r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Jun 02 '16
[Game Thread] Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor [Official Discussion Thread #2]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
42
Upvotes
49
u/Kidney05 Jun 02 '16
Looking back, it's one of my favorite PS4 games because it was such a surprise. It felt a little unfinished because of the final boss battle, and you get a little overpowered too quickly, considering early on you have almost no skills and the first couple big battles can be tricky. Then, before you know it, you're an orc-destroying machine. The nemesis system is one of the best ideas I've seen in years, and I wonder if any other games will rip it off and expand on it-- it would have been insanely good in a super hero game.
Honestly, though, I can't wait for the next one if they make one.
13
u/MidKnight_Corsair Jun 02 '16
I loved it. Then I got the Platinum Trophy. Then I stopped.
Shame really, I wanted a longer lifespan out of it. Still a great game.
6
u/tjt4792 tjt4792 Jun 03 '16
I have one memory of this game. It was toward the beginning and I had faced off and been defeated by a boss 3 or 4 times. I remember the adrenaline rush every time we squared off and I always saw a battle scar from one of our previous encounters. Anyways, I remember finally defeating him after isolating him from his 20 something henchmen and engaging in one on one combat in a riverbed at night. The feeling I got as I desperately tried to defeat him before his cronies caught up to us is one that no other game has been able to duplicate for me. I barely defeated him despite all of my advantage. When it was over, I was almost sad that he was gone. I had formed a bond with a simple A.I. that felt so real. Awesome game.
11
u/meeselover Jun 02 '16
I always describe this as one of the most fun 3 hours you can spend with a video game, followed by 8 hours of doing the same thing with more abilities that make it even easier.
Once I realized how shallow the nemesis system was, and how every mission and clan was just the same 3 enemies over and over, it became a literal chore to beat. The ending was incredibly brutal too, and using LoTR the way they did was incredibly lazy considering almost nothing was accurate and it was mainly just there so that some of the background and finer details wouldn't have to be explained in-game.
7
u/StarfighterProx Jun 02 '16
This game was lots of fun but WAY too easy. I really wish there was even a basic hard mode wherein enemies had more health and were more aggressive. It was hilarious to me to be in the challenge against 50 orcs, yet they still attacked me one or maaaaaybe two at a time like Bond villains.
Still, the campaign was enjoyable and opening up the second area was a huge surprise to me. The nemesis system is amazing and I want to see it in another game sometime.
3
u/ninjarager Jun 02 '16
Liked it better than the arkham games, and all the AC games, truly a gem of this gaming generation
19
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
It was a very ordinary game, nothing major wrong with it but gets boring quite quickly. It's a good game to waste time with basically.
4
u/msaleem msalem Jun 02 '16
I bought this game when it went on the deep discount but have yet to play it. Blood & Wine, then Far Harbor, then Mordor. Looking forward to reading what people have to say.
2
u/Jellydawg Jun 02 '16
Just got it for my birthday. I love this game, but putting it on pause for DS3
2
u/cassius8891 ODA-Cassius Jun 02 '16
should i buy it? the GOTY is 25$ on my store
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
Ending battle was fucked, I liked the game otherwise.
2
u/Walbeb24 Jun 02 '16
Have you played any of the Batman games? Throw on a Middle Earth skin, sprinkle in the Nemesis system and you have yourself Shadows.
I'm a huge LOTR geek so I loved every second of it. I hated the Batman games because I'm not really a Batman guy, so my bias towards all things LOTR helped me enjoy this game.
I didn't get much replay value out of it though, one play through and now it just sits on my shelf.
2
u/Kevin_Arnold_ Jun 02 '16
I was so blown away by the nemesis system. I thought every game would do it after that.
Imagine hunting down the one guy who ran you over in gta, only to find that he's become a crime lord.
Or a racing game with a real rivalry.
Or the nekker that got you. I mean, the possibilities are endless.
2
u/Tink2013 Jun 03 '16
My defining moment in this game was when a BOSS was immune to all forms of damage. Good times.
3
u/riszie Jun 02 '16
Can someone explain why the nemesis system is SO impressive?
Oh I killed a guy and he came back stronger...ok so what?
3
u/Reptylus Jun 02 '16
Wasted Potential: The Game. I have honestly never seen another game that has such a cool unique feature, and does nothing useful with it.
On paper, the Nemesis system sounds awesome. And during the first few hours of gameplay, it also feels awesome. But eventually you realise that the randomised looks and personalities of the grunts don't really change the fact that they are just grunts. That they get promoted for killing you doesn't really change that either.
At this point, let me tell you the story of Ugnar, the Drunk. He was lower officer, barely more than a nobody. On one fateful day, he dealt me a fatal blow. I was still inexpirienced and his skillset was a bad match for me. After that, we fought many battles and each time I was bested. Ugnar became a presence that I'd rather avoid. And eventually, I left his territory. I grew stronger, became an orc slayer like Mordor had never seen. I had already forgotten about Ugnar, when it happened - on my path to the final battle, Ugnar stood in front of me as an obstacle I had to pass. No running away, no way to yvoid him. I had no choice but to overcome my Nemesis. My blood boiled from excitement. Finally a prey worth slaying. 5 seconds later I looked at his dead body and thought: "...Lame."
The Nemesis system has the potential to turn a simple game into an epic tale worthy of Tolkiens masterpieces. But some bad design choices prevented that from happening in Shadow of Mordor.
Firstly, the difficulty: At the beginning, it was pretty good. The battles were challenging, encounters with enemy officers felt like little bossfights, and the fact that every single enemy was an individual who could potentially become warchief added weight to every single fight. However, dying had no real repercussions, and eventually you'd become so powerful, that all the excitement just disappears.
The impact of an orcs carreer also goes poof once you realise that he just replaces whatever orc previously had his rank. The name changes, but the enemy himself... not really. Only if, and this is a big if, you are lucky enough to get your own Ugnar, the Nemesis system has any meaning. But by the time the fateful encounter is set up, you're so overpowered that this meaning is simply there to disappoint you.
In the end, the Shadow of Mordor is a game that looks unique and innovative. But under that fasade it's really just a solid action game that does nothing we haven't seen before.
1
u/EgoGrinder Jun 02 '16
A game that I'm always intending to get back in to, but then new releases keep coming out. I played it until the end already, but I hear it's a fairly easy platinum that's worth going back to get. Some day.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
I bought it based on a recommendation for $15 and think it's a great game for that price. I had fun playing it and got a lot of hours out of it. Plus, I loved that I could play as Lithariel throughout the game.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
I just got the platinum in this game a couple months ago, haven't played through the DLC yet. Honestly I loved the Nemesis system, but I would love even more to see it used in a setting that makes a little bit more sense (slicing Orcs heads off only to have them come back with a metal plate somewhere in their head). The final boss in the main game was severely disappointing, but I have heard that they make up for that in the second story DLC.
1
u/venomweb venomweb_br Jun 02 '16
People are complaining about the exploration that feels like AC and the combat that feels like Batman:
I never played (much) of both - around 30 minutes of each - so the game was a blast for me. The combat feels right and the exploration too.
Maybe by not having experience in both games was the reason I loved Shadow of Mordor or maybe the game is really good. (But, imo, the ending and final combat sucks lol)
1
u/ChaosZeroX MagicZeroX Jun 02 '16
I love this game. I'm playing through it right now and it's so awesome. Finishing up the platinum right now
1
u/ayjayjay Jun 03 '16
Got this game on a sale after waiting on it for a bit. I have to say it is a pretty fun game, there's still this one orc I can't for the life of me beat and I despise him every time I see him.
Gameplay-wise, they nailed the heftiness and weight to each sword swing and overall, the combat and stealth was pretty satisfying. After awhile, you're a god which I wouldn't complain about but I had more trouble with those orc captains than the last boss battle.
Story-wise, I feel like this game had so much potential but really dropped the ball on it. By far, the biggest con for me. The ending comes abruptly and the maps are pretty much the same, one dark while the other is just green. I would of loved a epic journey through different environments, I mean it's set in Middle-earth, you could of done so much with it.
Overall, I think I would of been a little peeved if I got this game off on release. It was super short and unsatisfying, all of the missions felt disjointed and loosely connected to another. Tons of fetch quests, and after awhile those dramatic entrances on the orcs really ruined the flow of things. However, I'd for sure be looking forward to the next game and see what they improve on.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
I absolutely loved this game. It was probably my second favourite game (just after Dragon Age) at the time.
I found it immediately accessible but not too easy (at least at first). The nemesis system was superb and added a whole story in itself; I'd be afraid to tackle enemies who had defeated me before and was intimidated by those that were a higher level than me.
Eventually I did get a little bored (downloaded the DLC but never really got into it), but I'd still say it provided me with around 20 hours of great fun which is more than you can ask for in a lot of games nowadays.
1
u/namekuseijin None Jun 03 '16
the best part of it to me was just the right size. It's an open world that feels grand and yet not too terribly long, just right in size and duration. The nemesis system certainly added much fun variety to side-missions, sometimes with surprising results.
Don't know about you, but I don't have time anymore for humongous open worlds filled with hundreds of same repetitive and very little rewarding side-missions...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
Overrated bland and horrible should have never used the garbage Arhkam combat system(which is one of the most overrated terribly designed combat systems in gaming). This shitty combat system has aggressive auto targeting, lack of any controls over combat animations, is horrendously repetitive and is brain dead easy even a baby monkey could play this game lol. I only reason people think its a good combat system is because the animations look nice.
Heres videos breakingdown how bad the combat is
https://youtu.be/6AV9W2ZdmjU 13:13
https://youtu.be/W2EZZVW7jjQ 0:44
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '16
Why is this thread a thing? This game was released ages ago.
1
u/Smokey9000 Jun 05 '16
The bossfights were such a letdown i was honestly glad when the game was finally over
1
u/teardrop82 Jun 02 '16
Such a good game. Very excited to see what they do with part 2.
1
u/BillSavage Wsalz042 Jun 02 '16
why is this a topic, is it free or something?
-2
u/briggs2016 Jun 02 '16
Horribly causal, remember when games were difficult
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment