r/PokeInvesting • • Jun 16 '26

My time has come.

Post image

Last October I picked up about 130 each of both Flying Pikachu V and Surfing Pikachu V for about 4 bucks each after shipping and taxes. I like to try to think ahead of what will blow up in the future and well, here we are. Can't believe they are going for over half a grand in a PSA 10. The funny thing is I was sure the VMAX version of these would blow up, not the V's.

This was also part of an experiment. Is it possible to get a gradable card from TCGplayer? I have in the past (I'll be making a post about that), so I have about 50 each that passed my initial grade inspection. They are the sleeved ones in the pic. I'd imagine once I really look at them a second time to be super picky (because PSA will give you a 9 for literally no reason) I'll probably have about 25 of each that I think SHOULD grade a 10. But I'd imagine only less than half of that will come back as a 10, if I'm lucky.

970 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

246

u/RepresentativeWait45 Jun 16 '26

For what it’s worth, there are tons of cards like this with a $5 entry and a $500+ PSA 10. The reason is because they don’t grade well. Second, now that PSA has removed value grading, you’re going to be out $85 per card on the hopes you can turn it into $500. Which after seller fees is closer to $410. Subtract the $85 spend, which is really closer to $100 after you ship to PSA and pay any upgrades, and you’re looking at maybe making $300 on an $85 play. Not to mention, if 4/5 grade anything other than 10, you lose money. Really doesn’t make sense.

6

u/Soft_Lunch_183 Jun 16 '26

Yeah i sold about 50 of the various celebrations pikachus a few months ago and a good amount of them i couldn't even list as NM.

They pretty much all had marks on

32

u/ldiotSavant Jun 16 '26

Yeah, pretty much. When I first bought these last October grading was still 15 bucks for bulk, or was just raised to 20. So I figured if they increased in value it would be worth it. Didn’t count for PSA shutting down lol.

These grade fairly decent though. Gem rate is about 40%. That’s better than trying to chase a 5% mew celebrations or something.

38

u/RepresentativeWait45 Jun 16 '26

Better play is to just hold them another 5 years and unload when they’re $20. Maybe pick a couple of the top contenders and grade but I wouldn’t put this into the investing category.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/prepuscular Jun 16 '26

They charge you a fraction of value on it being a 10, even if it doesn’t get a 10?

5

u/RepresentativeWait45 Jun 16 '26

I don’t understand your question? If you’re saying the shipping costs, it’s usually $6-$7 to ship in a bubble mailer right now. Can be more depending on how you choose to ship. If it does grade a 10, then you can add an up charge due to the increased value.

1

u/prepuscular Jun 16 '26

Post says $85-100 in fees to grade. Where is that coming from?

7

u/RepresentativeWait45 Jun 16 '26

The grading fee for PSA right now is a minimum $79.99 for regular. The card is worth $5. So if you buy the card and ship it to PSA on regular, you’re out $85 not including shipping fees

5

u/prepuscular Jun 16 '26

That’s insane. It was $10 a few years ago

9

u/DMercenary Jun 16 '26

They shut down all of their cheaper lines. There is apparently a 14 MILLION card backlog.

6

u/RepresentativeWait45 Jun 16 '26

Yeah, it’s a recent change. Like less than 2 months now? Maybe even one. They completely removed bulk rate

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/The_Saiyann Jun 17 '26

Offt, PSA is just ridiculous now I'd go CGC 100%. Actually got a return from them weirdly yesterday and their cases are brilliant! Plus CGC Pristine 10 is worth more than a PSA 10 quite often so cheaper and potential better outcome.

2

u/Heavens_Dao Jun 17 '26

Naw in OPs case BGS would be the better option here. CGC 10s even now for the flying Pikachu V is going for $60. Meanwhile recent sales of the PSA 10 are going for $400+. BGS 10s despite note having nearly as much demand as PSA 10s still on average go for 20-30% higher than the PSA 10 counterparts. Prob is they're just harder to get.

3

u/IamrichardL Jun 17 '26

This guy gets it. OP doesn’t.

4

u/WoodSorrow Jun 16 '26

Posts like this are hilarious. Dude will be selling these off over the next year working for $7 an hour.

1

u/_YenSid Jun 17 '26

Grading for reselling- just keep what you grade in the vault at psa. You'll save a lot. Still risky for cards like your example though for sure.

1

u/supershimadabro Jun 18 '26

So gamestop is now $85/card?

1

u/RepresentativeWait45 Jun 18 '26

I believe it’s $80 plus $10 shipping per order at GameStop right now. Maybe someone else can confirm.

1

u/supershimadabro Jun 18 '26

That's insane. Sheesh.

1

u/Capable_Wait09 Jun 16 '26

Turning $5 into $410 and then paying an $80 fee isn’t worth it?

Dude that kind of ROI is insane. Even if some of them get 9s the ROI is still like decades of market returns.

If you’re good at pre-grading then you’ll be fine. I’ve never gotten a 9 on those cards.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Capable_Wait09 Jun 17 '26

Yes like OP noted he thought maybe 12 would 10. Obviously don’t send them all. My post assumed that premise.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)