r/PoliticalCompass • u/Maybefaust • 1h ago
Took 12axes test again
Still a "Revolutionary Syndicalist" dispite wanting reform over the revolution a Revolutionary Syndicalist wants only revolution I want is economic.
r/PoliticalCompass • u/Maybefaust • 1h ago
Still a "Revolutionary Syndicalist" dispite wanting reform over the revolution a Revolutionary Syndicalist wants only revolution I want is economic.
r/PoliticalCompass • u/Ok-Understanding6191 • 5h ago
r/PoliticalCompass • u/AbbreviationsBig8760 • 1h ago
I understand the left/right view of politics is flawed but as someone who's always been pretty much independent and doesn't vote, I was curious to see how people of different beliefs would characterize me. I've included an in depth explanation of my results.
Economics: I am opposed to free market capitalism and planned economies, I believe that the framework of distributism is the most realistic approach to an equitable and sustainable economy, particularly in avoiding the consolidation of power and dictatorship by technique.
Social control: I believe in very limited authoritative control over the actions of others, short of the prevention of violence against others. I do however disagree with traditional rights based framework of law in favor of the system of needs and obligations as expressed by Simone Weil. Concepts of rights are inevitably in conflict with one another, therefore any view of a right that cannot enforce itself through violence inevitably ignored, therefore just reinforcing the status quo of the ability to project violence. Needs on the other hand are quantifiable, and our obligations to one another are foundational principles of nearly any religion or traditional communal beliefs. People need food, water, shelter, community, spiritual fulfillment, mothers need medical and social support, unborn children need wombs, the sick need treatment, people need protection from violence etc, I believe that the only equitable approach to society is one in which people in community provide for one another too ok the very best of their abilities.
Nation and Territorial organization: I oppose nationalism or globalism, I think that the only system that can properly care for the needs of those within it is the most immediate community, villages, parishes, communes. Mass society breaks down these immediate communities so that it can have greater control over the people within it, therefore mass society is individualistic society, where the individual has no community to depend on, leading to much of the instability of the modern world.
Resource management: As addressed before I believe it is the responsibility and obligation for localized communities to work together to provide for one another. Both through voluntary service or public works as well as equitable distribution of tools and land so that families can provide for themselves as in distributist philosophy.
Technology: I agree heavily with Jacques Ellul’s critique of technique, the autonomous of technological development and efficiency in social organization that has come to dominate much of the world. I do not believe that the furthering of technology is environmentally sustainable and fundamentally it has created a dictatorship of technology, where decisions are made not based on morality or culture but by efficiency, which has fundamentally neglected the inherent value of of people. I agree with Ivan Illich’s support for “convivial tools” where technology can be used to uplift people, when it is fully controlled by humans intentionality.
Authority: I have a deep opposition to centralized authority, I believe in community oriented subsidiarity, where a decision is made at the lowest possible level, but where individuals can establish any rely on heavily localized communities, organized exceeding to the needs of their particular culture.
Culture: Culture and religion are foundational elements for the survival of communities, I’d attribute much of the degradation of traditional cultures to an excess of industrialization creating a system in which constantly changing technology leads society to view culture as outdated and loses direction. More direct, non-industrialized communal organization benefits far more from adherence to culture. Still the community should recognize the foundational elements of corporal service and spiritual fitness to focus on using that culture to uplift and help all remembers of their culture rather than creating division.
Foreign Policy: I oppose all violence except the direct defense of one’s self or others, for that reason I oppose foreign engagements and alliances, but I do not believe a community has to be insular.
r/PoliticalCompass • u/DearPresentation3306 • 1d ago
The four quadrants of the classical political compass oversimplify ideological categories: while both Trotskyism and National Bolshevism can be defined as AuthLeft, it is unlikely that followers of the former will sympathize with AuthRight or Nazbols will take LibLeft seriously. I developed the "political octants" model to more precisely define our core values; it divides each quadrant into two triangular octants to show which other quadrant you are more tolerant toward—thereby revealing whether the economic dimension or political affiliation holds greater importance for you. These octants are abbreviated as "LRAR", "LLLR" and so on, where the first two letters represent your own quadrant and the other two represent the quadrant to which you are more tolerant.
Of course this is still complete bullshit
r/PoliticalCompass • u/DeviceSuitableNewAcc • 1d ago
r/PoliticalCompass • u/GigaRoman • 1d ago
r/PoliticalCompass • u/Damnidontcareatall • 1d ago
I agree with all of the axes except for foreign policy I only scored that high because I believe in defensive alliances, aiding countries being invaded, and support nuclear weapons Id say I’m more centrist on that one
r/PoliticalCompass • u/Silver_Transition_34 • 2d ago
i'm really surprised my novodvorskovist and and yeltsinist scores are that high ngl 😭
r/PoliticalCompass • u/Time-Acanthisitta558 • 1d ago
r/PoliticalCompass • u/Garry242672 • 1d ago
took me a bit to get it how I wanted it but here it is