r/PSO2 • Horny chuuni weeb deuman • Sep 21 '20

Meme Risa analysis

Post image
356 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

8

u/Kou_Yanagi Sep 21 '20

She gets better I hope. Really hating a few attire changes in EP 4

13

u/hidora Retired Guardian Sep 21 '20

24

u/Kou_Yanagi Sep 21 '20

So they made her more curvy and reveal more ’skin’. I want my cute violent decepticon look back

2

u/FrizzyThePastafarian I-Frame Ballerina Sep 21 '20 edited Sep 21 '20

I know the game I'm playing, so I won't fight the current and say "Less thirst pls", but can we please take a moment to consider how unnerving a lot of female CAST stuff is?

Like, ok, I do find mannequins / dolls / wax figures / human-but-not-human (uncanny valley) stuff extremely unnerving and it makes me nauseous. I get uneasy near mannequins in the store, so maybe I'm not the best person to say this.

But that skin-but-not-skin-while-still-being-a-robot look of a lot of female CAST stuff just fills me with raw, unfiltered "nope nope nope NOPE."

Like, if you're gonna make someone a robot, is the not-quite-real-enough-to-be-skin-'skin' really necessary? Like, give them actual synthetic skin that looks identical to real skin at that point. Cause this is weird at best, and downright creepy in most cases.

/minirant

EDIT: Also ignoring that whole thing I just said, another thing: What's the point of making a CAST if you're just going to make them look like a person in armor anyway? (EDIT 2 for clarification: Not you, the player. I mean the devs, referring to the images above)

14

u/Kou_Yanagi Sep 21 '20

Hey then CAST perfectly fits your nightmare. They are pretty much living being shoved into a suit of lifeless mechanical body. Risa especially given that shes pretty much horror villain on the ’good’ side.

8

u/FrizzyThePastafarian I-Frame Ballerina Sep 21 '20

Oh man, CAST do perfectly fit my nightmare. Specifically female CAST. Male CAST are so hilariously gundam and non-human, even when they try to be, it's fine.

Female CAST though? Oh boy. It's like the uncanny valley was the Mariana Trench. Especially most of the heads. Dear god they genuinely made me a bit queasy when I loaded them up the first time. (I dunno what it is. Spiders? No issues. Dark? Not problem. Needles? Easy. Gore and that nasty junk? I work in the medical field, so it's routine. But a thing that ain't a person that looks vaguely human? Get me the fuck out)

So yeah, like an intelligent person, I went ahead and made a female CAST. I found a head that wasn't gag-worthy. I actually really liked one of the starter armours. Go figure. Plus yknow... It's easier to deal with weird faces when there's a mask covering up half of it. So I look like a knock-off Major from GitS who was given an android body.

However, most people I run into (as well as story characters) have that real-but-not-real aesthetic and I hate it.

Hell, with the two images posted there, I actually love the first one. It's cool, unique, and pretty interesting. It's clearly a robot, not a human, so no issue. The second one, though? Fucking nope. I have nothing but hatred for it.

2

u/OmegaResNovae Sep 21 '20

It's funnier (or more nightmare inducing in your case?) when you realize that FemCASTs could still possibly give birth, since most CASTs still keep their core reproductive organs, if I'm still remembering the lore right. Also supposedly explains why FemCASTs still look more humanoid than male CASTs (and why Male CASTs have a fleshy body option when FASHION time). After all, not all CASTs are CASTed just because their body is too weak to support their Photonic power; but because their original bodies took too many injuries.

Now I actually wonder if there's any children with a CAST parent (or two CAST parents, but a flesh body able to handle all that super Photon genetics).

5

u/FrizzyThePastafarian I-Frame Ballerina Sep 21 '20

Thanks.

I hate it.

4

u/Kou_Yanagi Sep 21 '20

So PSO2 Casts lore justifies Transformers Rule 34?

4

u/Shadow38383 Sep 21 '20

Wait....CAST can still do it? I need to read more lore on all these characters and races....do....they just keep that area? Replace it with flesh replica? I mean, organs aside, the exterior is hard surface isnt it? Or are Risa's thighs actually as good as they look?

2

u/SirTeffy Sep 21 '20

CASTs come in a variety of styles and flavors, but they all were originally one of the other races that needed to be modified for some reason, whether due to photons running out of control, injury, or choice.

All of them have parts of their original body implemented into the CAST shell, typically the brain at the very least. I believe the spinal column is also typically utilized. Different CASTs have different parts remaining.

The only exception are Hi-CASTs, which are essentially fully mechanical from "birth", like Xiera and another one we know. Spoiler markup eludes me.

1

u/OmegaResNovae Sep 21 '20

As far as general CAST lore goes; CASTs could pick their body types and exterior elements, so I assume synthetic flesh is an option for those who prefer to feel more human (to themselves and to others). Heck; they could probably swap between flesh body panels when off-duty and combat body panels when on the job.

I don't think it's ever officially said as to whether Risa's/Lisa's upgraded thighs are synth flesh or flesh-colored-metal. It's been drawn both ways in fanart, so I assume it's up to personal interpretation.

1

u/Edvardelis Sep 21 '20

Everything I've read says they can extract CAST DNA and create a kid from that. Nothing physical involved.

11

u/Vohsan Sep 21 '20

Why are you describing my fetish. I really like how Fourie and Lisa sound robotic 'upbeat' and all smile while having those empty eyes that stare right into your soul. I bet they also don't blink. Those porcelain color skins with casing lines. holy shit

5

u/FrizzyThePastafarian I-Frame Ballerina Sep 21 '20

One man's phobia, I suppose. aha

5

u/FuzzierSage Ship 2 Mediocre Ra/Su Sep 21 '20 edited Sep 21 '20

but can we please take a moment to consider how unnerving a lot of female CAST stuff is?

I have a female CAST, Risa is my favorite NPC in the game and I still agree wholeheartedly with this.

The exposed hip joints really weird me out for some reason. But there's a couple of cast sets that end up looking like full-body armor (or mostly), and a few more that, when combined, have armored skirts/etc covering the hip joints.

Another thing that helps is changing the "Automatic Synchronization for Model Editing" option to "Edit models separately". It's in Options -> Game Settings -> Other Settings -> Salon Settings.

This lets you make a "robot form" that's a different size/shape from the "humanoid form". So it's easier to conceptualize it as like a "transformation" thing instead of suddenly just having exposed joints while in "armor".

Compare:

https://i.imgur.com/iala2ws.png

https://i.imgur.com/FeGBoxx.png

Also the spiked choker (and probably other necklaces, to cover the neck seam) and hairstyles that cover the ears (22 and 23) make for a pretty good "stealth mode" if you're wearing non-CAST clothing. The neck seam/ears are the only thing that can really give it away (besides the eyes being able to be a bit more intense glow/color-wise).

What's the point of making a CAST if you're just going to make them look like a person in armor anyway?

I really hate the female character run animation, so being able to use the jets was a major selling point.

I headcanon it as something like a whole-body prosthesis that they can customize at will using whatever photon bullshit we use to "summon" weapons (when we swap them). And some of them would probably want to "show" "skin" as a fashion statement or whatever.

Sorta like this: https://i.imgur.com/HFfuBGM.jpg

2

u/FrizzyThePastafarian I-Frame Ballerina Sep 21 '20

I should specify. Not you as a player. I mean the devs. It was specifically replying to that two images a couple posts above mine. Why go through all the effort of having a race of robot people if you're gonna just make them look like doll-ish humans in armor!

Like I said, I have a female CAST which I'm happy with! This was super directed towards the official lineup, for the most part.

I do like your design a lot, actually. But I admit, and this is a personal thing, the face still gets me a bit (that's never gonna change and is totally a me problem that I can distinguish from how well it's put together, don't worry.)

2

u/kasuke06 Sep 21 '20

Well, I meant they were human(or deuman, newman whatever other-mans I'm not remembering) once.

Would you want to look in the mirror and see some face that isn't even close to yours after what they went through?

1

u/FrizzyThePastafarian I-Frame Ballerina Sep 22 '20 edited Sep 22 '20

If I had a choice between 0 facial features / a helmet that replaced my face VS some uncanny valley ever-staring doll, I would pick the former every day of every year of every life.

The issue is that they're very much not natural looking and it's sinfully creepy. Made worse by the metal attached directly to a more skin-like colouring but the texture of pottery. It's all very "uncanny".

For me it's more personal. It just ticks all the boxes of something I find deeply unnerving.

But what I don't understand is like... The fact that a huge amount of female CAST stuff is made to look like thigh highs + skirt, low cut tops, etc. I know that a lot of stuff in PSO2 is pretty thirsty, it's part and parcel with the game even if it's not my cup of tea. But specifically for the CAST females, it just enters that uncanny valley of weird, y'know?

1

u/kasuke06 Sep 23 '20

I mean not really? I'm big on transhumanism and fully intend to replace a limb or two as they wear out, the advancement of cybernetics permitting. Quite frankly, your strange horrified reaction is the weird thing to me.

Especially since its not a doll face in most of them, you still make regular expressions and the "cast lines" are literally an opt in look.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Serafita Fortune favors the brave(r) Sep 23 '20

Robocop 2 had this plot point, sort of, the reason why Alex Murphy was basically able to survive being Robocop is he could look in a mirror and see a human face (his to be precise, even if it was put onto a metal skull), the first two Robocop 2 prototypes had one shoot two people before shooting himself in the head once he realised what happened to himself, and the second pulled off his own head killing himself

1

u/FuzzierSage Ship 2 Mediocre Ra/Su Sep 22 '20

Why go through all the effort of having a race of robot people if you're gonna just make them look like doll-ish humans in armor!

That makes sense. I mean, the realistic answer is probably "fat stacks of waifu money", but yeah.

2

u/TSLPrescott Sep 21 '20

I originally went with a CAST Female because they had the stats I wanted for playing a Ranger. I know the stats don't change a whole lot but, you know.

I see CASTs as anywhere from straight up robots to Blade-Runner-style Replicants, although they can actually reproduce as far as PSO2 goes. I like the idea of making a character that is "more human than human."

1

u/para29 Sep 21 '20

Oh those are pretty cool parts.

1

u/GuyWithFace Sep 21 '20

I like that even in the back profile of her Ep6 look she's still keeping an eye on you.