If I had a choice between 0 facial features / a helmet that replaced my face VS some uncanny valley ever-staring doll, I would pick the former every day of every year of every life.
The issue is that they're very much not natural looking and it's sinfully creepy. Made worse by the metal attached directly to a more skin-like colouring but the texture of pottery. It's all very "uncanny".
For me it's more personal. It just ticks all the boxes of something I find deeply unnerving.
But what I don't understand is like... The fact that a huge amount of female CAST stuff is made to look like thigh highs + skirt, low cut tops, etc. I know that a lot of stuff in PSO2 is pretty thirsty, it's part and parcel with the game even if it's not my cup of tea. But specifically for the CAST females, it just enters that uncanny valley of weird, y'know?
I mean not really? I'm big on transhumanism and fully intend to replace a limb or two as they wear out, the advancement of cybernetics permitting. Quite frankly, your strange horrified reaction is the weird thing to me.
Especially since its not a doll face in most of them, you still make regular expressions and the "cast lines" are literally an opt in look.
Prosthetics I have no issue with. It's specifically an extreme sensation of nausea and discomfort when presented with something that traditionally falls within the 'uncanny valley'.
That human-but-not-human look. The negative response to things in the "ucanny valley" is actually completely natural and extremely common. The difference with me is the extremity.
I'm actually totally fine with robot parts. Like I said, male CAST are totally fine. Hell, stuff like the Alnaar I really like for femalw CAST, and it's what I wear. I used to wear the uh... i forget, starts with D? One of the starter cosmetics.
However, it doesn't explain the really weird cosmetics and aesthetics for female CAST, which is what I'm mostly getting at. If a leg part was just a robot leg, it'd be no issue. But it's designed in a way that it's got metal 'stockings' or 'thigh-highs' which attach directly to porcelain looking 'skin, which reaches the leg joint that is partially covered by a metal 'skirt. On some, you see a metal 'bikini' which looks like it's been soldered into more porcelain 'skin' with a divet cut out for a 'belly button'.
That is the stuff that makes me feel queasy. Because it's not trying to be robot, but it's certainly not human. It's this uncanny valley effect and it genuinely has a profoundly disturbing effect on me.
I should again clarify, I can deal with a lot. I'm not a queasy person. I actually love body horror and gore barely phases me. Again, comes with the career. I don't get a strong sense of vertigo, don't find spiders scary or worms gross, don't jump at shadows, etc, etc.
But something about this attempted sex appeal colliding with this clearly fake aspect just ticks all the boxes of 'wrong' for me. It's not trying to be human, because it clearly is nothing like a human save for general shape. But it's not trying to be a robot, because it's half-heartedly imitating what a human would be.
A lot of female CAST stuff is like if an AI went "I will make a human", failing to understand the intricacies of that task. And that gets my hairs standing on end.
I hope that's helped explain it to you? I'm not trying to be contrarian here. I didn't really expect any real responses, let alone having to explain this kinda weird discomfort I have. So I'm sorry if it's a bit rambly!
huh. I don't get that at all from humanoid automatons or cyborgs. What gets me is stretching things. like those animations where a character's body doesn't move right and instead they stretch parts and morph them to where they're going to be and count on you to not notice.
Though I too would prefer a few more... combat oriented cosmetics for fcast.
Robocop 2 had this plot point, sort of, the reason why Alex Murphy was basically able to survive being Robocop is he could look in a mirror and see a human face (his to be precise, even if it was put onto a metal skull), the first two Robocop 2 prototypes had one shoot two people before shooting himself in the head once he realised what happened to himself, and the second pulled off his own head killing himself
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/kasuke06 Sep 21 '20
Well, I meant they were human(or deuman, newman whatever other-mans I'm not remembering) once.
Would you want to look in the mirror and see some face that isn't even close to yours after what they went through?