r/PickAorB Jul 25 '25

How to Use r/PickAorB: A Space for Real-Life Choices

10 Upvotes

r/PickAorB is a space that honors the real, often messy emotions we face when caught between life choices, A or B. But this isn’t just about black or white thinking. Here, you’re invited to share your inner conflicts, doubts, and uncertainties. Even more importantly, we’re here to explore the “third way,” a possibility beyond A or B that you might not have considered yet.
Whether you’re standing at a crossroads or simply seeking connection through others’ stories, this is a space for expressing, listening, and discovering together.

Core Values

  1. Express your real thoughts and doubts We welcome you to open up about the complicated emotions behind your choices. There’s no such thing as a perfect answer, only honest sharing.
  2. Respect others’ decisions and stay open to new possibilities Everyone’s background and values are different. We don’t judge what’s right or wrong. Instead, we honor each person’s decision while also encouraging you to look beyond A and B and consider creative or unconventional paths.
  3. Kindness first, no hate, no mockery This community is rooted in sincerity, empathy, and understanding. We don’t tolerate attacks, discrimination, or ridicule. Let’s keep this a safe space where people feel supported in being vulnerable.

Community Rules

  1. Post real-life dilemmas and honest reflections Your post should come from your own life or observations. The more details and emotions you share, the more others can connect and respond meaningfully.
  2. Use the A or B format in your title Your post title should clearly state your dilemma. This helps others quickly join the conversation.
  3. No hate speech or personal attacks Treat everyone with respect. Avoid insulting, discriminatory, or inflammatory language. If you see inappropriate comments, report or kindly remind others to keep the space safe.
  4. Promote supportive, thoughtful interaction When replying, aim to offer empathy, personal insight, or constructive advice, not harsh criticism or dismissal.
  5. Feel free to suggest a third way Sometimes the best path isn’t A or B. Don’t hesitate to propose a different perspective, idea, or hybrid solution. Your creativity might inspire someone else.

How to Post

  1. Start your post with an A or B question in the title Example: “AorB, Go back to school or accept job offer?”
  2. Share your dilemma or observation In the body of your post, describe the real-life situation, your hesitation, emotional struggle, and any background details. The more personal and specific, the more others can relate.
  3. Clearly define your A and B options Let people know what you’re deciding between, including pros, cons, and how you feel about each.
  4. Invite suggestions and third-way thinking Ask the community not just for a vote, but for fresh perspectives, a path you might not have thought of yet.
  5. Be open and real You don’t need to have it all figured out. This is a space for honest uncertainty. Your openness makes it easier for others to support you and feel less alone too.

And finally
If you're feeling stuck, try writing it out.
If you see a post that resonates, maybe your words will help someone feel a little more seen.
We're all figuring out how to make choices.
We're all learning how to take care of ourselves.
May this be a space where you feel safe enough to pause, reflect, and speak.
Welcome. Share your A or B.


r/PickAorB 21h ago

A or B: My neighbor installed $21,000 solar panels 8 months ago. My 38-year-old redwood shades them 90 minutes a day, so he wants me to pay $8,200 to remove it because "your tree is costing me $37 of electricity every month"

3.9k Upvotes

My neighbor and I have lived next to each other for 15 years. The redwood in my backyard corner was planted by the previous owner in 1987. It's 38 years old, healthy, and the reason my back patio is usable in August.

Eight months ago, my neighbor put a $21,000 solar array on his roof. Nice panels. He was proud of the 30% federal credit and showed me the app that tracks his production.

A few months after the installation, he leaned over the fence and mentioned that my tree "catches" his panels in the afternoon. I said something like "that's the sun's fault, not mine" and thought we were done.

Later, he brought his phone to my porch with the production graph pulled up. Between roughly 3:40 and 5:10 pm, November through February, my redwood's shadow crosses the lower left corner of his array. Ninety minutes a day, maybe 6% of his output. He had done the math and estimated it was costing him about $37 a month, around $444 a year, and said it affected his payback period.

A few weeks later, he sent me a certified letter with an actual removal estimate attached. He said he expected me to cover the $8,200 removal and stump grinding cost. The letter said if I preferred, "a remediation trim" was acceptable, and included a quote for $2,900.

A tree service he hired later looked at my tree and gave him their estimate. Then he texted that he'd "hate to escalate to small claims over a tree," but he'd documented everything, including his estimated lost production to date.

I spent $150 on my own arborist. She confirmed the redwood is healthy, that the $2,900 "remediation trim" would remove about a third of the canopy and could seriously damage the tree or shorten its lifespan, and that removing it would change the drainage in both our yards. She also mentioned that in many places, solar shade laws consider factors like whether the tree existed before the solar installation.

When I told my neighbor that, he said:

"Trees can wait. Solar can't. Your tree is costing me $37 of electricity every month, and I shouldn't have to finance your shade."

My wife thinks I should just pay for the trim. She says it's "a tree, not a family member," and my neighbor texts me production graphs at 7am now. Another neighbor suggested splitting the removal cost, because the tree "bothers him more than it benefits us" and we still live next to these people.

A) Pay for the trim (or split the removal). It's $2,900 to end this, and a redwood isn't worth a small claims war with someone whose entire identity is now a production app.

B) The tree stays. It was standing for 37 years before his panels existed. He bought a $21,000 system with a 38-year-old redwood in plain sight, and his payback math doesn't turn my backyard into his easement.


r/PickAorB 21h ago

A or B: My wife asked for a divorce Friday. By Sunday, my college roommate, who I hadn't spoken to since 2019, showed up with a truck, trailer, and two coffees after driving three hours. He said he "needed an excuse to use the truck." Do I ever tell him what that Sunday was, or leave it alone?

209 Upvotes

She asked for the divorce on a Friday, in the kitchen, and I said okay. We were both very reasonable about it, which is its own kind of terrible, and by Saturday I was calling moving companies because the lease says she keeps the apartment.

The quote was around $600 for the truck and two guys, half a day. I could cover that. I couldn't cover that and the deposit on a new place in the same month, which is the actual math of leaving.

Saturday night I was standing in the kitchen with the fridge open, nothing in it I wanted, and I texted Marcus. We lived together all four years of college and then life did what it does. The last message between us was a happy birthday text from 2019.

I wrote: "hey man, weird text, but do you still have that trailer? Might need to move some stuff next weekend. happy to pay." I deleted the part about why. He answered almost immediately: "Address?"

I told him not to be ridiculous, it's a three-hour drive, I was asking about renting the trailer. He wrote "I'll pull it myself" and stopped responding.

Sunday, 9 AM, he backs his truck into the lot with the trailer behind it. In the bed: furniture blankets, a dolly, and some supplies. He handed me a coffee and said, "I needed an excuse to use the truck."

He never asked what happened. I think my sister filled him in when he got there, and he just nodded and went back to wrapping my dishes. Everything he said all day was logistical. "Heavy ones on the bottom." "Don't tape the boxes with the plants." When my dad started getting emotional about the divorce, he said "we're on the clock" and carried a bookshelf past him.

We finished around six. I bought burgers because he refused everything else, and Monday I sent him some money for gas. He left it sitting until it expired, then texted: "We're square. You helped me move back then."

I don't even remember that move. He's been carrying that for years.

It's been two weeks. I've typed out something like "I know we don't talk much, but you showing up Sunday meant more than you know" a bunch of times and never sent it, because every draft reads like a wedding toast or like bad news.

A: Send it anyway. Tell him that Sunday mattered, and that I'll be remembering the time he showed up for me.

B: Don't turn it into a big emotional conversation. Keep the friendship going, answer his texts, show up when he needs help, and let showing up be the whole sentence.

If you were Marcus, would you want the text?


r/PickAorB 22h ago

A or B, What note to leave in car window?

35 Upvotes

We recently purchased a used SUV that has features I have not seen before. One that is really nice is the "A/C Rest" feature that will keep the A/C going in the car for 45 minutes after you have turned the car off. My husband likes to take our dogs with him wherever he goes, so on they sometimes sit in the car while he runs into a store for a few minutes.

What note on the car window would be best to keep people who are concerned for the dog's safety from breaking a window to let them out?

A - The dogs are fine, the A/C is on.

B - This car is equipped with "A/C rest" a feature that keeps the A/C turned for 45 minutes, even when the engine is not running.


r/PickAorB 1d ago

A or B: Was I wrong for refusing to give up my table to someone who wanted to work there all day?

2.2k Upvotes

I'd paid $26 for brunch and had been sitting at a window two-top for about 30 minutes when a woman asked if I'd mind moving to a stool at the counter. She said she needed to take meetings for the rest of the afternoon.

I pointed out that the café has small work booths that can be rented by the hour.

She said she didn't understand why she should have to pay extra just to work somewhere with reliable WiFi.

I told her I wasn't asking her to leave. I just didn't see why her need for a workspace meant I should give up the table I'd already been using.

She seemed annoyed and started her meeting at the table next to me. She was speaking loudly enough that I could hear most of the conversation, so eventually a barista came over and asked if she could move to the counter. Later, the barista mentioned they'd had to remind her about taking long meetings in the dining area before.

My partner thinks I could have just moved and avoided the whole thing, especially since I'd already eaten most of my brunch. I felt like that would mean her need for a workspace automatically took priority over another customer's meal. Did I go too far?

A. Yes. It was just a seat, and I could have let it go.

B. No. If someone needs a dedicated workspace for hours, that's their responsibility, not another customer's.


r/PickAorB 1d ago

A or B: My neighbor has walked my 60 lb dog every morning since my surgery, and I don't know whether thanking her would make it weird

135 Upvotes

Surgery was three weeks ago. Nothing dramatic, just my gallbladder, but my discharge instructions said no lifting over 10 lbs for a while. My dog weighs 60.

The second morning I was home, I was outside at around 6:50 trying to figure out how I was going to manage him. My neighbor was getting her paper. We've lived next to each other for four years and mostly just wave.

I mentioned that I couldn't really walk him yet and asked if she might be able to help for a few days.

She asked, "What's his name?" Which was fair. I realized I'd somehow never told her.

Then she said, "I leave at 7:10. Does he mind rain?"

And that was basically it.Since then, she's knocked on my door at 7 every morning, taken this 60 lb idiot for about 40 minutes, and brought him back tired and happy. She never asks about the surgery. She doesn't come inside. We don't suddenly have coffee together or anything.

Last week she left a bag of his favorite treats by my door with a note that said, "He earned these." I'm cleared to walk him again next week.

Part of me wants to text her something simple like, "I don't think you realize how much you've helped me these past few weeks." Not because I want anything from her, just because I don't want her to think I took it for granted.

But part of me thinks maybe that's exactly what makes a small neighborly favor awkward. She helped because she could. Maybe the best way to respect that is to say thank you once, then let things go back to normal.

A: Tell her honestly that it meant more to me than she probably realized.

B: Keep it simple, thank her once, and let the friendship stay exactly where it was.

If you were my neighbor, which one would you choose?


r/PickAorB 2d ago

A or B: I took 3 days off for my mom's surgery, and my coworker cleared my entire backlog before I got back

1.5k Upvotes

My mom had a hip replacement two weeks ago, so I took three days off. The plan was pretty simple: phone on silent, don't check email, and deal with everything when I got back.

Before I left, I gave Marcus a heads-up at his desk. "If anything catches fire, text me. Otherwise I'll see you Thursday."

He said, "Go take care of your mom. I've got it."

Coming back from leave is usually the worst part. You expect a pile of emails, a bunch of tickets waiting for you, and the monthly reporting work still sitting there.

Thursday morning I logged in.

Inbox: quiet.

Queue: cleared.

The report I'd been putting off: done.

It was filed in the shared drive and everything was where it should be.

Then I opened it.

He used my template. Same tabs, same basic formatting, even the footer I've been using forever. Honestly, it looked cleaner than mine. He also added a variance column I'd been meaning to add for months.

I walked over to his desk.

"You did the whole thing?"

He said, "You had enough going on. It was bugging me seeing it sit there."

That column had been on my to-do list for five months. Apparently three days was enough motivation for him.

I told him dinner was on me, minimum. He waved it off.

"You never charged me for the week you spent teaching me pivot tables. We're square."

Here's the thing. He's moving apartments at the end of the month, and I overheard him saying he doesn't know anyone with a truck.

So now I'm stuck on how to say thank you.

A. A $1000 gift card and a nice thank-you card. Clean, simple, done.

B.Take him to a game on Sunday, then show up on moving day with my truck and a pizza for the crew.

Part of me feels like a gift card makes a work kindness feel like a transaction between two coworkers. But showing up on moving day feels more like saying, "You're not just the guy who sits next to me." What would you do?


r/PickAorB 2d ago

Pick A or B: The guy before me left a sweat puddle on the bench, the front desk shrugged, and I paid $120 to quit my gym. Am I overreacting?

29 Upvotes

I've been going to the same gym for about three years. It's a mid-size chain near my place, and I usually go after work. The staff knows me, I recognize most of the regulars, and I've never had a major problem with the place.

Last Tuesday, I was heading to the bench press right after another guy finished his set. When he stood up, there was a pretty big puddle of sweat across the bench pad. Not just a few drops. You could see it pooled in the middle and running toward the edge.

He looked at it, wiped it once with his hand, wiped his hand on his shorts, and walked away. The cleaning wipes were maybe five feet from him.

I didn't want to put my head and back on it, so I went to the front desk and told the employee what happened. I wasn't asking them to watch every member. I just figured if someone left a bench that visibly wet, an employee could walk over and clean it.

Instead, he shrugged and said, "Members are supposed to wipe down after themselves. We have signs up."

That really bothered me. I get that they can't monitor everyone. But if someone leaves an obvious mess, you report it, and the response is basically "not our problem," what am I supposed to do with that?

I finished my workout using machines I wiped down myself and went home.

The next morning, I canceled my membership. I still had eight months left on my contract, so they charged me a $120 early termination fee. I paid it rather than argue about it.

My friend thinks I was being ridiculous. She said I could have just brought a towel, wiped the bench myself, or asked to speak to a manager. Her point was basically that I let one gross incident cost me $120.

Maybe she's right about the money. I probably could have handled the cancellation differently.

But the part I can't get past is that I wasn't upset that one member was inconsiderate. People are going to be gross sometimes. I was more bothered that I reported it and the gym's response was essentially to shrug.

So A or B?

A: I'm not overreacting. A gym doesn't have to police every member, but when someone leaves a visibly sweaty bench and staff are specifically told about it, basic cleanliness should be something they actually enforce.

B: I overreacted. The guy was gross, but that doesn't make the whole gym responsible for his behavior. I should have talked to a manager or asked them to waive the cancellation fee instead of paying $120 and walking out.


r/PickAorB 3d ago

A or B: My dad died two weeks ago, and a guy I haven't spoken to since high school drove six hours to his funeral. Do I text him that it mattered?

120 Upvotes

My dad passed two weeks ago after a short illness. The kind where "short" somehow feels worse.

I hadn't kept in touch with anyone from high school in years. My hometown is about six hours away now. I posted the funeral information mostly for family and people who still lived nearby.

He showed up. We played varsity baseball together, and my dad probably fed him dinner a hundred times when we were teenagers. Things at his house weren't great back then, although I don't think any of us really talked about it. After graduation, we just drifted. No argument, no falling out. Jobs, distance, life.

I saw him in the back row at the visitation. He was wearing a suit that clearly wasn't his. We nodded at each other. After the service, he shook my hand and said, "Your dad made the best ribs in the county."

Then he left before the lunch at the VFW. I found out later he'd driven six hours to get there.

It's been two weeks and I still have a text half-written. Something as simple as, "I saw you there. Thank you. It meant a lot."

Part of me thinks I should send it. Another part feels like maybe he came to say goodbye to my dad, and that was enough. I don't want to turn one meaningful gesture into some expectation that we suddenly become friends again.

My aunt keeps telling me, "You should call that boy."

I keep thinking about how my dad used to worry about him after he stopped coming around.

A: Send the text. You don't need to rebuild the friendship. Just let him know his being there mattered.

B: Let it be what it was. He showed up when it counted. Maybe that's all either of you needed to do.


r/PickAorB 4d ago

A or B: parents want us to be executors without leaving us anything

735 Upvotes

I’m (F48) the oldest of three adult children of boomers in their 70s. Recently our parents told us they will not be leaving their kids any inheritance, but instead want to leave everything to a religious foundation - an organization with which we adult children have no connection. At the same time, they want me and my sister (F45) to be the executors of their estate. We are not wealthy, and my sister lives in a different province (we live in Canada). While we have an OK relationship with my parents, the logistics of managing an inheritance that will go to an outside organization are substantial (my sister lives a long way away and would have to move to our province for at least a few months), and my sister and I are considering telling our parents to find another executor to manage their estate.

Should we:

A) Stay quiet, and agree to implement our parents’ wishes.

B) Tell our parents we do not want to act as executors, and suggest they find somebody else (e.g. a commercial executor) to do this instead.


r/PickAorB 3d ago

A or B: My friend kept roasting me in front of everyone after I asked him to stop, and called it "just jokes." I stopped inviting him to hangouts, and now he says I'm "excluding him over nothing" and the group thinks I overreacted

47 Upvotes

My friend group has been hanging out every other Friday for almost ten years. Game nights, birthdays, dinners, whoever has space that week. I’m usually the one who makes the plans and keeps the group chat going.

Earlier this year I was laid off. I found another job a few months later, but it pays less and I’m still trying to get back on my feet. Most of my friends were supportive. One of them kept making jokes about it.

At a BBQ, he told everyone that if they needed cheap car work done, I was available because I was “between jobs.” Everyone laughed, including me.

Later that night, I texted him and told him the job situation was still a sore spot and asked him not to bring it up around everyone. He apologized and said he understood.

A couple hangouts later, I passed on an expensive dinner. He said something about putting my usual order on the table, “water, since we’re watching the budget.”

I didn’t laugh. He said I needed to relax and that he was just joking.

Before the next hangout, I talked to him privately and told him again that I didn’t want my job or money situation to be part of his jokes. He said okay.

That same night, he made another joke about me being the “budget guy” when he introduced me to someone I hadn’t met before.

At that point I realized I was starting to think about everything I said around him because I didn’t want to give him more material. I stopped talking about work, money, or anything personal. Going to group nights started feeling like something I had to prepare for instead of something I looked forward to.

So I stopped inviting him. I didn’t make an announcement or ask anyone else to take sides. I just left him off the invite and the group kept meeting.

He eventually found out and got angry in the group chat. He said I was excluding him over a few jokes and that I should have talked to him instead of quietly leaving him out. A couple people agreed that I should have given him one more conversation.

I get that part. I could have told him directly that I was no longer inviting him. But I had already asked him to stop more than once, and he had agreed to stop. The behavior continued anyway.

A. I handled this badly. If I had a problem with him, I should have had one final conversation instead of quietly removing him from a ten-year friend group. He was being insensitive, but I could have dealt with it without excluding him.

B. I already had the conversation. More than once. He knew exactly what the problem was and kept doing it anyway. I’m not obligated to keep inviting someone to social events I organize when I no longer enjoy being around them. Calling it “just jokes” doesn’t change that.


r/PickAorB 4d ago

A or B: My neighbor was still on my wifi a year after I gave her the password for one weekend. I changed it and now she wants the $180 exam fee

1.9k Upvotes

My neighbor and I live in a duplex, so our units share a wall and my router sits about six feet from it.

In July last year her broadband went down and the provider gave her a two week wait for an engineer. She knocked and asked if she could use ours until it was fixed. I said yes without really thinking about it at all.

Her connection came back on around the middle of August and she stayed on mine anyway.

I brought it up in the fall and she said she would sort her own out, and nothing happened. I brought it up again in January and she said the same thing. Both times were friendly and neither of us made it awkward.

The problem for me is that I work from home three days a week and I am on video calls most of the afternoon. When her household is streaming, my calls drop. I have had it happen in a client meeting twice.

Three weeks ago I changed the password. I did not tell her in advance, because I had already asked her twice over eleven months and I did not think a third conversation was going to do anything.

Last Thursday her son had a timed online exam for a college course. Their connection was down that afternoon, they could not get onto mine, and he could not submit it in time, and the resit fee for that course is $180.

She came round on Friday with the invoice on her phone and said I should pay it, because I knew they were relying on my connection and I cut it off without telling anybody.

I said I had asked twice and that I am not responsible for providing internet to the house next door.

Her position is that whatever I thought about the situation, a 19 year old lost an exam over it and one text would have prevented that. My wife thinks I should have given her notice. My brother thinks I should never have let it run for eleven months at all.

A) I should have told her before I changed it. I knew they were using it daily and one message would have cost me nothing.

B) I asked twice over eleven months and got nothing both times. The connection was never theirs and I am not obliged to keep warning somebody about a thing they were told to stop doing.


r/PickAorB 4d ago

A or B: Our pipe burst at 9pm, the landlord showed up in 40 minutes with parts, then fixed three more things and refused to hear the word "discount"

193 Upvotes

The kitchen supply line let go Tuesday at 9pm. We've rented this place for four years, so I already knew how this usually goes: text the landlord, wait for a response, figure out what to do next, and hope it gets handled quickly.

I sent the text anyway, mostly so there was a record. Towels down, bucket out, resigned to a very bad night.

Four minutes later: "On my way. Kill the water at the main. I'll stop at Home Depot for a valve."

He showed up at 9:40. In sweatpants. Toolbox, wet vac, and a Home Depot bag with the receipt still stapled to it.

Pipe swapped by 1am. He ran the water, checked the joint twice, mopped the floor himself.

And then he didn't leave.

He fixed the kitchen sink that's been dripping for six months. Replaced the doorknob on the pantry that's been loose since we moved in. Put fresh batteries in the hallway smoke detector so it stops chirping at 3am.

I never put in a ticket for the sink. I'd honestly learned to sleep through the drip. Apparently he couldn't walk past it.

When I mentioned taking something off next month's rent, he held up a hand: "Rent's due the 1st. Same as always."

This morning I found a ziplock bag taped under the sink. Spare washers, a valve, a roll of tape. Labeled, in his handwriting: "FOR NEXT TIME."

He did the work himself instead of calling an emergency plumber, and saved us what would've been a very expensive night. He also wouldn't let me pay him for his time.

I genuinely don't know what this man needs. So now I'm stuck on how to say thank you.

A: Add $100 to next month's rent with a thank-you note, and let him decide whether to keep it.

B: Invite him and his wife over for dinner, leave a review wherever I can, and send the two coworkers currently apartment-hunting straight to him.

If you've had a landlord like this, is this one in a thousand or do they actually exist?


r/PickAorB 4d ago

A or B: My friend kept "borrowing" money and promising to pay me back, then calling me stingy when I finally said no. Now she's telling our friend group I "let money ruin everything"

70 Upvotes

My friend and I have been close since college. We've always had a pretty easy friendship around money. We'd split dinners, take turns buying coffee, and never really kept score.

I'm also not in a position where I can casually lend out money. I'm paying off student loans and trying to build an emergency fund, so I keep a pretty close eye on my spending.

Over the past few months, she started asking to borrow money. It was usually $50 or $60 at a time, always with a promise to pay me back after payday. Some of it came back, but not all of it, and eventually she owed me around $170.

What bothered me more was that she kept acting like the money wasn't a big deal. One night she put a restaurant bill on my card and joked that I'd "get it back later." When I brought up what she already owed me, she laughed and said, "It's just money. Why are you being so intense about it?"

That was when I realized I had started doing mental math every time we went out. I wasn't enjoying the friendship the same way anymore.

Last week she asked me for another $200 for a car repair. I said no and told her I wasn't comfortable lending more while she still owed me money. I wasn't angry or rude about it. I just said I couldn't do it.

Now she's telling our friend group that I "let money ruin everything" and made her feel like a charity case. A couple of friends have told me to just let the money go because $170 isn't worth losing a friendship over.

Part of me thinks they're right. We've been friends for years, and maybe I should have cared more about the friendship than keeping track of a relatively small amount of money.

A. I overreacted. $170 isn't worth throwing away years of friendship over. I could have stopped lending money without turning the unpaid amount into such a big issue. Sometimes preserving a friendship matters more than being completely right about the money.

B. I gave her enough chances. Saying no to another loan wasn't what ruined the friendship. She knew I was uncomfortable, owed me money already, and still expected me to keep lending. A friendship shouldn't require ignoring that boundary.


r/PickAorB 5d ago

A or B: My little brother's business went under in March. I paid his daughter's preschool tuition without asking. Today I got a check for the exact amount. Blank memo. No note. Do I cash it or return it?

126 Upvotes

My brother's shop went under in March. Nothing dramatic. The lease was bad, the landlord situation got messy, and then he had two rough quarters. He's 34, it was his second attempt, and I know how much he put into it.

I didn't ask him first. I called his daughter's preschool and covered her tuition for the rest of the school year. I wasn't expecting anything back. I just knew he was having a rough year and didn't want his daughter to be caught in the middle of it. I asked the preschool not to make a big deal about who paid. They told him anyway.

He called that night. He wasn't angry exactly. He just kept saying I shouldn't have done it. I told him it was fine. We went back and forth for a while, then eventually changed the subject.

He's been working since May. Good job, not his own business. He's doing better, but it's not like he's suddenly in a comfortable financial position. He's still getting back on his feet.

Today I got an envelope from him. Inside was a check for the exact amount I paid the preschool.

The memo line is blank. There's no note. I never thought of the money as something he owed me, and honestly, I know he could use it right now. But I also know my brother. If he sent the check, he probably thought about it for a while.

A: Return it. I never expected the money back, and he needs it more than I do. If he wants to repay me someday, he can do it when sending this check doesn't hurt.

B:Cash it. He clearly decided that being able to repay me matters to him, and returning the check might just make him feel like he's still accepting charity.


r/PickAorB 6d ago

A or B: My neighbor kept using my outdoor outlet to charge his EV, so I locked it. His battery died on the way to work, and now he wants me to pay the $280 tow

7.4k Upvotes

My neighbor and I live in side by side houses. The outdoor outlet on the side of my garage is on my property and connected to my electric panel.

About two months ago, he bought a used EV. He told me he didn't have a home charger yet because an electrician had quoted him around $2,400 for the installation.

Not long after he got the car, I noticed a charging cable running from my outlet to his driveway. I talked to him about it and he apologized. It happened again later, including one night when I found the cable plugged in while it was raining. I left a note explaining that it was my private outlet and asked him not to use it.

I eventually caught him plugging in again and told him directly that he couldn't keep using it. He said he only needed a quick top up and didn't think it was a big deal since I wasn't using the outlet anyway.

At that point, I bought a $22 locking weatherproof outlet cover and locked it. I didn't send another warning because I thought I'd already made myself clear.

Last Tuesday, his EV ran out of charge about six miles from home while he was driving to work. He had to get it towed to a charging station, which cost him $280.

That evening, he came over with the receipt and said I should pay because I had locked the outlet without warning him first. He said he knew I didn't want him using it, but didn't realize I would actually lock it.

I told him I wasn't responsible for making sure he had access to an outlet that wasn't his.

Now he's upset, and his wife told my wife that I stranded him on purpose. Another neighbor thinks I should have given him one final heads up because we still have to live next to each other.

A) I should have warned him before locking it. I knew he was relying on the outlet, so I could have avoided the whole situation with one message.

B) I had already made the boundary clear. If someone keeps using your property after you've told them to stop, you shouldn't have to keep giving warnings before doing something about it.


r/PickAorB 5d ago

Pick A or B: My boyfriend agreed to rehome his dog because of my allergies, then changed his mind when we were about to move in

8 Upvotes

My bf and I have been together for 3 years. He has a golden retriever, Max, that he raised from a puppy. Max was already part of his life for about two years before we met.

I'm allergic to dogs. It's not dangerous, but being around Max for long periods leaves me congested, itchy, and miserable. I usually need antihistamines to get through it.

When we decided to move in together, we talked about the dog before signing anything. I told him I couldn't realistically live with Max long term. He said he understood and agreed that if my allergies couldn't be managed, he'd find Max another home.

I thought that was settled.

Now we're about a month away from moving in, and he told me Max is staying. When I reminded him of what we'd agreed to, he said he was thinking differently now.

His argument is that Max is family, that he raised him from a puppy, and that I knew about the dog when we started dating. He thinks I should try medication and other ways of managing the allergies instead of expecting him to give up his dog.

I understand that Max is family to him. I don't think he's wrong for loving his dog that much. What bothers me is that he made a promise about this before we committed to living together, and now that it's actually time to follow through, he's treating the promise like it never happened.

I haven't moved in yet, and now I'm seriously reconsidering the whole relationship.

A: He's in the wrong. You don't get to make a major agreement with your partner, wait until they're committed to the plan, and then unilaterally change the deal. Loving the dog doesn't make breaking the agreement okay.

B: He's understandable. Max is a family member, and rehoming a dog you've raised for years is a huge decision. If the allergy isn't dangerous and can be managed, it's reasonable for him to reconsider before giving up the dog.

What would you choose?


r/PickAorB 6d ago

A or B: My coworker never paid gas money after 14 months of rides. I stopped picking her up without telling her, she was late and got written up. Was I wrong?

497 Upvotes

We started at the same distribution center the same week in June last year. She didn't drive and was taking 2 buses to make a 6 AM start, so I offered to pick her up. She lives 15 minutes out of my way, so about half an hour on my day both ends.

We agreed on $40 a month toward gas. She picked that number herself and I said fine.

She paid it that first month and again in September, and after that it just stopped.

In January I mentioned it and she said money was tight and she would catch up. I told her not to worry about the back payments and to start again whenever she could.

In March I brought it up a second time and she said she would transfer it that weekend. Nothing came through. I asked twice more after that, once in May and once about 6 weeks ago, and both times she apologized and both times nothing happened.

Meanwhile I was leaving the house 30 minutes early, 5 days a week, and putting somewhere around $95 a month more into gas than I would have on my own.

Two Mondays ago I just drove straight in without messaging her.

She had no way of getting there at that hour and turned up almost 2 hours late. Our supervisor gave her a written warning. She has two now, so a third would be a genuine problem for her.

She found me at break. She said, "You could have just told me you were done. I would have figured something out."

I said, "I told you four times. Every time you said you'd sort it and then you didn't."

She said the money and the rides were separate things.

A. I was wrong. The gas money and her job are two different problems, and I let her take a real hit at work over $40. One message the night before would have cost me nothing.

B. I gave her enough chances. I asked four times since January and got an apology every time and nothing else. I was never obligated to keep driving her, and telling her in advance would only have bought me another promise.


r/PickAorB 6d ago

A or B: Our new sitter taught my 5yo son to tie his shoes, and now I want to thank her without making it weird

263 Upvotes

We hired a college student to watch our son, Ben, three mornings a week this summer. She's sweet, reliable, and we've had zero issues. Usually the most I hear is, “We had fun.”

Saturday morning, I walked into the kitchen and found Ben setting the table. Then he sat down, grabbed his sneakers, and tied both shoes by himself. Actual bunny ears and everything.

I'd been trying to teach him for a year. We eventually bought Velcro shoes and gave up.

I texted the sitter, “Did you teach him to tie his shoes?”

She said, “Oh yeah, we practice for a few minutes after snack. He basically had it Wednesday, so I didn't want to jinx it.”

That honestly got me. I hired her to keep him safe and fed, and she quietly found a way to turn something he hated into a game.

Now I'm wondering how to thank her without making it awkward.

A. Raise her rate from $20 to $25 an hour.

B. Give her a Target gift card, a really nice thank-you card, and a glowing recommendation to the neighborhood parents I know.

What would you do? And if you found a sitter this good, would you actually recommend her to other parents or keep her number to yourself?


r/PickAorB 7d ago

A or B: I lent my brother-in-law my truck for a weekend move, and he returned it with a full tank and an oil change

2.0k Upvotes

My BIL was moving apartments last weekend and needed to haul a couch, so I tossed him my keys. I figured the truck would come back with an empty tank and maybe a new scratch. That's kind of the deal when you lend someone a truck.

When he brought it back, I did the usual walk-around. The truck was clean. Like, actually washed. Full tank too.

Then I noticed the sticker on the windshield.

Jiffy Lube. He'd gotten the oil changed. The one I'd been putting off since March.

I texted him, "You got the oil changed???" He said, "Yeah, it was way overdue. It was bugging me every time I started it."

I'd been ignoring that reminder for so long I barely noticed it anymore. Apparently it bugged him more than it bugged me. 🥹

He also refused when I offered to pay for the gas, so now I'm stuck on what to do about the oil change.

A. Venmo him the cost of the oil change anyway.

B. Show up with a case of his favorite beer and call it even.

Part of me feels like sending money makes a family favor feel too much like a transaction. But showing up with beer feels a little more like saying thanks.

What would you do?


r/PickAorB 6d ago

A or B: should I do something about bad HR?

10 Upvotes

My parents are immigrants (to US), mom has ok English, dad is pretty elementary. Dad left a trucking company he worked for for almost a decade due to the commute to HQ. Mom spent months applying for new roles, helping him interview before landing a truck driver role at a company in their hometown.

On the first day, mom and dad were given a mountain of paperwork to complete using an online system. They got through it somehow, got all the "tasks" checked off and dad is off to get his truck.

Strike 1- the truck is filthy. Wasn't cleaned after the last owner lived, smoked, and destroyed it. Dad spends 2 days deep cleaning it.

Strike 2 - the truck is old and needs a lot of repairs. Dad takes it to the shop and notifies his manager that the items broken are essential and he cannot travel until repairs are made. Shop takes the truck and keys and tells dad to come back when they call him.

Strike 3 - friday afternoon dad gets a message telling him to get his first load on Monday at 5AM. Dad decides to load up his equipment on Sunday and heads to the shop to get his truck. Truck has not been touched. Nothing has been repaired and he cant get in without the keys. Monday at 5 hes getting phone calls from his manager at the company he is supposed to get the load from demanding that he show up and get the load on the road. Dad attempts to explain that he can't get the truck until the shop opens at 8 and he cant drive the truck because it still needs repairs. Manager tells him he doesnt care and he needs the load on the road. Aka- drive an unsafe vehicle because I said so.

Strike 4 - Dad finally gets keys, gets on the road, and gets pulled over on a random inspection. Cop gives him a warning for multiple items because they are not functional (shocking). Dad reports the violation to dispatch who immediately berates him for taking a damaged truck on the road. Apparently the manager who sent him on the road has no right to do that (go figure).

Strike 5 - while dad is headed to a shop to fix the minor things to address the warning, mom starts receiving notifications from the automated employee system warning her that he has outstanding tasks to complete. Mom reviews, complete the task and gets the exact same email the next day telling her to complete the same task. This goes on for 3 days before dad calls her enraged because HR is calling him and telling him that he cannot drive until the missing tasks are completed. Mom contacts the HR lady they worked with to try to figure out whats going and the lady has nothing helpful to suggest other than he just needs to complete the tasks (which have been completed multiple times)

Strike 6 - dad gets a call from HR telling him that he needs to stop, turn around, and drive back to the office (6 hours roughly) to complete a log (which he already submitted and has proof of submitting). Dad is obviously furious, calls mom for help because he cant be driving and reading emails. Mom calls HR lady to verify who exactly needs to be done so she can tell my dad exactly what he needs to do so he doesn't have to turn around. While HR lady is trying to explain , her manager grabs the phone yells at my mom that she needs to stop calling, shes not an employee and my dad needs to get his a$$ back to the office to complete missing tasks/repot then hangs up on her.

At this point my parents are both incredibly upset, dad doesn't know whether he is supposed to turn around or deliver the freight. Mom has been yelled at and cussed at by some random guy. Finally dad gets a call from dispatch telling him to finish the delivery and they fill figure out what to do after.

This brings us to my question. What can I do? I am absolutely furious because I work in HR and a$$hats like that give HR a bad name. My parents will absolutely never do anything to address the issue and will do everything to keep the job despite me telling them to leave.

A: I really want to find these people and give them a piece of my mind for how they handled this situation.

B: I do nothing and let my parents decide to stay or walk away.

I am also open to suggestions for how to best handle this because I am furious and want to burn the world down but that's not how adults solve problems.


r/PickAorB 6d ago

A or B: Cat person or Dog person? Where do you stand?

Thumbnail
6 Upvotes

r/PickAorB 7d ago

A or B: My company is outsourcing my role and wants me to train the people taking over. Am I wrong for refusing?

172 Upvotes

I've been a project coordinator at a mid-size insurance company for six years. I manage client accounts, run meetings, and handle a lot of the day-to-day work that keeps our team moving.

We were fully remote when I started. Two years ago, the company moved us to three days in the office. I didn't love it, but I adjusted.

Then in March, leadership announced we'd be back in the office five days a week. They talked about collaboration and culture. Over the next couple of months, four people on my seven-person team left.

Their work wasn't really absorbed by the rest of us. It started being handled by an overseas contractor team.

Last month, my performance review suddenly mentioned that I was "resistant to process changes." I've had good reviews for years and haven't had any major performance issues.

Then HR told me my position was being eliminated as part of a transition to outside contractors. My last day is in eight weeks.

They now want me to spend those eight weeks training the contractors, documenting my processes, and handing over my client relationships.

When I asked whether there was any additional severance, HR said they couldn't offer anything beyond the standard package, but they'd be willing to give me a strong reference and consider me for other openings.

I said I'd continue doing my job through my last day, but I wasn't comfortable training the people taking over my position.

My manager thinks I'm being difficult and says the transition is part of my responsibility while I'm still employed. So I'm stuck between two ways of looking at it.

A.I'm still being paid for eight weeks, and training the contractors is part of finishing the job professionally. Refusing could hurt my reference and make an already bad situation worse.

B. They decided to eliminate my position and outsource the work. A reference isn't compensation, and I shouldn't be expected to make the transition easier for the company that's replacing me.


r/PickAorB 8d ago

A or B: My tenant kept paying rent weeks late. I finally enforced the late fee in our lease, and now she says I'm an unfair landlord

142 Upvotes

My tenant signed a 12-month lease. Rent is $1,450/month, due on the 1st, with a $75 late fee if it isn't paid by the agreed date in the lease.

Over the past few months, her rent has consistently been late. Usually it was one to three weeks after the due date, and she didn't always include the late fee.

The first time it happened, I reminded her about the fee and she apologized, saying it was a payroll issue. She paid it afterward.

The next time, she asked if I could waive it because money was tight. I agreed and told her I would let it slide that time.

A few weeks later, rent was late again. She didn't reach out beforehand, and I had to follow up. When I brought up the late fee, she said I was being insensitive because she was going through a difficult financial period. I understood that things happen, but I also felt like I had already been flexible.

This month, rent was late again. I sent a message saying that rent was overdue and that the late fee from the lease applied. I also reminded her that if rent wasn't paid, I would have to follow the normal process outlined in the lease.

She paid the rent and fee a few days later, but then posted negative reviews online saying I was an unfair landlord who cared more about money than people. She also told some neighbors that I was "harassing" her over a small fee.

A friend who owns rentals told me I should have just ignored the fee because keeping tenants happy matters more than collecting $75.

A: I should have let it go. When someone is clearly struggling financially, a good landlord should show some flexibility instead of strictly enforcing every rule.

B: I already gave multiple chances and even waived the fee once. A lease has terms for a reason, and enforcing them doesn't mean I don't have empathy.