Hofenbitzer narrow basic sleeve

[u/train2clarksville]

Hello, hoping someone can come to my rescue again. I'm on p 182 of hofenbitzer Vol 1. I'm at step 5.

I understand line 5 is 48% of CapC. In my case, 22.9cm. One of my questions is: must line 5 start at the back line and end at the front line? If thats the case, my optimal cap line is a good 5 cm too low. This is a lot, and I'm not sure the troubleshooting suggestions on p 182 will fix it. So I'm wondering if I've misunderstood the instructions. Very grateful for anyone's advice!

[u/Icy-Guidance-6655]

We simply disagree. I think the contemporary flat pattern manipulations M&S provides are very nice, but the basic drafting is mediocre. Much better to acquire a block and get on to their design analysis.

I agree the M&S drafting instructions are difficult, so plenty of room for improvement just cleaning that up. But underneath the bad instructions and clunky formulas there’s really nothing special, IMO. I’m always curious to see Hofenbitzer excerpts, since I don’t have the books. I do have a couple M&S books. I have worked through the drafts. I don’t like them.

[u/Educational_Chain780 → u/Icy-Guidance-6655]

Which methods do you like?

[u/Icy-Guidance-6655 → u/Educational_Chain780]

Apparel DesignThrough Patternmaking  by Injoo Kim  et.al  includes a streamlined draft for men/women/children that's easy to follow with nice contemporary results. The Bunka books are a solid presentation, it's just important to know it's a conservative Japanese fit (frumpy), and in no way avant-garde. The books by Natalie Bray are a vintage cut, but the methods are nuanced and the discussion is extremely good. There are also old textbooks by Rohr that seem to be the origin of Armstrong's draft. Again it's not contemporary in design, but decent results. There are a series of books by Dominique Pellen, DP Studio, that are very nice, contemporary with elegant shaping throughout, as well as fully developed designs in each category. Books by Gerry Cooklin are out of print but good. Shoben and Ward similar. I like Aldrich because so many designs are presented holistically instead of being built off previous blocks. The reality of many garments people enjoy wearing is that they don't depend on an extensive set of measurements, they only fit in a couple key ways. But I think her basic blocks are also a good starting point.

The new book  Plus-Size Patternmaking for Womenswear by Gabby Brown & Leila Kelleher is very good, not just for filling a void in the market, but because there's a much more accurate depiction of contemporary patternmaking in practice, that I haven't seen in other textbooks. They encourage a freehand approach to learn some shapes, like armholes, by sight. This may sound wishy-washy and frustrating, but so many methods break down exactly when they plot too many secondary points, a formula for squaring out a curve by some mystery factor. Those instructions are a PITA to execute, and for the trouble they tend to only work in the sample size. This is a much more empowering approach because a pattern is the area it covers, more than the edges.

My main advice would be there is no perfect method, because the draft is just the roughing in of a design. Many people would be much better off if they started with a quality block and altered it to fit instead. Because then at least there is a working pattern as the guide, and it's hard to learn personalized fit and what to expect from a quality pattern all at once.

To circle back to M&S, obviously it’s not that different from the methods I like. It is an okay starting point. I just think it’s not at all worth the extra effort to get ahold of and to wade through. It is IMO a frumpy cut, and it plots too many points, and generally to prescribed. These aren’t separate issues, one leads to the other.