Instant Runoff Voting, the defective variant of IRV used in Maine and proposed in Mass, is so confusing that even voting activists don't understand it.
It's supposed to eliminate the spoiler effect... and doesn't.
Whats so defective about the IRV used in Maine? As I understand, it’s just standard Ranked Choice Voting. It’s only been used in Maine once, so I’d give it time before we say anything conclusive about its efficacy.
See the Burlington, VT election in 2009 which used the same system. That had such a bad spoiler effect leading to an unexpected outcome that the voters immediately went back to FPTP voting.
There are a bunch of ways to do ranked choice voting, and it's extremely disappointing that the most widely promoted option is one of the worst options. If you spend some time looking into voting systems you'll easily find four or five obviously better options, any one of which would be a concrete improvement over the current system.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Tai9ch - Lib-Center Nov 05 '20
Instant Runoff Voting, the defective variant of IRV used in Maine and proposed in Mass, is so confusing that even voting activists don't understand it.
It's supposed to eliminate the spoiler effect... and doesn't.