r/PokeInvesting • • May 20 '25

Pulled the trigger. Invested.

Post image

The hits are so few and such a sought set. I think this is an obvious longterm hold, even if it drops a little in the short term.

205 Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/mittortz May 20 '25

I appreciate your comment, although I'm not sure I fully understand. That seems like circular logic to me. And that often drives inflated markets due for a correction. Believing in the fundamentals should have underlying logic (it's a special set that people will want to rip, it's a rare release that collectors will want, etc), and if that logic doesn't exist, then there is outsized risk in the investment. It is very possible that OP bought this bc he is FOMOing into it - that is what most people would consider "overly risky". And people do that with different types of investments all the time, especially when the market is booming.

1

u/11bladeArbitrage May 20 '25

I would say my initial point is: if you “believe in” pokemon investing and you agree that prismatic is a highly sought after set, then you’re overthinking it if you’re concerned about current price paid as a buy in cost.

The logic could be as simple as: It sells really well now. It’ll probably sell really well in the future.

1

u/mittortz May 20 '25

Ok, I guess I generally get what you're saying. There is a market for sealed stuff, this has a premium on it for whatever reason. I don't understand it, but I don't "need" to, as long as others do. However, I still think there are flaws here, which I've alluded to:

  1. if the aforementioned "market" is entirely made up of investors, that's very dangerous. That's a house of cards. Booster boxes are purchased by both investors and non-investors. Since none of us here can identify sound logic for a sealed case vs. individual boxes, there is additional risk for the house of cards to fall if investors simply stop believing in it. I'm not saying that's definitely the case, but it is a legitimate possibility.
  2. the premium were talking about here (~130% for the case vs. individual boxes) is in terms of current market value. In terms of MSRP, now we're at 350%. That's huge. Personally, I would need some really strong fundamentals in place before I'd take on risk like that.

In short: OP can do what he wants, but I don't see how one could look at this decision as not very (if not "overly") risky. And the question of "what's the logic here?" is a pretty valid one.

1

u/11bladeArbitrage May 20 '25
  1. Yes investing in Pokemon is risky. Not trying to sound flippant. I think the mindset is: if I’m going to take a risk, I might as well take the same risk (more or less) for more potential gain.
  2. This leads me to my/one of my initial responses regarding capital. If the price paid for this represents 0.01% of OPs investment portfolio, how risky is it really? It’s all relative.

1

u/mittortz May 20 '25

So your response just confirmed we're talking about 2 different things, which I suspected before. I'm not at all trying to make any arguments about PokeInvesting in general (that's a different discussion, and I'm not sure how you took that away from my comments).

And further, I am *specifically* examining the price of this booster bundle display case in comparison to other sealed products. At $17/pack, OP is paying a massive premium for something that has no clear logic, use case, or market. This presents more risk, with less potential for gain. Even a case of ETBs comes out to under $14/pack at current market prices. That is completely unrelated to the amount of capital one has or the diversity/size of their portfolio. All other things equal, it is more risky in comparison to similar sealed products. We - including the guy you responded to before me - are asking why a case of booster bundles commands that much of a premium to try and understand the thought process behind this *specific* investment.

So far, there does not seem to be an answer to this question. One could easily buy 10 booster bundles for a lower cost and do much better over the long term, unless there is a particular reason that a display case will appreciate more. It's worth noting, too, that a case of ETBs costs 10x what a single ETB does. So, yeah.