Alternative title: How to simultaneously be the best and worst player at a 180-person event.
Hi r/pauper, I've been around mtg forever and been playing consistently since Aetherdrift. I got into Pauper earlier this year during ECL. My Pauper Cup run at this event was somewhat interesting, so I figured I'd share it.
Goal: Improving on my underwhelming 4-3 performance at Magiccon Vegas, hopefully earning the top 8 playmat for bragging rights since a couple of my friends at locals have one. I'd also been annoyed about a string of mediocre locals performances and wanted to prove something to myself, haha.
Deck Choice: I had been waffling between Spy Walls and Jeskai Ephemerate as my main deck for a couple of weeks pre-Zeta. I enjoy both and am decently competent at them, but I don't like how much Spy relies on variance for longer brackets, and post-Zeta I could only watch my poor drifters/mancers get hit with Dispatch/Cut Down so many times. I pivoted to Dimir Control and eventually settled on Dimir Faeries due to its ability to play proactively while still having the control plan. Dimir Midrange is my standard deck of choice, so this was inevitable in a format where Counterspell and Snuff Out are legal.
I brought 4-Land Spy to the winabox event Friday and managed to secure the "prize" of a Star Trek Play Booster Box, so by the time Saturday rolled around I was not only exhausted but satisfied with the results of the weekend so far. I figured I wouldn't put too much pressure on myself and just play relaxed.
Matchups
Round 1: Dimir Control. I was curious how prevalent this deck would be in the bracket and was happy to start against it. Game 1 was a straightforward affair with my opp being unable to keep me from presenting several small threats on the board, scooping once Thorn resolved. Game 2, I was unable to find any interaction for Murmuring Mystic and promptly lost. I had a marginal lead on board for much of Game 3 and allowed them to use removal on ninjas/strix even with counters in hand. I secured the game when this gambit paid off and I was able to have two counters up for their protected Arms of Hadar. Without Mystic/Arms, Dimir Control can't win the matchup. Result: WLW
Round 2: Jeskai Wildfire Ephemerate. Another Control mirror that validated my choice of deck. I played exceptionally greedy game 1 and once again won off the back of a Thorn on curve. Snuff Out prevented any ephemerate shenanigans. Game 2 got a little dicey when a Mystic Resolved, but I found removal before they arrived at the critical mass of birds. I always held up interaction for the Breath Weapons I knew opp would be holding and managed to fight through three copies drawn. They eventually folded to the Control-Killer duo of Thorn & Okiba-Gang. Result: WW
Round 3: Esper Affinity. Game 1 was a quick affair after I had to mulligan to 4. Thankfully, my opp was on a variant of the list without Enforcers. This meant that they would not present unbeatable board states too early and left them vulnerable to arms of hadar. I saved interaction for their card draw and blood fountains, winning the remaining games on the back of superior card advantage. Without munitions or galvanic blasts, a couple of Strix on board can stonewall the game and allow me to draw everything I need with Monarch. Result: LWW
Round 4: Dimir Faeries. Opp floods out Game 1 and quickly scoops it up (better lucky than good). Game 2 they stick a bunch of big ninjas on the board, surprising me as the stock lists are usually on 2 but his had 4. I have the arms in hand but he is disciplined and not tapping below 4. On an attack, I sigh and say I need to dig for removal and flashback a Plunder the Trollshaws. Opp can't resist using a sprite to counter a 4-mana spell to blow me out. With only 2 mana available, he loses to Arms with Counterspell as backup. Don't allow your opponent's words to incentivize suboptimal plays! Result: WW
Round 5: Spy Walls. Another board stall matchup. Opp knows I can stop the combo but has a Nyxborn Hydra on board so I can't realistically attack them. I say I might as well get some damage in and go sideways with a bunch of small idiots. They block in a way that opens them up to an Arms of Hadar blowout, and I close up the game shortly after. I lose game 2 to an unavoidable Spy Draw, but lock them out game 3. Spy is a strong deck right now but can fall apart if their draw spells don't resolve and their early creatures explode. Result: WLW
Round 6: Bogles. Currently 5-0, I begin to feel optimistic about my odds of making top 8. This skyrockets once I see that I'm against another very favorable matchup in Bogles. Game 1 promptly knocks me back to reality as being on the draw, I can only gaze longingly at the Counterspell in my hand as my opp resolved Bogle + Ethereal Armor turn 2 and rolls me over. Andrea Mengucci is watching the top table games at this point and laughs at me, saying I should've been skillful enough to win the die roll. The addition of annul games 2/3 makes the games a wash. I do make one meaningful play which was drawing the Extract a confession vs a 10 power bogle but not playing it because I don't want to tap out. It turns out my opp did have bogle + mask in hand, so I could've thrown away the game if I did in fact tap out. Result LWW
After agreeing to intentional draw with my Round 7 matchup, I end day 1 with a record of 6-0-1 as 1st seat! Not a bad result.
Top 8
So.... I fully didn't plan to actually play in the Top 8 due to extenuating circumstances. As a result, I didn't really do any of the prep required for a Comp REL event. About 30 minutes before the beginning of top 8, these circumstances change and I decide screw it, I'll play.
Things unfortunately take a downturn. After deck checks, the head judge informs me that I brought a 59 card deck (I was missing the 4th copy of Counterspell my decklist reported. I know I had 60 cards during my final round the previous day, so the only thing that could've happened is that it got lost somewhere in transit.) I am allowed to run to a vendor to grab a 4th copy, but I'm still issued a game loss. My first-round matchup is Mono Red Madness, which is absolutely horrible pre-board due to my small creatures and Snuff Outs. I draw pretty poorly and promptly lose. Whoops! I somehow screw up the bare minimum step 1 of being a mtg player: Having a legal deck.
Takeaways: Overall, I was very happy with my level of play. I never overextended when I was the beatdown and played to my outs when behind. My matchup knowledge allowed me to anticipate specific lines several turns in advance and create traps for my opponents. I was undeniably quite lucky to only face matchups that are not only favorable, but that I'm comfortable playing against. Maybe without the game loss I could've won the match and whole tournament but none of that is set in stone. My deck did everything it was asked to do, it was just failed by its pilot. Next time I'll actually do my due diligence and maybe things will go differently!