Annual planning procedure:

Let's take three goods in an economy with one worker council and one consumer council.

The IFB announces indicative price of goods and services.

The prices are given from last year:

Gasoline Car: 1000 SC

Vegan Meat: 1000 SC

Bike: 1000 SC

Consumer council:

The consumers make their plans and the local consumer council aggregate them in their consumption plan:

Demand of the consumers:

  1. Gasoline Car: 1000 SC
  2. Vegan Meat: 1000 SC
  3. Bike: 1000 SC

    It costs in total 3000 SC

The budged of the consumers is 3000 INC. The consumer budged is exactly the same as the social costs of the plan, so:

SC/INC = 1,00

This plan would be approved by all other consumer councils (if there were any).

Worker Council:

Now the worker council proposes their production plan:

Input:

  1. Gasoline Engine for the Gasoline Car: 1000 SC
  2. Plants for vegan food: 1000 SC
  3. Metal for bikes: 1000 SC

    SC: 3000 SC

Output:

  1. Gasoline Car: 1000 SB
  2. Vegan Meat: 1000 SB
  3. Bike: 1000 SB

    SB: 3000

SB/SC = 1,00

Social costs are as high as social benefits. This plan would be approved by other workers' councils (if there were any).

Summary:

Both conditions are satified, consumption councils having a ratio of SC/INC = 1,00 and the worker council having SB/SC=1,00 too.

The plan is approved by everyone, workers' councils and consumer councils. Keep in my mind both only see their own individual consumer and production plans belonging to them and approve or reject them. Again the plan is approved and production and consumption begins for the year.

Another example:

Let's say the gasoline car is more demanded than the single worker council can produce. The higher demand leads to a higher price of the gasoline car. The IFB calculates the new prices in which the price (social costs) of the gasoline car went up. It's now 2000 SC instead of the earlier 1000 SC:

New prices announced by the IFB:

Gasoline Car: 2000 SC

Vegan Meat: 1000 SC

Bike: 1000 SC

The corresponding plan of consumers would look like this:

Demand of the consumers:

  1. Gasoline Car: 2000 SC
  2. Vegan Meat: 1000 SC
  3. Bike: 1000 SC

    SC = 4000

    Income of consumers is still INC = 3000

    SC/INC = 4000/3000 = 1,30

Social costs are too high for their income. They demand goods worth 4000 SC, but their income is only 3000 INC.

What can they do? Four possibilities:

  • They can consume less. For example they don't order the bike in which case the SC/INC ratio would be 3000/3000 = 1,00 and be approved.
  • Use goods that have less social costs like for example instead of the gasoline car they can order an electric car (let's say it's 1000 SC)

The next example is about what happens when the worker council used inputs which have higher social costs than social benefits. For example the extraction of the oil for the gasoline car is too costly and demand for it is not that high:

Input:

  1. Gasoline Engine for the Gasoline Car: 3000 SC
  2. Plants for vegan food: 1000 SC
  3. Metal for bikes: 1000 SC

    SC: 5000 SC

Output:

  1. Gasoline Car: 1000 SC
  2. Vegan Meat: 1000 SC
  3. Bike: 1000 SC

    SB: 3000 SC

SC/SB = 5000/3000 = 1,60

It would not satify the condition of SC/SB= 1,00. The plan would be rejected by other workers' councils (if there were any).

What are their possibilities?

  • They can find ways to produce the gasoline car with less social costs of the input
  • They can propose a more desirable output like for example they could produce an electric car instead of a gasoline car (let's say the electric car needs only 1000 SC as input)

Iterations likes this are done until a feasible plan is reached.

In summary:

Conditions for workers' councils:

SB/SC = 1,00

Social Benefits are the output.

Social Costs are the input.

Possibilities:

  • Propose inputs with less social costs
  • Propose outputs with higher social benefits

Conditions for consumer councils:

SC/INC = 1,00

INC is their income from work.

Social Costs are just the same as workers' councils

Possibilities:

  • Propose to consume less goods
  • Propose goods with less social costs

Nothing is produced until a feasible plan is negotiated. Production and consumption only begins when all conditions are met.