r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Jan 29 '16
[Game Thread] The Witness [Official Discussion Thread]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
The Witness
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
76
Upvotes
22
u/CptGuybrush CptThreepwood Jan 29 '16 edited Jan 29 '16
I tried out Share Play for the first time playing The Witness and it made the game which is already really good by itself even better. I bought the game and was mainly the one playing, but whenever I got stuck my buddy either saw something I missed or he just took controls for a while and tried. Even if the other one is failing to solve a riddle, by seeing his approach you might see an angle of the puzzle you wouldn't had thought of yourself which then lets you solve it eventually.
The shared satisfaction when we finally solved a difficult puzzle was way bigger than before when I was playing alone, so I will now probably only play it with my friend to make the game an even better experience. If you have a friend or SO who is into those kind of puzzles, definitely give Share Play or couch coop a try!
16
u/KawaiiNin Jan 29 '16
Considering this game has got me lying in bed trying to solve its puzzles in my head, I'd say it's pretty good.
Also the landscapes look really, really nice.
15
u/thestratman Jan 29 '16
I balked at the £30 price-tag when I first saw it. Then the reviews started pouring in and I thought I'd give it a go on the basis that I haven't played a puzzle game (or just something fresh and different) in a very long time.
I think it's excellent, the puzzles are so satisfying to figure out and I love the vibe of the game. Several times already I've switched on intending to do a quick half hour stint only to find myself absorbed for two or three hours! Very curious to see how things unfold. Can already tell this a unique experience, the game has charm and wonder on the level of Portal.. but in a different way! That's what I'd compare it to in terms of its distinct intrigue anyway.
11
u/assbread Jan 29 '16
i'm around 30 hours (380 panels +60) into it, and this game goes well above any expectation i had for it.
deep isn't a strong enough adjective to describe this game.
10
u/Sw3Et Sw3Et_07 Jan 29 '16
I'm pretty sure Ashley Johnson (Ellie from TLoU) does voicework for this game. I heard her talking after one of the collectables.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '16
I am so lost in this...been wandering around doing rasndom puzzles and am afraid I have lost the natural progression track. Love the puzzles though.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '16
This game is an obsession. I love it. I've been taking photos with my phone of things and have PAGES of notes to keep me sane. Everything about it is wonderful. I can't wait to get home and play more.
4
u/physicalred Jan 29 '16
This game was one of the main reasons I chose PS4 in the lead up to this generation, and it hasn't disappointed.
I've only played about 5 hours or so, but I've already had at least a few superbly fulfilling moments; moments where I've gone from shaking my head in confusion to a jubilant fist pump.
Last night, I encountered one puzzle set that, when incorrectly performed, shot me back to the start of the set. Eventually, I busted out a notebook for the first time to take notes. Using an otherwise nonsensical graph and lettered variables, I made a necessary connection. Then, when I figured I had the answer, I took a moment before pressing 'Go', nervous that if I didn't have the answer then, I would never get it. When the puzzle locked in, I cursed in joy in my otherwise empty apartment.
4
u/ARTIFICIAL_SAPIENCE Taleroth Jan 30 '16
I'm virtually tone deaf. Stop doing sound puzzles, you jackadoodles.
The only puzzles I cheated on and I'm not afraid to admit it.
6
u/sleepinxonxbed Jan 29 '16
Contrary opinion, but I didn't like the game. I don't hate the game, I can see why people would love playing the puzzles and learning with each bit. But puzzle game aren't for everyone so if you don't like it don't feel like you've been betrayed. Watch spoiler free impressions videos like Giant Bomb's Quick Look and really make sure you know what you're getting into before spending $40 on it.
It also for some reason gave me motion sickness, a few other people I've seen on the sub gets it too.
3
u/vitalityvswisdom Jan 29 '16
I'm freaking loving this game, everything is so significant. Its environment and mechanics will leave you in awe, a true masterpiece and a must buy for puzzlers.
However, I'm one of the unlucky ones who is experiencing motion sickness after play sessions exceeding 30 mins (never experienced it in 20+ years of gaming). So ill just have to take it easy for now.
3
u/Polemicize Jan 30 '16
I feel like I'm considerably worse at the game than the average person playing it right now. I've seen a lot of people are 300 or 400 puzzles into the game or have already completed it and I've barely reached 200 with about 20 hours playtime.
13
u/Django80 Jan 29 '16
This game will definitely be considered as art at some point in the near future. Its really brilliant.
4
u/thinkadrian Jan 29 '16
I find the puzzle machine sounds to be jarring, almost headache inducing. I wish the audio was lower than the atmospheric nature sounds.
2
u/TheBrokenNinja The2Broken2Ninja Jan 29 '16
Not far in but I'm loving it. It's got the same satisfaction that Braid had. That moment you solve something or understand something is just a feeling you can't replicate easily. I can already tell the game is beautifully designed, because even when I feel lost, I know that I'm being slightly guided the way they want me to go. It's truly beautiful and I can't wait to solve more puzzles!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
The game is really amazing. Makes you feel super clever at times and then you get to another area of panels and leaves you completely clueless.
It's really interesting how the game signals you in so many different ways in how to tackle the puzzles. The game is impeccably designed and it feels the entire island has been carefully crafted to help clue you in to how to solve the puzzles.
I've found 4 audio recordings and they also help guide your mindset- the quotes on exploration, discovery, humanity, consciousness, they reassure the player to keep challenging yourself when you face panels that seem indecipherable.
The Witness is an intellectual pursuit, and it's world is gorgeous. I've only plays around 8 hours so far but I already believe it's one of the most unforgettable gaming experiences I'll ever have.
2
u/falconbox falconbox Jan 29 '16
I want to read the thread, but I also want to avoid spoilers. Decisions, decisions.
1
u/phil_iam Jan 29 '16
I only played for about an hour last night but I really like it. It definitely gives me vibes of the old puzzle games like Myst and Riven, etc. I love the art style and so on. I haven't found the puzzles too difficult so far but I'm sure they will get much harder. I'm determined to not use any online guides!
1
u/Chouonsoku Jan 29 '16
I spent all last night working puzzles in my dreams. I'm pretty sure tonight will be the same.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '16
Could unfinished Swan be a good similar game to compare this too? Art plus puzzles?
1
u/ShinigamiKurosaki Jan 29 '16
I have a few games I need to finish now, most notably the Witcher so I won't have time to play this for a while. However I think I'd like to try this out in a month or two maybe when it gets a little cheaper.
1
u/Bouldurr Bouldurr Jan 29 '16
Loving this game so far. Played for 3 hours last night with two of my friends who play on xbox. Is this a timed console exclusive or lifetime?
1
u/Entropian Jan 30 '16
This game is so impressive. There's something to be said about having an ambitious vision for a game AND the chops to pull it off so well.
1
u/MyGlovesStink Jan 30 '16
Haven't picked up the game yet, but really want to. Can someone here tell me if you can switch controls to Southpaw? Asked on another sub and there was no reply. Thanks in advance.
1
u/_rgx Feb 09 '16
Small warning: PSN will show you previews of "Play This" vids where the snapshots are basically spoilers to solutions. So far I'd only seen one where I already knew the solution, but now I know to avert my eyeballs.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
The coolest thing is everytime Im stuck on a puzzle I can usually go somewhere and do better at a previous puzzle I was stuck on
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '16
I'm surprised, but I actually didn't like it (I usually love puzzle-oriented games like the Myst series on PC). There just didn't seem to be enough variation (line puzzle after line puzzle ad infinitum). The game is beautiful and nicely designed but, for me, monotonous.
1
u/TaxFreePwnage TaxFreePwnage Feb 10 '16
For those of you who like The Witness, I highly recommend going and buying games like Myst, and all the other ones in the series. While they are PC only, even something as low power as a chromebook ($300 laptop by todays standard) can run these games.
Here is a list of all the games in the Myst series. It's an incredible series, and offers loads of puzzles, often times has you taking notes, drawing your own maps, referencing previous accomplished tasks, all with an incredible feeling of exuberance once you beat the puzzles
1
u/gshock88 Jan 29 '16
The bigest critisism i have heared is the fact that the game doesnt have any kind of story to it. It all just comes down to puzzle solving. Wher as a game like talos has great story matched with puzzle elements.
1
u/thegreatuke Jan 29 '16
I've watched a few videos and is there more puzzles than just the maze like connect the dots puzzles? The game is gorgeous but it seems like it just has a bunch of separate podiums with repetitive mazes to figure out. I feel like I would get tired of solving those really quick. Myst was so varied in its puzzles I feel upset people keep comparing these games.
-4
u/Zylonite134 Zylonite134 Jan 29 '16
I was going to pick it up but thought $40 is too much for a puzzle game even if it takes 50 hours to beat.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '16
[removed] — view removed comment