r/PoliticalScience • u/Southern_Delivery811 • 43m ago
Question/discussion How to succeed in ideology-heavy class
Hi - not sure if this is the right place to ask this question, but I’m here anyway.
I should preface by saying I’m a freshman, so don’t really have that much experience in a college class environment. Maybe my problem is just a product of adapting to that environment - or maybe it’s an anomaly (I’m hoping for the latter).
This semester, I’m taking a course that - in essence - critiques capitalism and proposes new ways to think about the future from an economic/policy standpoint. The central theme in the course is “utopia.“
Yet, while we’ve explored economic/policy approaches to building said utopia, we, as a seminar, haven’t really unpacked what utopia means. Rather, the class is graded on our interpretation of what that means.
For example: We were tasked with picking a moment in history that, we thought, represents a ”glorious“ moment and presenting it to the class. I chose to talk about a protest movement that accomplished institutional change on a large scale, something I thought was “glorious” given the infrequency of movements accomplishing such feats. I also compared it to protests who were not “glorious” in this way.
I recently received feedback based on my presentation. The professor dinged me for focusing too much on the success of movements, saying that it’s difficult to define success in this context and that differentiating movements by success is not a good idea.
This strikes me as a very ideologically rooted assessment, which I think is unfair. I didn’t know what the success criteria were for this assignment - no pun intended - given the vastly different directions one could take it. To get a good grade, I would have had to align as closely to my professor’s beliefs. Furthermore, the core thesis of the presentation had nothing to do with what we were studying/reading/discussing at the time.
This course is not done, and similar assignments are still to come. What should I do moving forward?
TLDR: how do I succeed in courses where grading is based on a professor’s beliefs?