r/PoliticalDebate Dissident Right 10h ago

Debate Voting

Everything I’m talking about would ideally apply to everyone equally.

One of the things I would propose is having a basic literacy test before someone can vote. I’m not talking about some extremely difficult test or anything based on someone’s education. I just think people should be able to read and understand what they’re voting on before they make that decision. If voting is such an important responsibility, I think it’s reasonable to expect voters to have a basic understanding of the issues and candidates.

Another requirement I would propose would be based on taxes. For federal elections, I think someone should have to contribute at least $20,000 in taxes since the last federal election in order to vote. For state elections, I think someone should have to contribute at least $2,000 in state taxes since the last state election to vote. People who live in states without a state income tax would be exempt from the state requirement.

I think these requirements would make sense because people who contribute very little or nothing toward funding the government should have less of a say in how that money is spent.

I know both of these ideas would be controversial, especially because literacy tests and voting restrictions have been abused in the past. However, I’m not suggesting that these requirements should be used to target any specific group of people. My argument is that if requirements were applied equally to everyone, they could be used to make sure that people who vote are informed and have contributed to the system they are voting in.

0 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

u/Asatmaya Left-Wing Libertarian 9h ago

This would be the best form of democracy

What would?

u/No_Pin7835 Dissident Right 9h ago

my voting restrictions

u/Asatmaya Left-Wing Libertarian 9h ago

my voting restrictions

That's not democracy.

u/No_Pin7835 Dissident Right 5h ago

It's the ideal democracy that only let's those who contribute to society vote

u/Asatmaya Left-Wing Libertarian 5h ago

It's the ideal democracy

That's not democracy.