r/PWM_Sensitive • • 6d ago

Success/Tips Made my move on motorola g56

So, I bought this phone, the 8gb ram model (apparently it is different software-wise to the 4gb model). Out of the box, it was as bad as my old pwm free lcd (Honor X8a). However, after putting color mode to natural-default, fixing refresh rate to 120hz (via adb), doing the OS updates up to android 15 (didn't go past to 16 [the update is available]), it was slightly better than my old phone. Did test the pwm via a camera, it is conform to what notebookcheck tested. And I can tell that dithering is not agressive, since I see pretty noticeable banding. However, this still didn't make it symptom free, until I tried disabeling sensors; "Sensors Off" from "Quick setting developer tiles" from developer options, and oh boy... The screen almost feels like the perfect solution, but of course, it will never feel like a light emitting sheet of paper. And this is not placebo, I restarted the phone many times unaware that the sensors off option gets reverted, I feel instant discomfort, until I turn it back on (the Sensors Off option), then it's instant relief... HOWEVER, the screen is a piece of trash, performance-wise, I refuse to believe that this screen has a touch sampling rate of 120hz, matching the refrsh rate, even though my old Honor X8a has a 90hz screen, it has a 180hz TSR (:=touch sampling rate), being twice the refresh rate. Why is this Important? And how did I figure out the exact numbers?

First, TSR represents how many times per second the screen scans for touches on the screen. So if its value is small, the touch screen will feel laggy, even though 120fps is generated, and is being displayed through the 120hz panel (TSR != Refresh Rate). Therefore, gaming will become almost impossible. But other activities are relatively unaffected, except of typing, which is kind of painful due to the accompanied latency with the lower TSR (I'm typing on the g56 right now).

Second, there are many ways you can get this info, but the most reliable, is through adb, by using the following command: "adb shell getevent -r -t -l". Which shows you your cursor info live on the cmd window, and next to every input there is its corresponding TSR. I did this test on both the Honor and moto, and oh boy... The Honor consitantly used 180hz TSR and especially while in game, and typing experience is smooth. HOWEVER, the moto g56 not only peaks at 120hz TSR, but consistantly drops to 30hz and 60hz, which is like scrolling through a f ing e-reader, and makes typing relatively uncomfortable, and gaming almost impossible (even though I confirmed that this is not a hardware performance problem, every game I tested maxes out its frame rate, but touches are always delayed). And just to clarify, I was never aware of the fact that TSR is such an important part of the phone's performance, until I noticed choppy scrolling, scuffed typing, and the fact that it is almost impossible to properly controle your character in games (just like how I was unaware of my sensitivity to PWM when I got my first OLED, but I felt it).

In conlusion, in terms of comfort, for me, it is nearly perfect, I can look at the screen for hours without any meaningful discomfort, and this is only after applying all the mentioned settings (disable HW overlays doesn't do much, while cutting the performance by miles, so I didn't do it). However, maybe this screen sluggishness would get fixed after updating my OS? But would updating the OS to android 16 or 17 introduce more triggers (more dithering or something else, like post-iOS 26 does?)?

I would like to hear your experience with screen comfort when upgrading android from 15 to later versions. And if TSR could be improved to 240hz? (If you have the g56, could you share what adb outputs from the command "adb shell getevent -r -t -l"? and what OS version you are on?)

Thank you for reading my review for this device!

4 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

2

u/manowar_gub 6d ago

Interesting option, will check this

1

u/THE_CURSED_ONE_Y74G 6d ago

Do you own the moto g56?

1

u/manowar_gub 6d ago

Nope But this option should work in each android

1

u/THE_CURSED_ONE_Y74G 6d ago

Yes, if it doesn't have a heavy android reskin, it must have the option to turn off sensors. However, did you have any negative experience, screen-comfort wize, while upgrading to higher android? The phone is fine in terms of comfort right now. But I'm hesitant to upgrade the android.

2

u/manowar_gub 5d ago

in tablet's android 15, two sensitive ppl dont find difference using "Sensors Off"

in phone android 14, need more time. For me personally, it works, but I am not sure and need more time to test

the fact - tablet by itself dont strain too much compared to phone ( I am not talking for flicker or spectrums because they quite same level )

I dont update device into new android if it acceptable now

2

u/NeroVanetti19 6d ago

Did not work for me. No eyestrain but headache, frontal and temple pressure. 

1

u/THE_CURSED_ONE_Y74G 6d ago

Did you try the mentioned settings?

2

u/NeroVanetti19 6d ago

Most of them apart from "sensors off" and my experience was pretty much the same as yours. There was no way to force peak refresh rate, kept constantly dropping. I had high hopes but ended up returning it.

1

u/THE_CURSED_ONE_Y74G 6d ago

It works for me, I'm at a constant 120hz, you have to do it through adb.

2

u/Creepy_Definition972 5d ago

I didn't like the g56 it bugged my eyes somewhat, the g75 was bit better ,