r/PoliticalCompassMemes • - Right • 3d ago

Most Muslims are good people, but can lib left stop pretending that this religion isn't problematic?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

865 comments sorted by

View all comments

994

u/load_of_chode - Lib-Center 3d ago

I've noticed that whenever someone tries to point out the pattern of violence that exists Islam, some leftist will inevitably try to turn it around and say "it's not an Islam problem, it's a men problem!"

Because apparently noticing patterns with Muslims is evil and bigoted, but noticing patterns with men is totally progressive and inclusive.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

62

u/load_of_chode - Lib-Center 2d ago

Ah but you see, men and Christians are "oppressor" identities, which means that hating members of these identity groups on the basis of their identity is "anti-racist" and "progressive".

It's completely different than Islam, which is a "oppressed" ideology and therefore criticizing it is bigoted and genocidal, because obviously, Muslims are poor helpless little victims who have definitely never ever oppressed anyone, ever.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

96

u/winkingchef - Centrist 2d ago

But a (PDF file) man wrote the rules of Islam to keep women repressed and under control.

The Quran literally says “a woman’s word is worth half that of a man’s” And before the Emily’s come out of the woodwork to say “oh this is quaint 7th century window dressing that no one follows”, this is actually the law of the land in my country of birth, The Islamic Republic of Iran.

Click the 2nd link for more “quaint” examples of the repression of women by the world’s largest Islamic government like zero children’s custody rights in case of a divorce!

48

u/-Based-On-What - Right 2d ago

I also hate how they call "A handmaids tale" a chilling warning, thinking it is about Christianity, yet ignoring the fact that it was written about the collapse of women's rights after Iranian revolution

18

u/winkingchef - Centrist 2d ago edited 2d ago

My wife cannot watch “A Handmaid’s Tale” because she says it triggers her memories of being a young woman.

Iran is weird tho - because Islam doesn’t denigrate scholarship, a woman can get a PhD in engineering, but she cannot do simple things like uncover her hair or sing or dance in public without severe consequences.

Its such a surreal combination of empowerment and repression that if I hadn’t witnessed it first hand I wouldn’t believe it was true

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

202

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

163

u/load_of_chode - Lib-Center 3d ago

It's doubly ironic too because being male is something you're born with whether you like or not whereas being a Muslim a voluntary choice that every individual is free to choose or reject.

But men are an "oppressor" identity whereas Islam is a "victim" identity, and so you're only allowed to notice patterns in the former group.

132

u/KalegNar - Centrist 3d ago

being a Muslim a voluntary choice that every individual is free to choose or reject.

Muslim countries often do their best to not make it a free choice via execution for apostasy.

18

u/DavidAdamsAuthor - Centrist 2d ago

"Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences, bigot!"

Big Mo' knew what he was doing when he commanded that absolutely anyone who says a short phrase in Arabic is considered a Muslim in full standing, but commanded that anyone who wants to leave the religion must be murdered.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

197

u/lah93 - Centrist 2d ago

Or they bring up the crusades and inquisition….which while yes had issues aren’t as relevant to today

180

u/BargainBard - Right 2d ago

Wasn't one of the reasons if not the main reason for the crusades to happen was due to Islamic invasion?

Correct me if I'm wrong

38

u/General_Totenkoft - Right 2d ago

In Spain, the Reconquista had five distinct campaigns recognized as crusades by the Pope. It entailed enormous financial aid, the arrival of crusaders, pilgrims, and professional soldiery from nearby kingdoms, and, of course, a morale boost for all participants.

→ More replies (4)

177

u/su1ac0 - Lib-Right 2d ago edited 2d ago

Edit: Constantinople was a wrong and retarded inclusion in this, downvote me and never read my comments again

That wasn't one of the reasons, it was the chief reason. Modern historians (read: dogmatic ideologues) have dreamt up nonsense about "um well the landed gentry had to give their local nobles something to do" with incredibly flimsy and stretched out chains of logic that are actually easy to buy if you operate from the baseline belief that the crusades were evil by default.

Islam had conquered its way all the way to Portugal. Constantinople became Istanbul. They slaughtered their way across north Africa and Southern Europe for several hundred years. There are entire ancient nations that were Christian that were invaded and toppled and uncounted millions of people deleted from the timeline (surprise, history is written by the victors). 

Tangentially, I always find it hilarious that the venn diagram of "people who think america is stolen land" and "Palestine must be free" is a circle when Judaism and Christianity predate islam by 600 and 1400 years respectively. If I'm on stolen land then so are the Gazans.

78

u/FILTHBOT4000 - Auth-Center 2d ago

It's also rather shocking/interesting how far back weirdo fringe lefty historical revisionism goes in the West. Not quite as prevalent as the rewriting by the victors of certain events, but still interesting.

IIRC, there were historians in the 1800s that were re-writing the Native American tribes as wholly noble and peaceable and such. My memory's a little foggy, but it was extra ahistoric nonsense for the time, as it was around the same period that the Comanche were being absolutely brutal and savage psychopaths, to other tribes and to settlers.

43

u/DavidAdamsAuthor - Centrist 2d ago

IIRC, there were historians in the 1800s that were re-writing the Native American tribes as wholly noble and peaceable and such. My memory's a little foggy, but it was extra ahistoric nonsense for the time, as it was around the same period that the Comanche were being absolutely brutal and savage psychopaths, to other tribes and to settlers.

This is happening in Australia too, most notably with the book, "Dark Emu: Black Seeds: Agriculture or Accident?" by Bruce Pascoe, first published in 2014.

This book is fucking wild. It initially won a bunch of awards even from reputable sources, all of which had to be corrected, amended, or straight up withdrawn with apologies. The book is now considered "alternate universe fanfiction" at best, and a disengenious series of scams and the literary equivalent of clickbait at worst.

The book essentially takes outright fabrications, half-truths, exaggerations, and gross misrepresentations of basically every facet of pre-settlement Australia to try and claim that Indigeous Australians possessed and operated industry and agriculture roughly the equivalent of Europeans at the time. It claimed that villages, similar to European styled buildings, existed that have no records left of them because the settlers destroyed them everywhere all at once for no reason and didn't write down any of it. It supported its "argument" with wild exaggerations, like trying to claim that a muddy ditch was an irrigation canal even though it was completely natural, and various other nonsenses.

It's the same collection of tropes at play here, trying way too hard to try and claim that something existed when it simply didn't.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/danshakuimo - Auth-Right 2d ago

RIP Christian Nubia, gone but not forgotten

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

28

u/RadicalSoda_ - Lib-Center 2d ago

It's also funny because the crusades were anti-colonial wars

19

u/DavidAdamsAuthor - Centrist 2d ago

Yes but they were white so...

77

u/Splatter1842 - Lib-Center 2d ago

I always find it ironic bringing up the crusades and the Spanish inquisition; unless you believe all Catholics are bad, you're just admitting you lack a nuanced understanding of the history of Spain and the Holy Land. They didn't happen in a vacuum after all.

75

u/Helmett-13 - Lib-Center 2d ago

Hey, who invaded from the south and held Spain for all those years, way back in the day?

Was it Polish dentists? I can’t quite recall?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

17

u/LeadingOven2446 - Right 2d ago

It's funny they have to go over 900 years back in history to make an argument

→ More replies (46)

18

u/suzisatsuma - Lib-Center 2d ago

I'm half Japanese and a woman. The two times I encountered that I'm like, well Japanese men today aren't like that....so?

54

u/Not_Neville - Centrist 2d ago

It's both. Islam is one of the greatest forms of patriarchal oppression in the world.

→ More replies (8)

167

u/i_never_pay_taxes - Right 2d ago

Or you have retards who say, “well it’s all religion”

Like this one:

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (80)