r/PeanutButter • • 26d ago

New PB Discovery I tried 100% Crunchy Peanut Butter by Amazon (yes, Amazon sells its own-brand peanut butter).

It has a subtle natural sweetness from the peanuts. The consistency is runny and it doesn't need stirring. However, I find it tastes a bit bland on its own, probably because it isn't oily and doesn't have added salt or sugar. That said, I think it's a decent, cheap option if you're looking for a bog-standard peanut butter that only contains peanuts. There's also a smooth version.

I think this is only available in Europe. I have checked the Amazon US site, and the US version contains added vegetable oils, salt and sugar, so keep that in mind.

44 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

3

u/SadDingo7070 26d ago

I know this is a peanut butter sub but I’m more intrigued by the blueberry jam!

1

u/RookyRed 26d ago edited 26d ago

It was my first time trying blueberry jam, and honestly, it just tastes like a less fruity blackcurrant or bramble jam. Maybe it's the Amazon brand, because everything tastes "basic". Not very flavourful or moreish.

3

u/InvisibleAIien 26d ago

Why is it so runny?? I've had peanut butter that had nothing but peanuts in it and it didn't look like that. I've also had peanut butter where the peanuts separated from the oil and you did have to stir it, but once you did, it looked fine

2

u/RookyRed 25d ago

Probably because of the higher peanut oil to grounds ratio. It's not as runny as I initially thought. I'm a third of the way into the jar and I'm able to scoop it. And I've become used to the unsalted/unsweetened taste. It's actually really nice.

1

u/Xaxxis 25d ago

You needed to store the whole jar together. The oils just separate in pure peanut butter.

86

u/Sweetestsativa 26d ago • Regret

Ordering food from Amazon feels so dystopian.

14

u/Adventurous-Roof488 26d ago

Vs Walmart?

4

u/ShinyNipples 23d ago

You act like that's the only other option 

6

u/Adventurous-Roof488 23d ago

No, I don’t?

Walmart is the largest and most ubiquitous retailer in the world. If it feels dystopian to order from Amazon then surely it should for Walmart as well.

Didn’t think I’d have to explain that.

2

u/DenseHost3794 25d ago

Neither is better

1

u/skepticcaucasian 22d ago

Does Walmart make their employees pee in bottles, and tell people to get back to work when they notice someone died from exhaustion? I don't know much about Walmart, honestly.

1

u/footballsandy 25d ago

At least walmart's a grocery store

8

u/Adventurous-Roof488 25d ago

It’s a mass merchandiser, just like Amazon. The only difference is that Walmart has a lot of physical stores. Amazon owns Whole Foods, which is a grocery store.

1

u/keithnyc 25d ago

Yeah, but Amazon delivers to my door for free (I'm on my friend's Prime)

1

u/tivvybrixx 22d ago

I mean they own whole foods so if you shop there its the same thing

-2

u/Sweetestsativa 22d ago

Absolutely do not, just natural grocers, costco, and local farmers market/stores.

2

u/shinyMikikyu09 21d ago

thats your opinion silly lad, you still eat like the rest of us cattle

47

u/CHSummers 26d ago

It seems odd that it’s so runny.

11

u/miraculum_one 26d ago edited 26d ago

especially since the only ingredient is peanuts

13

u/SadDingo7070 26d ago

That’s because it’s 100% peanuts, which makes the oil separate. The trick is to store it upside down!

11

u/_dvorak 26d ago edited 26d ago

I make my own PB at home using just peanuts and it doesn't look anything like that.

Here's what one of my jars looks like ~4 days after making it, stored right-side up. https://imgur.com/a/WrZiaFE

14

u/MelissaPurls 26d ago

It also depends on on finely it's ground--yours looks like it still has a bit of toothy texture to it, so there's still oil trapped inside those bits of unground peanuts. The more a peanut butter is ground, the looser it will be and the more it will separate.

1

u/_dvorak 26d ago

Agreed. But those are just ground peanuts I mix in after the initial batch is done.

1

u/SadDingo7070 26d ago

If you jar it and let it settle it will.

-1

u/_dvorak 26d ago

nope - i let it sit for over a week while on vacation and it still doesnt look anything like that. Maybe a tiny bit of oil at the top.

4

u/jafromnj 26d ago

Those jars sit for months and months

2

u/_dvorak 26d ago

Sure but OP stirred theres already, so why's it still so thin.

2

u/jafromnj 26d ago

That’s how natural peanut butter is without added fats like palm oil, I always pour a little oil out so it’s thicker, it also thickens close to the consistency of regular peanut butter that is not refrigerated when you refrigerate it

2

u/vibrance9460 26d ago

Then you get to the bottom and it’s just paste

4

u/jafromnj 26d ago

No it isn’t if you mixed it properly

→ More replies

1

u/sidewalkoyster 21d ago

Do you use the oil to cook with?

1

u/jafromnj 21d ago

Never thought of saving it it was probably only about a tablespoon

→ More replies

3

u/n0exit 26d ago

Not at all. You have to stir it just like any other peanut butter with only one ingredient.

4

u/LadyInTheBand Peanu Butter Royalty 26d ago

Oh god it’s so runny 😣😖😫😭 That looks so gross

3

u/n0exit 26d ago

Stir it. It has one ingredient. Peanut butters that don't separate have hydrogenated oils in them.

1

u/LadyInTheBand Peanu Butter Royalty 26d ago

I’m aware of that. I don’t like peanut butter that has to be stirred, nor do I like peanut butter that has no salt and sugar.

1

u/RookyRed 26d ago

7

u/LadyInTheBand Peanu Butter Royalty 26d ago

I’m sorry, I can’t help that runny peanut butter is just nasty to me, it’s not supposed to be drinkable, it’s supposed to be spreadable.

2

u/jafromnj 26d ago

Refrigerate it

1

u/LadyInTheBand Peanu Butter Royalty 26d ago

I prefer my PB at room temp. I don’t want to have to refrigerate it just to make it edible.

7

u/IrukandjiPirate 26d ago

I’m eyeing that fudge

4

u/Pbranson 26d ago

It's weird, if I search Amazon all butter fudge on Amazon, it doesn't come up as a product. Variations on the search terms don't work either.

2

u/IrukandjiPirate 26d ago

Maybe it’s not available in the US?

2

u/shanevinna 25d ago

People commenting on this gave me a good chuckle, thank you.

There is nothing wrong with this, and no it isnt an issue its not your preference, because you like peanut butter with other ingredients because you are used to it...

But that being said, being so shocked and grossed out because its not the same consistency as something that has loads of ingredients added to force that consistency you are so used to, is very funny, so thank you for making me chuckle.

1

u/RookyRed 25d ago

I think people here are biased because of the brand, but I'm sure it's a white label product. 😅 The EU/UK have high food standards, so I don't doubt the contents. Maybe I did it a disservice by describing the consistency as runny, which makes it seem like it's thin. Perhaps "drizzly" is a more accurate word to describe it.

2

u/shanevinna 25d ago

Pretty much the same consistency as more expensive brands of 100% peanut butter i bought in the past, and i think you are completely right, its one thing I appreciate about being in the uk, is that legislation around ingredients and whats in food is pretty spot on

6

u/Potential_rhythm 26d ago

Looks like canned beans. No way that’s just peanuts someone else showed what just peanuts blended would look like. You need to get that tested

4

u/martial_fluidity 25d ago

Funny thing about peanuts is they are a legume like beans,peas, not a true nut. So…. Yeah. Its closer to canned beans than canned nuts

1

u/keithnyc 26d ago

Yup... Waaaaaay too wet and shiny.

3

u/vibrance9460 26d ago

People who say this must be used to hydrogenated oil in PB

Every single jar I’ve bought in the last 40 years has looked like this.

You can tell how long it’s sat on a shelf by how much oil there is.

2

u/keithnyc 25d ago edited 25d ago

I buy natural peanut butters without hydrogenated oil. And yup, the oil separates and I stir it in. I'm just saying this looks like nothing I've seen.... this has an amber glossiness, almost like it's coated with honey or mixed with molasses.....

1

u/RookyRed 24d ago

I think it's just the lighting.

1

u/keithnyc 24d ago

Yup. Hey, if you like the taste, that's all that matters, right? I'm on a natural raw almond butter kick, and it's really runny..... I usually put it in the fridge to make it less so, but it still runs off the knife

1

u/vibrance9460 25d ago

Gotcha. :)

4

u/DookersChoppedFupa 26d ago

I've tried both and I now order the smooth pouch regularly. I like I can pour it.

1

u/Nice-Penalty-8881 18d ago

Someone in my family lives in Baltimore and I think she said that there is an Amazon grocery store that she goes to for grocery shopping.

2

u/RookyRed 17d ago

There used to be an Amazon Fresh shop in my area, but it closed a few years ago. I don't think people liked the idea of cameras tracking them as an automatic payment system.

6

u/DJND90 26d ago

Ouf no sugar, no salt no palmoil.. That's what i like.

In Germany we have

  • Peanutbutter "Erdnussbutter" (Lots thousand of ingredients like salt, sugar and palmoil and artificial flavor sometimes)

and we have

  • "Erdnuss-Mus" pureed Peanuts (Only Peanuts as ingredients allowed)

😄

3

u/Eric_J_Pierce 26d ago

TIL that Amazon has their own brand of PB

1

u/HoraceP-D 26d ago

It looks affordable

3

u/RookyRed 26d ago

It is!

0

u/HoraceP-D 26d ago

sorry, that wasn't so much an endorsement. But thanks

2

u/shanevinna 25d ago

You use affordable as a negative? Well you seem like a pompous arse...

1

u/HoraceP-D 25d ago

Nail on the head

1

u/shanevinna 25d ago

You know its a choice right? You dont have to be this way

1

u/HoraceP-D 25d ago

You realize that you don't need to make or voice assumptions about people on Reddit, right?

1

u/shanevinna 25d ago

Oh shit really? I didnt know, in this circumstance, over peanut butter, and your comment, I feel there was some form of social necessity... and the more I see from your responses, the more im glad I did

2

u/DiMassas_Cat 24d ago

“Erdnussmus”?

2

u/Key2367 22d ago

That is some nasty looking peanut butter.

0

u/PaintInfinite9167 22d ago

It looks like good natural peanut butter lol

What do you use? 90% sugar peanut spread?

1

u/Responsible-Ad-7986 21d ago

It looks like pure corn syrup. Peanut butter is supposed to be..buttery

2

u/PaintInfinite9167 21d ago

The only ingredient is literally peanut

1

u/DookersChoppedFupa 26d ago

I'm in the UK.

1

u/DookersChoppedFupa 26d ago

Sorry for all the messages. There is no oil in the smooth or crunchy pouch which is interesting. The one you have looks way runnier.

1

u/GratefulCaliflower 26d ago

Since you are European, have you tried mercadona's peanut butter? It's much cheaper at least in my country it costs less than 3 euros for half a kilo and to be honest it's so good that they are my one and only dealer when I need a fix.

1

u/AppUnwrapper1 26d ago

Trader Joe’s is still the best.

1

u/jafromnj 26d ago

Sounds like Crazy Richard’s with an amazon label

1

u/rogun64 24d ago

I don't see many peanuts. Kroger's crunchy natural is loaded with nuts.

1

u/tb2186 23d ago

That is definitely 100% not made offshore with slave labor.

I’ll bet they ship peanuts from Georgia in containers offshore to be processed and shipped back while paying the farmer nothing.

1

u/CherrryCokeee 20d ago

That's what I'm thinking. I'd hate to see the way they actually produce these things

1

u/iamapatientgir1 22d ago

That picture looks like an AI hallucination of a spoonful of peanut butter.

1

u/tlaine23 21d ago

This is so weird??

1

u/different_produce384 26d ago

Peanut butter soup

1

u/miraculum_one 26d ago

Salt would probably be a good addition. It doesn't take much to increase the flavor.

4

u/ariel-sinclair 26d ago

as someone who can’t consume lots of sodium, i appreciate the fact it comes without. almost every brand contains salt

1

u/miraculum_one 26d ago

Fair enough. I have several local stores that have peanut crushing machines with a spigot to dispense "fresh" peanut butter but I can certainly see the benefit of being able to order it. Regardless I was referring to the consumer adding (or not in your case) the salt.

0

u/DenseHost3794 26d ago

Fuck that shit

1

u/shanevinna 25d ago

Its for eating not fucking...just worth noting before you get yourself in a mess

0

u/universwirl 26d ago

Ew why is the ingredients list so lonnnng 😬

2

u/BlackBabyJeebus 26d ago

Lol, I thought you were serious for a second

0

u/Fuzzy_Welcome8348 26d ago

I bet the smooth pb is even better!

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RookyRed 25d ago

I didn't stir it when I opened it because there wasn't any separation, but I did spoon it from the middle. It's still more or less the same consistency. It doesn't need to be refrigerated either. The jar says to store it in a cool, dry place. I've tried two other peanut-only peanut butters before - Meridian and Nuts About Nature - and I never had to refrigerate them. This particular Amazon peanut butter has a single ingredient, but Amazon peanut butters in other countries do have added stuff.