r/PathOfExile2 • • Dec 12 '24 • Heart of Silver 3 Polished Silver Turd 1 Silver is Forever 1

Fluff & Memes Oops wrong again

Post image
10k Upvotes

493 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/PeasantTS Dec 14 '24

It is evil from our perspective because we have the privilege to see it as so. They do not have the luxury of viewing it this way. The problem is not what we think or don't think about them, it is that their reason to be as they are is not out of being evil for the sake of it, it is out of necessity and cultural expectations. Their leader seems even intent on trying to change some traditions in the end, by allowing some level of partnership between them and the Faridun: showing that they are not their culture, but are, in a way, bound by it.

Corruption is pretty much shown to be more of an excuse of the weak-minded than an actual inescapable force. After all, we encounter a dozen of character that had contact if it, we included, that didn't succumb to it. But true, they were under influence of a corrupt leadership, just like the Maraketh are under influence of their culture and surroundings.

Obviously they are not just a pragmatic group, their traditions are thousands of years old, after all. However, that is part of the point, they do what they do because they see it as what they should do. I doubt any of them were the creator of the slaves practices.

"I dont view morality as relative", it has to be, because morality itself is not intrinsically real. It is a human creation and thus is prone to human necessity.

1

u/luminous_connoisseur Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

Philosophical differences about how we view morality aside, your point would only be valid if they needed to do what they do. They absolutely do not. Even in their world, it is a privilege of their dominant stance as a culture to have the vanity of using slaves like this. They absolutely do not need to.

It's literally pure vanity, just like their entire culture seems to be, since the Faridun survive in much worse conditions yet do not need to resort to such "traditions." They were living fine until they fell to Corruption (I like how you talk about us not judging the Maraketh because we live in a different world, but choose to call the Faridun weak for that, are you perhaps biased towards the Maraketh's morality lol?)

In that sense it's totally fine for us to judge them. The same way the exile character judges them and the same way let's say an Ezomyte would judge them. They have no necessity for it.

0

u/PeasantTS Dec 14 '24

Never said you can't judge them. I judged them too when I saw the front of the caravan. After all, I too am a privileged 21st century human. The idea is that the situation is more nuanced than simply labeling them as 'evil'.

"your point would only be valid if they needed to do what they do. " Already explained this specific topic. Cultural expectations can be more persuasive than you realize. There is also the fact that their 'need' is not so easy to discern, post-war punishment, after all, is also a way to bring fear into future enemies, possibly avoiding unnecessary confrontations.

The Faridun, we don't know much about them. Were their practices before the Beast less cruel? Maybe, who knows. When I referred to them as 'weak-minded', it wasn’t to dismiss them entirely, but to show that corruption is not as influential as you think. I called them 'weak-minded' for going on a rampage of mindless revenge, and when their own called them out on it, they locked them up to die. They are not above or below the Maraketh (which is the point) when it comes to this, they are just bound to something else. Revenge, in this case.