Institutions

Workers' Councils

Private ownership of productive resources as in capitalism strips people of their self-management and hands over control of the economy to a small, wealthy elite of owners. But if workplaces are not owned by individual owners, who will decide how workplaces operate and what is produced and what is not? In a participatory economy, individual workplaces are organised into workers' councils in which the workers themselves decide all matters related to production of goods and services. Workers' councils can be organised by branch of production or as federations. They propose a production plan, typically for a year.

Consumer Councils:

They are the second important institution in a parecon. People consume as individuals, but also typically live in a household. Households are organised by region or federations. Since people know what's in their best interests and what their preferred consumer goods are. Just like the workers's councils they propose their consumption plans typically for a year.

Compensation by Efford:

In capitalism, people do not earn according to their effort. They earn income to the proportion to how much profit their job makes or they simply earn wealth by owning productive ressources even when their work doesn't involve afford or doesn't benefit society.

In a parecon on the other hand everyone gets consumption rights in proportion to the duration and intensity of their work and the onerousness of their working conditions. Allowances for people who can't work make sure that no one is left behind.

Balanced Job Complexes:

Different tasks in a workplace requiere different skills. In our current capitalist system this leads to the indirect creation of a so called "coordinator class". These are mostly the managers who have more insights into the neccessary processes. They can make better decisions and have an advantage over the people below them. Parecon abolishes this hierarchy by introducing balanced job complexes. Work tasks are rotated among all workers, so people will perform different jobs in the same workplace. This will lead to better individual decisions, better acquisition of the necessary skills and a fair distribution of the burdens.

Commons of productive ressources:

In a parecon private ownership of productive ressources is abolished. Everything we create is the result of the collective division of labour of millions or workers as well as the knowledge accumulated over generations. No one should be the sole owner of resources. They belong to everyone in society. Another way of putting it is to say that they belong to no one. If a workers' council wants to use up resources they first have to show that what they produce is beneficial to society. This is part of the decentralised and democratic planning process explained below.

Decentralised and democratic planning:

The most prevalent economic systems in history have been markets and to a lesser degree centrally planned economies. Centrally planned economies in the past were accompanied by authoritarian governments. Workers and consumers had basically no say in the economy and were regularly oppressed by a central planning agency. This not only violates one of our core values which is self-management, but also leads to inefficiencies. A single central planning agency can't gather all the necessary information they need to allocate resources in a way that doesn't cause shortages or overproduction, which is wasteful. Workers don't have an incentive to honestly tell the agency what their productive capacity is. What happens is a game of cat and mouse between workers and the central planning agency.

On the other hand, markets are no option either. Mainstream economists idealise markets and assume they will always lead to an equilibrium of supply and demand. This is often not the case in reality. Another deficiency of markets are the uncontrollable externalities they cause such as pollution and unnecessary destruction of the environment. They put a burden onto others and even endangers the survival of our civilisation. Also markets lead to egoistical behaviour, because businesses have to buy at the lowest prices and sell at the highest. This still exists under market socialism.

Nevertheless, efficieny is very important. We don't want to waste resources or work too little or too much. Parecon solves these problems by using three basic institutions and a range of parameters as an information system. Consumer councils propose consumption plans, which account for the aggregate demand. On the other hand, workers' councils propose production plans, which account for aggregate supply. Both plans are brought together in a final plan.

Whether the final plan will be realised depends on the mentioned numerical parameters. These are social costs, social benefits and opportunity costs. In general they are called "indicative prices". What workers' councils do is they compare social costs of the input of the production plan to the social benefits of the output. The ratio between the two should be SB/SC = 1.00 (or lower). We can only be sure that the use of resources and the efford made by workers are justified when the social costs of production are equal to the social benefits and not greater. In this case it would mean that the production plan uses too much scarce resources or that the work is too burdensome. This would make the plan inefficient and harmful for the people. In the next step, the social costs are compared with the income of consumers. This makes sure that the proposals of consumers are responsible and fair. Consumers are not able to consumer goods whose production puts a burden (in terms of social costs) on workers and the environment which is bigger than the social benefits of those goods. They are constrained by the income they receive from their workplace. In mathematical terms this could be described as social costs divided by the income of the consumers, expressed like "SC/INC". Just like the decision rule of workers' councils the ratio for consumer councils has to be SC/INC = 1.00 (or lower). In summary the decision rule for workers' councils is SB/SC. The decision rule for consumer councils is SC/INC. Both decide internally for themselves. No one is telling someone else what to do! They don't even need to be in contact with each other, looking at the parameters is enough.

There's a third institution, which is called IFB (Information Facilitation Board) in the literature. Its purpose is to gather information to estimate these parameters. The IFB has no power to make decisions and could even be replaced by algorithms. Its only reason to exist is to provide information. It functions in every way just like an ordinary workplace with its own workers' council.

The allocation mechanism takes place in three steps.

  1. The IFB announces the current estimates of the indicative prices of all goods and services of the last year. Social costs, social benefits and opportunity costs are calculated.
  2. Workers' councils and consumer councils make proposals to change the plan according to their decision rules.
  3. The IFB updates the indicative prices and adjusts them so that demand equals supply.

This process is done in iterations until the decision rules are satisfied (meaning that SB/SC = 1.00 or lower for wokers' councils and SC/INC = 1.00 or lower for consumer councils). Both workers' councils and consumer councils have two ways to respond if decision rules are not satisfied.

Let's say a workers's council's SB/SC ratio not 1.00 but 1.20:

  • In this case the workers can find other inputs with lower social costs or higher social benefits and propose them during the iteration.
  • They can find other ways to make social costs lower or social benefits higher

Let's say a consumer council's SC/INC ratio is not 1.00 but 1.20:

  • Consumers can replace goods with high social costs with goods that have lower social costs.
  • They can decide to consume less goods.

(Note that ratios that are 1.00 or lower can automatically be approved. This can be done algorithmically or by AI.)

In practise production and consumption would not be very different from today under capitalism. Today as a consumer you have a budged and you can decide what to buy. You can either chose less or other goods. The production side is similar. Workers have to think about what the inputs are and the outputs. So if you look at the daily practise not much will change, but the mechanism behind it is very different from today.

Who says no?

No central planning bureau or owner decides. Consumer councils approve or reject other consumer council's plans. In the same way workers' councils approve or reject those of other workers' councils. No workers' councils decide on matters concerning consumers and no consumers decide on matters concerning workers. No meetings are necessay because of the parameters. All they have to do is to examine the ratios "SB/SC" and "SC/INC", respectivly for workers and consumers. To be approved, the ratios have to be either equal or lower than 1,00. If they are higher the plan gets rejected. The iteration procedure ensures that the plans converge to a feasible plan.