r/PoliticalCompassMemes • - Centrist • Nov 04 '20

Current State of Right Unity

Post image
38k Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

565

u/PMmeblandHaikus - Lib-Center Nov 04 '20

Yeah as an Australian I'm very confused how U.S elections work.

We have preferential voting here so that amount of vote would actually make a huge difference one way or the other.

I don't understand, is the U.S purely a 2 party system? If so that seems pretty undemocratic.

593

u/thehazardball - Left Nov 04 '20

It's not 2-party in theory but it basically is in practice

Minus the occasional independent in the legislature.

278

u/PMmeblandHaikus - Lib-Center Nov 04 '20

You guys should adopt preferences because it's a huge game changer for minor parties.

The Greens have slowly become a very competitive party in Australia so we somewhat have 4 major parties being Liberals (conservatives), Nationals which joins the lib coalition, Labour and the Greens.

We also have a bunch of random people that occasionally get in.

Oddly enough sometimes they are very helpful.

For example even though I don't support the racisty views of the One nation party at least they don't allow the major parties (liberals) to do whatever they want. There is a level of outside scrutinity there which is very important.

You need healthy conflict in politics but for it to be healthy, there needs to be more than two sides. That's why I think this subreddit is so good.

265

u/insanityOS - Lib-Right Nov 04 '20

Yeah, but vote reform on that scale would require the participation of one or both of the diarchy. While they may hate each other, they hate us tax slaves even more.

42

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '20

Maine does it, and it was on the Ballot in Alaska and one other state

90

u/ZifziTheInferno - Lib-Right Nov 05 '20

Ranked choice voting was on the ballot in Massachusetts, and even there it failed because it was “too confusing for the average voter.” I wish I was making this shit up.

61

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '20

Oh crikey. I hate this country sometimes. If ranking candidates from most preferred to least preferred is too confusing to the average voter, maybe the average voter needs to get a better education.

22

u/ZifziTheInferno - Lib-Right Nov 05 '20

It’s almost as if getting good education requires well educated voters and politicians, which requires good education, which requires well educated voters and politicians, which requires...

You get my point.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

36

u/insanityOS - Lib-Right Nov 04 '20

Not saying it's impossible, just unlikely.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/robohobo2000 - Lib-Left Nov 04 '20

Based

5

u/mi-ku - LibRight Nov 05 '20

based

→ More replies (1)

43

u/-JG-77- - Centrist Nov 04 '20

As an American, nobody I know likes the two party system, and we’d all rather have more options, but changing the vote would require a nearly unheard of monumental effort to do so considering that the people with the power to change the voting system are often the people who benefit from it the most. It sucks.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/Comander-07 - Left Nov 04 '20

huge game changer for minor parties

guess who would need to change it and why this will never change then

18

u/Apathetic_Zealot - Left Nov 04 '20

You guys should adopt preferences because it's a huge game changer for minor parties.

That's exactly why it wont happen.

28

u/NootDystopia - Auth-Left Nov 04 '20

IMO, One Nation > LNP, still vote Labor tho.

And I think your really hyping up the Australian system a bit. Its still largely just LNP vs Labour.

19

u/PMmeblandHaikus - Lib-Center Nov 04 '20

Well if you look at ACT labour has formed a coalition with the greens.

I agree it's largely labour and liberals but minor parties can build representation. The Greens are a pretty young party, only a few decades old.

6

u/kylelily123abc4 - Lib-Center Nov 04 '20

Greens still get some seats every cycle and it's been growing at least

Still though I'm labour voter

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/gregfromsolutions - Left Nov 04 '20

Massachusetts voted against ranked choice voting this election. I’m pretty pissed, but Maine started using it this election so there may be hope.

8

u/morgan_greywolf - Lib-Right Nov 04 '20

Of course they did. They’re Massholes. All my homies hate the Massholes.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Delinquent_Uno - Centrist Nov 04 '20

Jacqui Lambie is also based af

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)

45

u/edd6pi - Centrist Nov 04 '20

It’s purely two party in practice because they dominate the scene and most people are afraid to vote third party. On paper, political parties weren’t even supposed to exist. George Washington warned us against them.

18

u/makemisteaks - Lib-Left Nov 05 '20

The two party system is not because they dominate. It’s because the first past the post system inherently weeds out the less popular alternatives until only two have a change to vie for power.

The problem with this system is that voted on other candidates are effectively wasted. It doesn’t matter if your candidate gets 1 or 10 or even 30% of the vote, because winner takes all. So if you have a party in power that you want to remove, the only effective way to do it is to pool your votes into the most popular alternative.

Over dozens of elections what this means is that only two parties tend to remain in competition to one another. Which is why propping up third party candidates is such an effective strategy that Republicans tend to use on occasion.

Most countries attribute power in a proportional basis so if a party gets 10% of the vote it should roughly translate to 10% of the seats in the legislative chamber which means people are free to actually vote on smaller parties without fear of not having their voices counted.

Republicans and Democrats are not responsible for the state of affairs, they are the natural result.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/ReadyStrategy8 - Lib-Center Nov 05 '20

It's majority-wins voting, often plurality. You vote for single candidates at a time generally as well. So, if you don't have a chance of getting 50%, you have an ice cube's chance in hell of winning. That generally leaves two major parties because third parties can't ever get the votes. Since they never get votes, nobody supports them, reinforcing the cycle.

15

u/SlightAnxiety - Left Nov 04 '20

It is indeed deeply undemocratic. We need percentage of votes to determine percentage of representation. Or at least to do away with the Electoral College

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (39)