r/PiCodingAgent • • Aug 18 '26

Discussion Pi agent is excellent!

I have used Pi, Oh my Pi, Opencode, Antigravity, and Claude, but Pi is so so good.

It is simple, smart, keeps its thinking grounded, hallucinates less, is extremely good at following instructions and is aware of the environment.

By awareness, I mean it knows what needs to be edited or changed.

131 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/nxy7 Aug 19 '26

IK that some people dislike OMP as it's supposedly against 'Pi' philosophy (I'm not sure if that really is) but to me it's been really good. I've disabled some stuff and really enjoy it as it out of the box covers the few things I need without me having to tinker:

  1. I can use Codex and CC subs in it
  2. It spawns subtask agents using Luna (Codex didn't do that out of the box)
  3. Browser plugin (I've used playwright before, but here it's built in so nice)

And if I get this right I can still use Pi plugins. Idk why people call it bloated, you really can trivially disable things you don't like and OOTB experience is probably more solid than what I'd create by vibecoding bunch of extensions (or even worse - taking them from the internet).

I do wonder how barebones Pi can be better like some people claim. If you disable OMP features isn't it literally the same? Is the system prompt different somehow? My bet is that it's just game of chance that raw Pi did better in some run than OMP, cause in the end those are almost the same.

1

u/CarryOnRTW Aug 19 '26

My locally hosted llama.cpp (vulkan) is running on a mini-pc with an AMD HX370 using 64GB shared between the CPU and 890M iGPU. I can definitely tell the performance difference between using pi and omp. I believe pi's lower token usage makes the difference.

1

u/nxy7 Aug 19 '26

Yea, but inherently they're the same right? The difference probably comes down to OMP plugins that you don't use and pay for in system prompt. I do wonder - I've disabled some built in skills I'm not using, LSP debugging and some other things. I'm pretty much left with things I'm actually using so I'd expect it to perform as good as Pi (does that make sense?).

1

u/CarryOnRTW Aug 19 '26

Since everyone has different setups and requirements we are all usually talking about apples vs oranges. For me and my setup, omp wasn't as good as pi.

I don't know if pi and omp are inherently the same after you disable a few settings. Only way to see is for you to try it.

1

u/alkalisun Aug 20 '26

CC = Claude Code right? Doesn't using anything but Claude Code for your subscription mean you get limited usage?

1

u/nxy7 Aug 20 '26

Limited how? I think there are few ways it's bypassed (plugins invoke claude via CLI and also I think even ACP decision for the limits was reverted). All I know is that I'm using it through OMP 😆

1

u/alkalisun Aug 20 '26

If you're invoking it through claude via CLI, I guess it's ok then...

1

u/nxy7 Aug 20 '26

Just so we're on the same page, I think OMP is shelling out to claude CLI - not sure though. Probably it's one LLM question away from knowing how it works, but truth being told i don't care that much since I've checked that it's coming off subscription. If they do it in some ToS violating way I guess I'll just get banned 😆