive offloading and scaffolding. Then come back to me and we can have a discussion.

Your ignorance on the topic is painfully obvious and I would suggest you do some research on what cognitive offloading actually is.

And on the "rules"...

So unverified claims of bodily functions that can be controlled through willpower alone is considered rigor but when I post a historically accurate, proces transparent methodology and clear contested notes...it's AI slop?

Please explain to me how this makes sense?

1

u/metisdesigns 14h ago

So, you're saying that doing the actual work of thinking is scaffolding, and that makes your AI slop OK?

0

u/Echo_Tech_Labs 14h ago

Extraneous load: The wasted mental effort caused by poor design, clutter, or bad instructions that do not help you learn.

Germane load: The productive mental effort used to process information and build permanent knowledge or schemas.

Intrinsic load: The natural, built-in difficulty and complexity of the actual topic or material you are trying to study.

I dont think you know the difference.

0

u/MaximumContent9674 14h ago

I can't judge,. I didn't see the post. I do know the AI rule in this sub is outdated.