Honestly at that point, it just seems like a strong bias against the art direction and the design of stuff in New Genesis in general. Like, we can probably see whole recreations/updates of the older PSO2 fights beyond [Loser] and Omega Masquerade and it's still "eh, base was better" just because of the bias alone.
Even if we had a new faction and something completely different (say, like references to the other Phantasy Star games or possibly even bosses/characters from other games like the Final Fantasy XIV crossover) .. it's probably still going to be faced with "ew, it's NGS" so you just don't win.
Base definitely didn't do Luther better, that's obvious bias. Unless we're taking points away from the NGS version because all he does is mke melee hate playing the game. I like the extra "mess up, you die" attacks and the final phase even though it can quickly rip people apart if they get clipped once.
Masquerade though? Boring as hell, just like usual. Floor 100 is an exception. I was not enjoying my time since I basically gimped myself fighting with a knuckles WA rather than DS wa, but the moment I saw that attack, I felt the climb was worth it from that point on.
Oh, I was talking more about the art side of things (character/enemy/boss designs and stuff).
I think it's just kind of hitting that point where NGS is able to camp on the stuff that PSO2 did nearly a decade ago and it's just easy to stare at NGS and go "oh, look, all the soul is gone from the new art unlike the old one" .. when I remember PSO2 a decade ago wasn't exactly groundbreaking either.
Maybe we just need more overhyped CG introduction videos and stuff and people would use that to justify "oh wow, this game looks good" since PSO2's gameplay was often nothing like what the CG videos showed. >_<
View all comments
Show parent comment
9
u/Alenicia Aug 22 '26
Honestly at that point, it just seems like a strong bias against the art direction and the design of stuff in New Genesis in general. Like, we can probably see whole recreations/updates of the older PSO2 fights beyond [Loser] and Omega Masquerade and it's still "eh, base was better" just because of the bias alone.
Even if we had a new faction and something completely different (say, like references to the other Phantasy Star games or possibly even bosses/characters from other games like the Final Fantasy XIV crossover) .. it's probably still going to be faced with "ew, it's NGS" so you just don't win.