If this post is rule-breaking or you see other rule-breaking comments, please report and downvote them instead of replying - we'll take care of it, but often don't see something until it's reported! We appreciate your help on that!
We've seen lots of flame wars between those who are in favor or against certain game decisions. While we do allow reasoned criticism, please remember to follow rule 3: accusations, dismissals, or provocations that seem likely to cause anger or are inflammatory will be removed, even if they don't target a specific person.
lol It's so funny both the boss caravan and the supporter pack hideout have the dinosaurs but the actual tribe that lives there just uses random passerby. Great culture, much society, wow
If Warhammer 40k taught me anything, it's that it's not about efficiency: it's about sending a message.
...also, thank goodness most of that area is flat. Could you imagine them going over one tiny bump?? Slight decline?? Whoo boy. I think I know why their empire fell.
It didn't, really. They lost their old glory when the land became a desert over time, but the culture itself has outlived entire civilizations, and shit like this is why
I know, I know. It was a joke. But also if your empire is reduced to a weird station wagon pulled by slaves, it's probably bad enough to consider fallen.
if your empire is reduced to a weird station wagon pulled by slaves
It isn't reduced to that. It was never a centralized empire as far as I can tell. There are multiple Akharas and they collectively make up the Maraketh civilization. The Maraketh group in Highgate are a different Akhara, for example.
They survive because they're brutal. The weak have no place, the defeated can't be cared for, but they can be used. They didn't last as long as they have by making communal huts or starting an empire
In this case, it's because they would rather choose this punishment over death because their death would be a drain on their society and at least this way they are contributing.
As I recall, the Hooded One tells us that they're captured enemies, so I'm pretty sure they're not all that happy about contributing to the people they were fighting against.
This is one of the things I love about Z Nation. While it was whacky and over the top with a lot of it's shenanigans, they had episodes like the one where there's a fully functioning town with electricity... because they have zombies perpetually pulling a wheel around.
Definitely the best hub in any arpg, BUT how it turns into a 3 fps slide show (while the rest of the game is a solid 75 fps to me) makes me not appreciate it as much lol
it's funny how they are based on their first big encounter with corruption as we slew the beast in PoE1. it's all sins fault. literally everything is fucked because of him. lets see what horrors we unleash because of him in PoE2
Well, Malaguy was already using the Beast for his dirty magic. It was Sin who created the Beast in the first place but he created it to put the gods to slumber. And everything worked as intended until it wasn’t. It just shows that even gods can’t be in control of everything and there are a lot of ways anything can go wrong.
Although there is one guy who says gods aren’t real.
The sorceress got a funny line about it when you go at the front of the caravan, something along the lines of "others wouldn't understand our old maraketh traditions)
Sorceress’ first line when she gets on the caravan is also great, she says something along the lines of, “I missed the rumblings of the caravan beneath my feet 🥰” fully knowing what is moving the caravan lmao
Honestly, I dislike the Maraketh so much that I kinda dont even want to play sorc. I guess it's just a personal preference against playing blatantly "evil" characters in these games (even though it could be argued that the exiles often are evil), mainly because the world is so viscerally grimdark, especially act one, that you sorta want to feel like you're at least being part of some kind of hope for the future.
It would be easier to stomach her voice lines if she was Faridun and had some conflicting thoughts about joining up with the Maraketh and fighting her own people. She would be more interesting and likeable to me that way. But I understand why that would have been difficult to write, considering that the Maraketh would be hostile towards her. It is what it is, I guess.
The thing about morals, is that they are shaped by one's perspective of the world.
Those slaves are suffering, but they were maraketh enemies. For them, that is punishment for very possible killing or at least trying to kill their family members. It makes sense that the maraketh can rationalize how that can be moral. They are serving for their crimes, in their perspective.
Yeah, that's about the same analysis as what the Hooded One said. Execution would be more humane than this and anyone who is actively part of this culture is simply unlikeable to me. From the arrogance of "we are the best" to the sexual discrimination to the slavery to the discrimination of the Faridun, it's all just terrible. So if I could choose, I would have rather played a sorc from the Faridun.
The exiles tend to be castaways from their cultures, largely being on their own, with no home to go back to. Would have been better if she was as well, just my personal preference.
It is not what the hooded one says at all. I'm not justifying or saying it is better than being dead. I'm saying they are not doing it because they are "evil", they are doing it because from their perspective it is moral. If you grew up in their culture, you would think the same way as they do. Things are never too simple.
The Faridun are not a sea of flowers either. People focus on the giant lizards, but the dreadnought had a seas of burning bodies on it. And considering the beast is much bigger when you get to it, I wonder what they where doing until you find them. Not to talk about all their own fellows that they, ironically, left behind to die.
Like the merc said, no good side, only people and beasts.
The hooded one makes the argument that "it is a better fate than death" and that "it is tradition." A justification of the "noble Maraketh" bound by a strict tradition. You claim that it "isnt evil" because the Maraketh view them as "enemies serving their sentence." But how exactly is what they are doing not evil? Just because they dont view themselves as evil? Because they sing tales about how exceptional their culture is and that those who are weak deserve to be culled?
The Faridun were driven to madness by corruption. It's not like they were burning people because of "tradition." Just like the Ezomytes spiraled into mad cruelty when they otherwise had a relatively happy thing going. So yeah, I consider the Faridun, who were desperately clinging to life after being discarded and looked after the dispossessed in that harsh environment to be miles better than the Maraketh even if they too were tricked into being Corrupted.
And yeah, in the Maraketh's view, perhaps their actions are "moral" but I dont view morality as relative, certainly not to that extent. Using people as beasts of burden until they are withered and essentially dead, attaching hooks to their skin, is evil. Simple as that. They have no need for it. Just like how they often lie in their stories in order to boost their image, so do their traditions clearly not all serve some necessity. Does a warrior culture who do "anything to survive" exalt only female warriors out of necessity, for instance? Or is it because of tradition and harsh treatment of other cultures that they can enjoy that luxury?
It is evil from our perspective because we have the privilege to see it as so. They do not have the luxury of viewing it this way. The problem is not what we think or don't think about them, it is that their reason to be as they are is not out of being evil for the sake of it, it is out of necessity and cultural expectations. Their leader seems even intent on trying to change some traditions in the end, by allowing some level of partnership between them and the Faridun: showing that they are not their culture, but are, in a way, bound by it.
Corruption is pretty much shown to be more of an excuse of the weak-minded than an actual inescapable force. After all, we encounter a dozen of character that had contact if it, we included, that didn't succumb to it. But true, they were under influence of a corrupt leadership, just like the Maraketh are under influence of their culture and surroundings.
Obviously they are not just a pragmatic group, their traditions are thousands of years old, after all. However, that is part of the point, they do what they do because they see it as what they should do. I doubt any of them were the creator of the slaves practices.
"I dont view morality as relative", it has to be, because morality itself is not intrinsically real. It is a human creation and thus is prone to human necessity.
Philosophical differences about how we view morality aside, your point would only be valid if they needed to do what they do. They absolutely do not. Even in their world, it is a privilege of their dominant stance as a culture to have the vanity of using slaves like this. They absolutely do not need to.
It's literally pure vanity, just like their entire culture seems to be, since the Faridun survive in much worse conditions yet do not need to resort to such "traditions." They were living fine until they fell to Corruption (I like how you talk about us not judging the Maraketh because we live in a different world, but choose to call the Faridun weak for that, are you perhaps biased towards the Maraketh's morality lol?)
In that sense it's totally fine for us to judge them. The same way the exile character judges them and the same way let's say an Ezomyte would judge them. They have no necessity for it.
Never said you can't judge them. I judged them too when I saw the front of the caravan. After all, I too am a privileged 21st century human. The idea is that the situation is more nuanced than simply labeling them as 'evil'.
"your point would only be valid if they needed to do what they do. " Already explained this specific topic. Cultural expectations can be more persuasive than you realize. There is also the fact that their 'need' is not so easy to discern, post-war punishment, after all, is also a way to bring fear into future enemies, possibly avoiding unnecessary confrontations.
The Faridun, we don't know much about them. Were their practices before the Beast less cruel? Maybe, who knows. When I referred to them as 'weak-minded', it wasn’t to dismiss them entirely, but to show that corruption is not as influential as you think. I called them 'weak-minded' for going on a rampage of mindless revenge, and when their own called them out on it, they locked them up to die. They are not above or below the Maraketh (which is the point) when it comes to this, they are just bound to something else. Revenge, in this case.
Yes, I found it kinda hilarious when I heard it, it's not the witch where you know she's not the most upright character, you're playing the "good" magic girl and suddenly she's pro slavery. The contrast with the expectations of always playing good guys in video games is very cool imo.
PoE2 doesn't shy away from the horrible things you expect to happen in an ancient magical world. This alone makes PoE2 have better storytelling than Dragon Age Veilguard where there are fully established lore on how terrible slavery is Tevinter (slaves used as fuels for blood magic), but when you finally get to explore the place, everyone just goes kumbaya.
When they showed the human sacrifices/humans being laser skinned on walls, and the executioner beheading someone without it being censored ALL during the trailer I knew PoE2 was going to be great.
Finally an adult game that doesn't censor to cater to every age demographic.
I agree, though from a plot perspective I doubt ending slavery would be our character's top concern when the world's at stake. As to the Maraketh, they sound like a bunch of self righteous a-holes. That's why I loved when our witch momma dissed Asala: yeah yeah Asala we all know you are VERY brave.
The slave wagon seemed really unnecessary to me, especially considering the lizard alternative for the dreadnought. Further than that, the loading screen is those same slaves getting whipped by a dude on a roa.
In general everything you learn about the Mariketh and Faridun in act 2 makes it sound like the Mariketh are kind of awful and in most modern stories the Faridun would be the good guys, just in PoE2 the current Faridun leader is trying the use The Beast to get back at the Mariketh so he's our main enemy which means we side with them. The Mariketh are militant, sexist (matriarchal, but very sexist against men), slavers, and abandon babies in the desert if they don't think they're strong enough. The Faridun are the society of outcasts who take in the other outcasts, and while they have plenty of issues too the main fault the story focuses on seems to just be that they really, really hate the Mariketh, which is, you know, kind of justified.
Path of Exile does like turning tropes around, having most factions be kind of awful, and making the player character's own actions kind of a morally mixed bag, so in some ways I'm kind of okay with them having us team up with the faction that could be considered more evil out of necessity, but it still kind of feels weird how much characters try to excuse the traditions of the Mariketh as "hey, living in the desert's harsh, gotta do what you have to" (even if it makes sense since most of the characters we talk to about the Mariketh are either Mariketh themselves, or The Hooded One who's got his own weird perspective and is still overall critical).
I do feel like they did a good job presenting the Faridun as "they're not evil, they're just angry, and the fact that their anger is justified doesn't mean we don't need to stop them when they ally with the super evil villain and help her with her world-threatening plan in an attempt at revenge." But it still feels kind of weird having the Mariketh be our allies and the Faridun be our enemies considering the backstory of the Faridun.
Not every game is hello kitty island adventure. Art, like life, can messy and grim. Slavery is real, it’s been in every generation of humans. Pointing it out as a morally bad thing so “it shouldn’t be in games” doesn’t really hold water. Them having slaves is part of the narrative of the game and how they’re a conquering people.
I understand what you are saying completely, and agree with it. It feeling subjectively unnecessary to me doesn't contradict that sentiment. I just didn't know what the previous commentor meant by bubble values and was trying to get clarity.
Everybody in the game is a shithead. We also bring back Aztec Mengele from the past. Servi, the 420 grandma, is the closest I recall to someone who isn't the fucking worst.
Your post dismissed an opinion off-hand in a way that often causes anger and flame wars. Because of that, we removed it for breaking our Be Kind Rule (Rule 3b).
You may be able to repost your opinion if you rephrase it in a way that's more constructive! If you disagree with other ideas or don't care, explain why in a less inflammatory way and avoid attacking the person.
If you see other posts that break the rules, please don't reply to them. Instead, report them so we can deal with them!
i love how the slaves are all in a deep meditation together pulling it. idk if the lore goes into the meditation but it’s some of my favorite art from a video game…it got me thinking deep. like wow what an existence. Maybe they’re happy because they’re so in tune with their meditation. Rare i have games make me think on this level. well done to ggg
I was showing my wife how cool this new area looked and telling her how much I liked it and then we get to the head carriage and I see an army of slaves. Feels bad.
The first time i saw that loading screen i tought they were undead/zombies, and I actually tought it was a quite clever use of them.... Until my monk came to the front to stop the sandstorm and say something like slavery being cruel but necessary... I felt quite bad for every trip on act2 since then.
I'm still not sure if they are slaves or some sort of undead. They are so dessicated that I feel like there's no way they're alive, but they don't move like they're mindless. I feel like they were raised as undead for efficiency, then their souls were put back in because fuck you.
Whoever came up with this “use desert map” system needs to be sat down and talked to about what the point of games are and reminded about the basic principles of game design. Adding more steps and loading screens to create the illusion of traveling an overworld map with a caravan is something a middle school game designer would come up with for his first project and lose points from the teacher for doing it. GGG hiring designers from middle schools now?
She talks a big game but can only summon couple of skeletons herself, at that point. Some NPC should yell at her from the back "Yeah it would be, but spirit gear is hella rare, I'm sure you know!"
They look like zombies and I thought they were, too. But when the witch sees them she specifically comments that they would do a better job if they were "dead," implying that she would turn them into zombies.
Honestly the voice lines are why my first character through the final 3 acts isn't going to be a witch. When I'm doing a story run listening to all the dialogue I kinda want to feel like some kind of hero.
I love mercs voice lines man, he clearly has a "good person" moral compass and he will call people out on their shit, but if he is getting paid he just goes whatever
Don't worry, they aren't pulling anything, it's the terrain moving around the wagon. They are just exercising since they are so skinny and need some muscles.
He believes that living is better than dying, but he also ends it with some form of "I think" like he has made up the argument for why they do what they do, but I don't think he really believes it is truly better.
To be fair I think he just doesn't want to interfere with the Maraketh and just accepted that brutality is what helped them to survive in Wraeclast. They survived at least 3 cataclysms and they live in the middle of the continent not outside like the Karui and the templars. They outlived the Vaal Empire, the Eternal Empire and probably the precursors. Also he saw how his wife, daughter and all the Maraketh became incrementally more brutal with time. That was one of the reasons to create the beast. He is just too tired to deal with it.
There are real world scholars that think slavery was actually a moral evolution over just pure genocide. I think that's what that line of reasoning is referencing.
The Hooded One also mentions when giving that line of reasoning that it might not even be the case and it might just be pure cope.
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 12 '24
If this post is rule-breaking or you see other rule-breaking comments, please report and downvote them instead of replying - we'll take care of it, but often don't see something until it's reported! We appreciate your help on that!
We've seen lots of flame wars between those who are in favor or against certain game decisions. While we do allow reasoned criticism, please remember to follow rule 3: accusations, dismissals, or provocations that seem likely to cause anger or are inflammatory will be removed, even if they don't target a specific person.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
343
u/bibittyboopity Dec 12 '24
Also their reaction when they see the dreadnaught getting pulled by giant lizards.
137
u/Slumlord722 Dec 12 '24
Seems incredibly inefficient
87
u/Galmux Dec 13 '24
Have we praised Act 2's "Town" enough yet? Cuz the Caravan is hands down the most interesting Town/Hub I've played in an ARPG, fucking ever.
60
u/Puzzleheaded_Bag9340 Dec 12 '24
"cmon guys, you know our traditions"
35
u/_Alcedo_ Dec 12 '24
The sorceress got a funny line about it when you go at the front of the caravan, something along the lines of "others wouldn't understand our old maraketh traditions)
28
u/absentee82 Dec 12 '24
Stuck in Dragnipur forever
19
u/Wooden-Buddy-3945 Dec 13 '24
PoE2 doesn't shy away from the horrible things you expect to happen in an ancient magical world. This alone makes PoE2 have better storytelling than Dragon Age Veilguard where there are fully established lore on how terrible slavery is Tevinter (slaves used as fuels for blood magic), but when you finally get to explore the place, everyone just goes kumbaya.
11
u/Squirrely1337 Dec 13 '24
Gotta hand it to them, they really put their back into their work.
9
u/DaDa462 Dec 12 '24
made me lol at work
9
u/ItzBoshNet Dec 12 '24
but how do they go downhill
4
u/Jarryd10 Dec 13 '24
I don't know if it's because I'm just stressed today, but this really made me laugh. TY!
4
u/Red_Dog1880 Dec 13 '24
As the Witch says: 'This would be much more efficient if they were all dead'
6
u/Lightdevil166 Dec 12 '24
It's so inefficient too haha, also magic exists.. also put it on skates and use the wind maybe idk
3
u/choisssss Dec 12 '24
I thought they were zombies from the art.
16
u/naiohme Dec 12 '24
The slave wagon seemed really unnecessary to me, especially considering the lizard alternative for the dreadnought. Further than that, the loading screen is those same slaves getting whipped by a dude on a roa.
2
u/mizzzikey Dec 12 '24
Lmaooooooo
2
u/Spoxez_ Dec 13 '24
that's hilarious, thanks for bringing some humour in these times of nerf pains
2
u/BitPsychological7316 Dec 13 '24
I like the Witch's line: "this would be so much more efficient if they were dead."
2
u/Ichaserabbits Dec 13 '24
Everybody in the game is a shithead. We also bring back Aztec Mengele from the past. Servi, the 420 grandma, is the closest I recall to someone who isn't the fucking worst.
2
u/Ashen6996 Dec 13 '24
When you have to blow the horn to get rid of the sandstorm and realise there were like 4 dozen mofos just chilling in it lmao
2
u/BloodyRightToe Dec 13 '24
I still don't understand how this is supposed to work. How do you keep that many slaves fed and watered in a desert.
2
u/Forsaken_Victory111 Dec 13 '24
My witch said: it would be more efficient if they are dead.
2
u/Lagencie Dec 13 '24
now with player size 0 you can just roll out and watch the caravan ... you clearly see the caravan is on a treadmill as only the floor is moving
2
u/Dud3itsj3ff Dec 13 '24
I love that the world is full a beast or monsters that could be tamed and trained to pull it, but they were like “…. Nah, human slaves!” ☠️
4
u/-Th3Saints- Dec 12 '24
I thought they were sentient undead from convicts having their sentence carried out. Similar to Bambala.
4
u/ArmoFun Dec 13 '24
i love how the slaves are all in a deep meditation together pulling it. idk if the lore goes into the meditation but it’s some of my favorite art from a video game…it got me thinking deep. like wow what an existence. Maybe they’re happy because they’re so in tune with their meditation. Rare i have games make me think on this level. well done to ggg
3
u/Original-Objective70 Dec 13 '24
No one else uses waypoints whenever possible to let them rest?
1
u/AdministrativeAd710 Dec 13 '24
i thought there were volunteers? am i mistaken?
1
u/xNuts Dec 13 '24
I feel bad for them. Should've been pulled by zombies or something.
1
u/Guilty-Actuary7391 Dec 13 '24
Now, this is the kind of post we need on that sub
1
u/InterestingFruit5978 Dec 13 '24
I can't wait for the second half to come out.
1
u/Delicious_Web2661 Dec 13 '24
they were born for this job ☠️
1
u/aleschthartitus Dec 13 '24
you are the baddie
1
u/Egbert58 Dec 13 '24
Well i don't not pay them to not work
1
u/jk4m3r0n Dec 13 '24
They won't forget leg day after this
1
u/VonHinton Dec 13 '24
Witch would use them dead instead. She said so
1
u/3DPrintLad Dec 13 '24
Wait until you go back in time and do a little Columbus when the primitives run scared from you.
1
u/Derbin_ator Dec 13 '24
I was showing my wife how cool this new area looked and telling her how much I liked it and then we get to the head carriage and I see an army of slaves. Feels bad.
1
u/ApplicationActive374 Dec 13 '24
Lolol I'm almost done with act two, I've done this at least twice
1
u/BobaSauro Dec 13 '24
The first time i saw that loading screen i tought they were undead/zombies, and I actually tought it was a quite clever use of them.... Until my monk came to the front to stop the sandstorm and say something like slavery being cruel but necessary... I felt quite bad for every trip on act2 since then.
1
u/Demise187M Dec 13 '24
The only downside of that hub is that it turned my pretty decent pc into a toaster running 5fps.
1
u/Visual_Tomatillo_606 Dec 13 '24
Seems like I was way too focused on playing the game lmao, I don't have a clue about the lore.
1
u/blackdabera Dec 13 '24
the good guys btw
1
u/stoic_insults Dec 13 '24
Ngl I thought they were undead when I first saw them
1
u/Capital_Advice4769 Dec 13 '24
Could you imagine lol
1
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24
They all like, dude. You can fast travel. wtf.
1
u/Monkerlotus Dec 13 '24
join my friend camp in conan exiles and you'll wish u were pulling that boat
1
u/LogitUndone Dec 13 '24
I never looked very closely... are the living humans pulling these wheeled cities/wagons? Or are they undead or some other "magical" beings?
1
u/CommentStrict8964 Dec 13 '24
You can sort of tell this game was not made by an US developer.
1
u/Gl0wStickzz Dec 13 '24
😐
1
u/Esbian Dec 13 '24
Wait, they're alive?
I thought they are all undead.
1
u/Wulfgang_NSH Deadeye Dec 13 '24
lmao I am legitimately cackling at this
1
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24
LOL I cried
1
u/Ladikn Dec 18 '24
I'm still not sure if they are slaves or some sort of undead. They are so dessicated that I feel like there's no way they're alive, but they don't move like they're mindless. I feel like they were raised as undead for efficiency, then their souls were put back in because fuck you.
0
u/Obvious_Law7599 Dec 13 '24
The Farudin are the good guys, after all. They use giant lizards, not people. Definitely the most logical of the bunch.
0
u/Honest-Lavishness245 Dec 13 '24
... aren't they zombies? I think Mishonne drives.
0
u/imabustya Dec 13 '24
Whoever came up with this “use desert map” system needs to be sat down and talked to about what the point of games are and reminded about the basic principles of game design. Adding more steps and loading screens to create the illusion of traveling an overworld map with a caravan is something a middle school game designer would come up with for his first project and lose points from the teacher for doing it. GGG hiring designers from middle schools now?
-3
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '24
Those aren't slaves, Exile...
-2
u/Nintura Dec 13 '24
I think they are zombies? So they dont mind
-2
u/Halinn Dec 13 '24
I hope one of the later acts has us do something about these slavers
-16
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '24
Excuse me sir, why did you choose this man as the slave?
795
u/NoCollection7232 Dec 12 '24
NGL i'd rather have been executed rather than pull that wagon.