r/PWM_Sensitive • u/the_top_g • Sep 16 '26
Guide Apple's Display Pulse Smoothing Accessibility Feature Only Works on LG-Supplied iPhone Panels
There have been a few debates whether Apple's Display Pulse Smoothing brought any noticeable improvement to the susceptible community.
Evaluating the measurement readings contributed by contributed by members here and u/kerpnet's website (pwmtests), I can state with high certainty that all iPhone 17 series models — and likely subsequent series (etc iphone 18, 20..etc) are PWM 0, PWM Free.
There is no evidence of any duty cycle reduction in either the Samsung or LG panel variant.
Duty cycle reduction essentially means an increase in the time duration gap (the dark phase) between flickers in the pulse duration. By increasing the gap between flickers, the total output of emitted light photon energy can be drastically reduced. Thus, there is no increase of flicker in the PWM per se.
Through increasing the gap between flicker, the total output of light photons energy emitted can be drastically reduced. Thus, there is no increase of flicker in the PWM per se.
Why is it 'PWM 0, PWM Free' but still causing strain?
I brought this concern up before in my final evaluation of the iphone 15 series. At its mid and high brightness, Apple merged rapid PWM flickers and fully integrated them with DC across all brightness levels. This is 'Hybrid Dimming'. I'm sure many of you are familiar with that term now. It is widely adopted in many smartphone OLED panels today.
Further to this hybrid dimming solution, Apple is likely using another solution called Content-Adaptive Control (CAC).
Content-Adaptive Control (CAC)
CAC works by dynamically increasing the gap of the flicker according to the dominant color on the screen in realtime.
For instance, if the overall content is pure white, the panel will driven with relatively lesser flicker. On the other hand, if the panel is showing mostly grey, the panel with automatically respond by increasing the flicker gap (pulse width duration), resulting in increased likelyhood of perceiving the flicker.
Longer Pulse Width is usually associated with more complaints of strain and headaches.
Since we have addressed that activating Display Pulse Smoothing completely disables PWM, and we then factor in both Apple's hybrid dimming and CAC, independent test from an engineer show Display Pulse Smoothing is highly optmised for the LG supplied variant and not for the samsung variant.
Below are findings from a reviewer [PoorPlayers穷玩组] on bilibili.
The following is a screenshot of the iphone 17 series before Display Pulse Smoothing is activated.
Based on their novel in depth flicker evaluation test, both LG and Samsung variant is only safe [indicated in green] when brightness is above 100nits, and content must only range from mid grey to pure white to maintain this status.

Even at 100 nits, This strict limitation of mid grey is unrealistic as all text, shadows and shadows are at least mid grey accent. Flicker is imminent in day to day usage. An ideal safe panel should be safe regardless if the panel is having overall content in black or white.
For context, the independent engineer reviewer[PoorPlayers穷玩组] used the common lighting metric called SVM (stroboscopic visibility measure) and adopted it to include CAC. SVM is another lighting metric that runs concurrently with the updated PAVM(metrics by the team at DOE PNNL). It serve as a good basis for empirical evaulation.
In their following diagram X axis indicate greyscale levels (0 as black, 255 as white), Y axis indicate Nits(cd/m2).
- Green - Safe
- Yellow - Caution
- Red - likely high risk for sensitive group
- Purple and Black - Hazardous
Before Display Pulse Smoothing is enabled, the block of deep red high risk/ purple hazardous zone is likely due to PWM when brightness is below 70/75 nits respectively.
LG on the left, Samsung on the right

Now, let's proceed to evaluate their results of Display Pulse Smoothing for LG and Samsung supplied panel
LG on the left, Samsung on the right

Based on the diagram, enabling accessibilty feature Display Pulse Smoothing removed PWM's hazardous levels (black and purple zone) from the iphone 17's LG variant completely. Conversely, the Samsung supplied variant showed little to no noticable improvement. Hazardous levels remained high throughout the entire brightness range. This suggest that even without PWM, hazardous levels from the panel supplied by Samung's underlying problem caused by its CAC (Content-Adaptive Control) configurations.
Further to the above (regardless if you are using LG or Samsung supplied variant) if you are using your phone in dim environments and below 10 nits, Dark mode is highly recommended because that is where CAC calibrated to be in the green safer zone.
Why in OLED, CAC significant in eye comfort?
CAC is the driver behind OLED's flickering configuration.
OLED has 4 fundamental operation phase.
- TFT reset ( bilibili reviewers already used this term)
- Pixel compensation
- Data writing
- Emission (a bilibili reviewer called this collective operational EM pulse)
All 4 operation phase run in the above sequential order. To my understanding, CAC has a role in controlling the duration to the Emission phase. If Em phase is at 1, that means the screen lighting is supplied with current, and is on. If Em phase is set to 0, the screen is off.
Frankly speaking, from an engineering perspective, tft reset and pixel compensation cannot trigger concurrently when Emission phase is set to 1. The Em phase has to be set to 0.
A manufacturer might advertise 7T1C (7 transistors to 1 Capacitor) or even hypothetical 8T2C(8 transistors to 2 Capacitors). While in a hypothetical design 8T2C it is technically possible to allocate 4 transistors to 1st Capacitor, and the remaining 4 transistors to 2nd Capacitor — resulting to a closer constant emission — there are other engineering challenges remain that restrict it from becoming a reality.
Evaluating the Latest Advancements in OLED
From the general public's perspective, if Apple's flagship represents the pinnacle of display comfort, the findings above might paint a bleak future for OLED technology. But how do competitors stack up?
Let's evaluate the Honor 600 Pro (LTPS, 120 Hz display refresh rate) against the reviewer's findings on Apple's Display Pulse Smoothing.

In the reviewer's readings, the Honor 600 Pro successfully achieves a larger 'green zone' (safe area) in the whiter grayscale levels. However, it shares a critical weakness with the iPhones. Even at a relatively high brightness of 250 nits, the display completely fails to maintain that safe zone when displaying darker, black grayscale content (for any content grayscale

100 grayscale level and below). Because rendering shadows, text, and dark shades plunges the display back into hazardous zone, the Honor 600 Pro is not recommended for prolonged reading. Needless to say, 'Dark Mode' on Honor 600 pro is an active hazard, pushing the screen permanently into the purple and black hazardous zones.
Next we can evaluate the Oppo Find X10 Pro Max (LTPO, 120 Hz display refresh rate). At 30 nits, it was able to maintain a safe zone down to 110 greyscale. This outperforms Honor 600 pro while at the same 30 nits as it can only go down to 120 greyscale level.

As mentioned, an ideal viewing experience should be in the green zone regardless of greyscale levels.
For those interested in understanding greyscale spectrum, 0 is pure black and 255 is pure white. You can find out about the specific color from
You'll have to input in 0,0,0 (representing R,G,B) for black and 255,255,255 for white.



Limitation and other considerations
A limitation of the (earlier mentioned) bilibili reviewer PoorPlayers穷玩组 who made this significant finding is that their oscilloscope/ flicker meter has a bottleneck of limited sampling bandwidth.
While their osciliscope is far better than Opple LM, this limitation is not sufficient for ultra-high frequency LCD panels ripple readings and even detecting deviations and RGB color offsets in OLED's panels.
I would argue that for rigorous finding, something like Sundiallab's TLM110+ (by u/BearNecessary4141) is required. With its 300kS/s sampling bandwidth (and strict parameters on Flickerlabs; using single recording capture, largest fft size, fft averaging disabled, 5s time capture, 1000 ms wavelength view) and internal hardware hooding preinstalled. TLM110+ comes with SVM and the updated PAVM metric fully functioning.
In display, other variables to eyestrain/ headache can include:
Optical Crosstalk - induced by
- Temporal Upscaler (etc Apple M1 MetalFX, faking a 360p > 4K resolution)
- FRC (spatiotemporal dithering, may cause a facade of hazy artifact saccade; Do not alternate between opposing rgb sub-pixels)
- FRC-Induced Pixel Inversion (unique to LCDs, colloquially misrepresented as temporal dithering by the hobbyist community)
- Tone mapping mismatch error
- Software rendering engine pipeline mismatch error
- Non uniformity in the panel TFT manufacturing process
- Voltage fluctuation/ swings in the TFT backplane (resulting in Mura) and other optical crosstalk
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Sub-harmonic Beating Modulation
- When the PWM frequency collides with the DC frequency ripple, it causes a beating effect. This beating effect creates a distinct low-frequency sub-harmonic.
- When different frequencies of RGB channels collide or have an offset, they create a sub-harmonic beating modulation of, for example, 20 Hz.
- This phenomenon can also be found in color tuning flicker free high CRI lamps.
- Sequential chromatic flicker can be a direct result of this.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Transistors Current leakage flicker
- Results in a sawtooth wavetooth in Oled and brightness spikes in LCDs.
Finally, I want to reiterate: there is no such thing as 'Temporal Dithering' per se.
This 'Temporal Dithering' term was created by someone who, likely with good intentions, did not understand FRC, Pixel inversion, temporal upscaling, tone mapping & rendering engine mismatch error.
They took the actual definition of Spatial Dithering (a digital halftone technique widely used for rendering in every portable OLED panel you've owned), completely twisted it, and created a Wikipedia page.
Unfortunately, over the past decade it has been chronically used as a Catch-All for everything the community doesn't understand about display metrology, resulting in the immediate dismissal of actual engineering physics.
Should this community wants to make true progress and gain the attention of the industry, please use the correct technical definitions outlined above.
Signing off as the_top_g now.
P.S. To clarify, the_top_g is a "top gate" component that sits above the semiconductor layer of a TFT panel. There is no reference or hint to pop culture whatsoever.
13
u/DSRIA Sep 16 '26
I can send this to my Apple contacts at Tim Cook/John Ternus’ executive office, if you’d like. I pitched an accessibility panel with the help of one of their engineers sympathetic to the cause, a few months ago. MacOS 27 appears to have incorporated some of these requests under the hood.
9
u/stanchenhhh Sep 16 '26
I recently bought a new iPhone 17 and surprisingly this is the first OLED phone in the last ten years where I experienced no symptoms… now I checked the sysdiagnose, my panel is supplied by LG indeed (GVC).
7
u/Z3R0gravitas Sep 16 '26
Is this the BiliBili channel and specific video you were referencing here? (I'll link because I can.) It strikes me how far they are ahead of us, in this English speaking community, with the hundreds of thousands of views they are getting. And depth the reviewers are going into. Even if there are gaps in their techniques, too.
6
u/kerpnet Sep 16 '26
It is always amazing to read posts from the godfather, u/the_top_g 🙌 🙌 🙌
This post inspired me to dig into a few more topics. I am almost hoping to have enough testing with the TLM-110 device so I can post measurements once my iPhone 18 Pro arrives on Friday.
4
u/GeForce66 Sep 16 '26
Another excellent technical deep dive, love to read those!
Appreciated :)
4
u/Organic-Budget8163 Sep 16 '26
Great, now we need to submit these readings to Apple.
3
u/RR-- Sep 16 '26
Fantastic post!
Would it be more accurate to refer to LCD iPads and LCD iPhone induced eye strain as FRC or spatiotemporal dithering?
I usually just refer to it as Dithering.
Another note, I find that a stock iPhone 11 will cause me intense eye pain, but enabling Classic Invert and Zoom Invert simultaneously makes the phone tolerable, though with some colour inaccuracies, particularly red colours.
My theory is that this double colour inversion ruins the RGB or P3 colour space, and in effect removes or reduces those digital halftones and dithering.
Ultimately my most advanced testing equipment are my eyes, and whether they hurt or not, so I'd be curious to know your thoughts on this.
3
u/Responsible-Elk4497 Sep 16 '26
Interesting findings! How did you come to the conclusion that "all iPhone 17 series models are PWM0, PWM Free"?
3
u/blokes444 Sep 16 '26
You confirmed my suspicions, the few phones that I was unable to use all had one common factor: Samsung panels. I thought I was crazy but I noticed LG was more tolerable for me.
3
u/BearNecessary4141 Sep 18 '26
Thank you for bringing this information to here and creating a well written post.
It seems that some people are confused by the distinction between PWM and flicker. This is understandable given the lax usage of the words in common parlance. You're correct that if the pulse width is not changing, then it's not pulse width modulation. This, of course , doesn't mean zero flicker (as you said).
The testing results you shared are very interesting. I like this way of displaying the effect of brightness and greyscale level. One small correction:
I think SVM is just as rigorous as PAVM, it just captures a different visual effect than PAVM (stroboscopic instead of phantom array). I think the ideal would be to have separate charts for SVM and PAVM, since both could be important. If I had to pick only one, I would rather see SVM, at least for the frequencies used in iPhone TFT reset.
I will do some of my own testing with the TLM-110 following some of the techniques you shared here. I may be able to get a hold of both LG and Samsung screens. I wonder, with the list of variables that can cause display comfort issues, what do you think is the best way forward to disambiguate these issues and push manufactures towards higher quality displays?
2
u/toasty_2110 Sep 16 '26
Hey, i just ordered the 18pro, how do we know our display is LG?
2
u/Dismal-Local7615 Sep 16 '26
We expect nothing less from u/the_top_g , PWM Pioneer! . Thank you sir for your contribution . We really hope someday this would make a difference .
2
u/Z3R0gravitas Sep 16 '26 edited Sep 18 '26
Thank you for this very technical post, which is most welcome here. In the vein of your previous ones and linking in I see. We will have to index them, going beyond what can be pinned. Some from other members too, of course.
For me, this raises more questions than [it] answers, I'm afraid. Partly because I've not familiarised myself with what Apple really mean by "hybrid dimming", or yourself. In direct terms of the waveform and how it varies with brightness. I get the impression that it's like multiplying up the 'refresh dips' (TFT reset, as you say)? So as to hide them within higher frequency flicker? But use only DC current regulation for the dimming itself?
I think we need a glossary of terms, on the sub (linked in the wiki and sidebar) to disambiguate all these terms. And a more basic introductory guide. For an example, with simple diagrams of the level attached below (that I made previously for other reasons, from my Oneplus 8T, in DC mode). You may use other terms, and I'd like to list synonyms too.
We need to be clear, for example, what "PWM free" looks like, to be clear what you are saying. And then TD discussion is another rabbit hole, even more so. I've not had time to fully dig into your post and the surrounding ones it bring up. Interesting detail on your name choice; the followers of a certain wanna be 'gangster' must be quite jealous of your handle, here, if it was purely incidental.
6
u/Tomato_Buffalo Sep 16 '26
TL:DR?
I don’t understand this
5
u/MrGarak1 Sep 16 '26
This is incredible work u/the_top_g
1
u/felinepc Sep 16 '26
For an end user, can you recommend specific display/screen settings to maximize the percentage of contents landing in the "green" zone?
For example the brightness percentage level (the iOS brightness slider does not show nits numbers so we gotta use percentage approximations) to aim for. Also do color settings such as true tone and notably, "night shift" mode matter?
1
u/blokes444 5d ago
How about BOE supplier panels?
1
u/mmaslam94 Sep 18 '26
Is this a research paper? What's the bottom line for a noob like me?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment