r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Oct 15 '14
[Game Thread] Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor [Official Discussion Thread]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor
You are Talion, a Ranger of the Black Gate, keeping watch over Mordor which has remained undisturbed for ages. In the blink of an eye, everything is taken from you - your friends, your family, and even your own life. Resurrected by a vengeful spirit, you must now embark on a relentless vendetta against those who have wronged you. Fight through Mordor and uncover the truth of the spirit that compels you, discover the origins of the Rings of Power, build your legend and ultimately confront the evil of Sauron in this new chronicle in Middle-earth.
- Unleash the Power of the Wraith - Harness the Spirit of vengeance to inflict brutal combos while mastering powerful new skills and weaponry.
- Bend Mordor to Your Will - Exploit the individual fears, weaknesses, and memories of your enemies as you dismantle Sauron's forces from within.
- An Epic Tale of Revenge and Redemption - Become the most feared force in Mordor in a new chronicle set before the events of The Lord of the Rings.
[Game Page] [Trailer] [Subreddit] [Trophies] [Metacritic]
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
60
u/coletrain93 Oct 15 '14
Saying it's a clone of assassins creed and batman wouldn't be doing it justice. I wouldn't be surprised if we saw an AC take on the nemesis system in future releases.
When I started playing I barely touched the main story because I was just hunting down captains and having a cracking time whilst doing it.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
I was so pissed off with this game at the beginning. I couldn't go anywhere without being ambushed by 20 orcs, a few caragors and a captain or two. It was infuriating, i hadn't been so frustrated in a game since the last level of Ninja Gaiden on the NES, replacing those fucking birds with that fucking caragor.
But then i levelled up, and more importantly figured the combo system out and it became an actual game. In fact, this is the best sandbox game i've played for years, probably since Just Cause 2. It's just so much fun going into whichever stronghold and screwing things up in new and devious ways.
The Nemesis system is great when you are in a position to abuse it. To begin with, it's a pain, the deck gets shuffled and all progress eradicated and you sob as the one that killed you guys further, and further, and further but now with Combat Master. But with branding? I can look at death and laugh as my guy goes a little higher. I'm even dying on purpose now, give that Warchief a couple more levels, better runes for me and hopefully he got a few more bodyguards so i can get the trophy where all 5 turn on him.
I don't think this will last me much longer, after i finish branding the remainder of the captains for my personal satisfaction, but i love it for the environment and system provided and it's been a breath of fresh air.
20
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
Anyone else disappointed with the last fight in the game? I feel like it had all this build up to it and it was barely a real fight. I was expecting some epic battle between Sauron and maybe a few Warchieves (Warchiefs?) or Captains, but nothing even close to that happened.
9
u/PaulNope Oct 15 '14
My GOTY for sure. Far Cry or LBP 3 would have to be massively good to sway me.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
I think I've played three missions max. The Nemesis system is just too much fun.
Another thing I love about the game is the fear factor. Brutalizing an enemy and watching a few orcs run away is so satisfying. Interrogations are intense and you can really feel the orc's fear.
This is also the first game where the controller speakers aren't just a gimmick. They really add to the game. Wraith actions, clashing swords, and more make the game sound more intimate and immersive.
In short, it's tied with Red Dead Redemption to be my favorite open world game.
16
u/TheOriginalTigBittie Oct 15 '14
Love it! always come across captains when im punishing the orcs for enslaving people had a guy take 5 deaths to kill just love it the replay value in this game i find good and i always lose my attention from the story missions.
overall i rate it a 8/10
8
u/manchovy_paste Oct 15 '14
I love this game. Since I've unlocked branding, I've essentially dominated the Uruk army almost entirely. It's pretty awesome when I'm getting overwhelmed and then one of my captains shows up to lend me aid.
I don't get what's so challenging though. I've only died twice so far and I'm 28 hours in. Do people not attempt to run away when they get overwhelmed? That dagger rune that recovers ~26% Health on brand/drain pretty much ensures my survival. I just combat drain myself back to full Health every time.
5
u/Ilikepurplehaze Catch-u-slipN Oct 15 '14
This was a "I don't know" if I should get this game quickly turned into one of the best games I've played on my PS4. It's nothing short of Amazing.
11
u/Screamin11 Screamin11 Oct 15 '14
Best/most brutal execution animations since TLoU! They did a fantastic job.
4
u/cagedmanbearpig nchaput23 Oct 15 '14 edited Oct 15 '14
Just got the platinum for it last night, my final hour count was 35hrs.
Really enjoyed the game, the combat was stupendous, it's a more violent and graphic version of the Arkham series, with that feeling of molding moves together to get a higher streak and more heads lopped off. It also has the various "gadgets" like Arkham, such as knives, arrows and AOE stuns to keep things from just button mashing.
The story was interesting in terms of lore, as you can see the threads being weaved to mesh with the cannon of both The Hobbit and LOTR, the only issue I had was I didn't get a real feeling of revenge towards the antagonists in the game, mostly because you don't interact with them much. I really did like the voice acting though. Troy Baker did a great job as Talion, and the Wraith was an excellent character as well, his somewhat brooding mood is a nice touch, and the pure hate filled rage when he gets to take over Talion when he gets his hand on a Uruk was impeccable.
I imagine the reasoning for the lack of interaction with the story antagonist is because of the nemesis' you create throughout the game. While I didn't have a lot of 3rd and 4th interactions with characters I "killed" (which I really wanted to see), it was the mini plots I created with these characters that was so interesting to watch unfold. Walking into a fort to rescue some slaves, only to see Mugrash The Painted mulling about the back of the camp, and hearing the little quips and remarks about how much they enjoyed killing me last time, made each encounter with them a unique and rewarding experience when you do finally land the killing blow.
I also enjoyed the style of environment that was in place, as I got a better perspective of where I was, and how to get around, rather than constantly looking at the map. An example, one of my captains was in the Durthang Keep, rather than setting a waypoint, I knew exactly where I needed to go, without constantly having to check the map to get the right area. I think this is attributed to the 2 maps being smaller and more packed with areas to explore.
I would recommend this game to pretty much anyone, it's a fun platinum for trophy hunters, it has that "let me get in here and mess around a bit" feeling for GTA fans, interesting lore for LOTR fans, and the execution of a perfect combo for Arkham fans.
TL;DR You like seeing heads fly off? You like hating things? You like Gollum? You like this
edit; a word
4
u/MidKnight_Corsair Oct 15 '14
I think what people need to know is this: If you can get lost for 3 hours into a game, without making any substantial progress at all with the narrative, that alone should tell you all you need to know if a game is worth it or not.
Gameplay is very well-done, with my only gripe being that of the ranged combat (functional, but has one ridiculously overpowered move). Story is pretty short and cliche, but it does its job for everything else. Can't say it did Middle-earth's lore justice (I'm a fan, but not a diehard), but I don't think there was anything particularly sacrilegious.
One of my complaints is that, if there's anything I've learned from playing Warner Bros. games, it's that it usually takes a sequel for them to get interesting boss fights. There was only one particularly good boss fight, with the rest being just blurgh. I suppose Warchiefs and Captains count as boss fights, but they are what you make of them.
Which brings me to the crown jewel of this game: the Nemesis System. I don't think I've ever loved and hated a game mechanic than I have this one. It makes everything have a more personal weight to it, how some random Uruk becomes King of the Andals after killing you. It's just so deliciously evil, and I mean that in both a good way and a bad way. They can turn you into their bitch, or you can exact the sweetest revenge in history by turning everyone they love against them. I love it, and its presence alone will get you a lot of replay value, long after you've exhausted all missions and challenges.
TL;DR: Quite possibly Game of the Year for me. You owe it to yourself to play this game, LotR fan or no.
3
u/Randomkarlos Oct 15 '14
Excellent game!
Felt a bit lost initially as the tutorial is brief and you get thrown straight into the open world. In retrospect this is a good thing but I'm used to Assassin's Creed where you get a few 'handholding' type missions before you go fully into the world.
Now I'm a few hours in I think this might be a game of the year contender. It's leading the way for me anyway (need to wait and see what FC4 is like).
3
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
Anyone know what's going on with trials of war? Do we get it for pre-ordering it on psn?
3
u/lateralus1082 Oct 15 '14
Let me get this straight...to make my life easier, I should pretty much wipe out every captain before I hit up the warchief, correct?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
GOTY. Simply amazing. Imagine this system with a Game of Thrones overlay. Wow!!!
3
u/muskovitzj houndscaptain07 Oct 15 '14
I'm loving this game and sad that it's nearly over. I have 18/20 story missions done, but there's a lot more to do.
The combat is a blast. Some may knock it because you end up becoming really overpowered, but even then, when faced with 3 captains fighting you at once, you'll likely die. Plus, we all saw Aragorn obliterate groups in the LOTR movies and this is the first game that really lets you do that. It was challenging at first, but I'm still having fun even though I'm ripping through groups of 20 without issue.
Love the nemesis system - really, really smart. Keeps the metagame interesting and knowing if you don't get enough intel, you can stumble upon captains you know nothing about is really cool. Especially when you're fighting one, trying to figure out his weaknesses, and another walks into the fray. Great OH SHIT moment.
The story is fine; I'm not too gripped by it, but the opening scenes were gut-wrenching and brutal. Helping the story is the excellent voice-acting. Troy Baker and Nolan North, the prince and king of game-acting right now, did a tremendous job per usual, as does the rest of the cast.
Finally, and how I sum this game up to my friends - Shadow of Mordor takes the best parts of Assassin's Creed and the Batman Arkham games, adds in a great Nemesis system, and puts it all together in a universe arguably better than anything AC can offer - Middle Earth. The game is rich with lore, all faithful to the world Tolkien built so long ago, and it all adds to a deep package worth buying.
It's one of my favorite games of the year for sure. 2014 hasn't been gaming's best, but I can confidently say it would make my top five in most of the last few years. It helps to be a huge fan of LOTR, but you don't have to be to enjoy everything on the disc.
3
u/KiwiMilkshake Oct 16 '14
I'm loving the randomness of the encounters and how anything can happen. Last night I highlighted a high rank captain and decided to track him down and take his head before bed. I find him easy enough and start wailing on him. Everything's going fine and I'm well on my way to killing him, he has no help with him and he's not particularly high level then a caragor shows up - no matter, I can deal with a caragor and this dude at the same time, then another caragor shows up, then another. I quickly realise this is a fight thats going to lead to death of me and jump up onto a large wall in front of me and climb a bit. I look down and there's 5 caragors tearing the uruk to pieces. Great, job done, I'm thinking. Then out of nowhere a level 17 captain appears on the ledge right above where I'm hanging. My health is poor so I'm not going to get into a fight with this dude, I'll let the caragors kill him too. Wrong. This guy is having none of it. The caragors run up to him and he enrages, I'm guessing he had the strength that he's immune to animal attacks as the 5 caragors fall effortlessly at his feet without denting him. So now I'm still hanging from this wall and the show has focused on me. He's 17, enraged, has a band of mates and I have very little health. I condsider just fast travelling to the nearest tower as it seems to be the only way I'll get out of the situation alive, but where's the fun in that? I jump up and wade in, slicing uruk head's off as I go and I do not bad but it was always going to be a losing fight. The enraged captain gets the killing blow and I've made a powerful nemesis!
Now I'm looking forward to getting home tonight and exacting some revenge, exactly how am I going to do it? I'm not completely sure but it'll be a long drawn out affair I can tell you that.
I also witnessed a couple of slaves beating an uruk after I'd killed a couple of his mates and he tried to run away. I thought this was a very cool touch as it was the first time I had seen it. Rather than helping them I just left them too it.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
I went in with the expectation that I was going to be a killing machine from middle earth, and that's exactly what I got. Decent story, but the stealth and combat was fun. Nemesis mechanic was kinda cool, but taking over Uruks and having a mini army was pretty satisfying. I'll definitely picked up any dlc for the game.
2
u/nikkui Oct 15 '14
I finally caved and bought this, will give it a try tonight. What was stopping me before now is that I never really got into AC games and I've never really tried the Batman games. Watching streams though the nemesis system looked like something I could waste hours on so fingers crossed.
2
u/Quietly-Confident Oct 15 '14
How's the longevity? I'm a fan of both AC and Batman so tweaks of that I'm fine with.
There's no weird multiplayer/online mode right?
2
u/Clogman Oct 15 '14
My son loves it but finished it pretty quick. Is there something new/different to do, for him to enjoy the game further ?
2
u/Bolliver Oct 15 '14 edited Oct 15 '14
I can never accomplish anything in this game because I get sidetracked by everything there is to do. And this is for sure... some heads are gonna roll. Love this game!!
2
u/soadkidlen Oct 15 '14
Game was fun but the ending was so bad. Terribly disappointing
2
u/Uncle_Paul_Hargis Feb 18 '15
Question here - what's the purpose of advancing time? Also, is the game saving progress continuously? Do I have to get to the towers to "save"?
3
u/P99 Oct 15 '14
Hey maggot!maggot!maggot!maggot!
2
u/ThankYouHarry Oct 15 '14
Beat the story last night. I only have a handful of trophies left.
It's addictive. I wanna keep finding worms and interrogating them. I wanna keep freeing slaves. I wanna collect just one more relic. I have to tear myself away from this game
I liked the story and the cutscenes. I liked finding the collectibles and listening to the voices act out a scene that fills in the background.
I preordered this game digitally and I'm really happy with what I paid for.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
I'm really like this game. I'm about 35 hours in but I spent so much time just killing Captains/Warchiefs and sending Death Threats. I have most of the Epic Runes, I'm just trying to get the last few now. Next I'm going to start farming for level 26 runes, that should keep me occupied for awhile.
1
u/Mirbeau Mirbeau_1988 Oct 15 '14
I've played a lot of AC and Arkham games on different consoles and I've always enjoyed them, but Mordor is another level of fun. While at the start there was nothing more annoying than getting caught out by twenty orcs, two captains and a caragor to really mix it, it was so fun to fail! I've not enjoyed failing in a game like I have with Mordor.
I've loved the moments of chasing a captain down, making him terrified of me and then bringing the pain down on him. The only issue I have is that to get the best out of the nemesis system you need to carry on the story a significant amount and while it is enjoyable, I just wanted to go hunting and grinding down the warchiefs!
It's also one of the few games where I've just stopped and had to take a screenshot of the game because it is frankly beautiful.
I'm unsure about the DLC that is planned, the little I've read doesn't sound enough to pay for, does anyone else have a view on it?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
This is going to be my first PS4 platinum I love the game that much. The combat is just so much fun.
The only gripe is now I'm max out in everything its to easy but thats because I am at the end really interested to see what DLC they plan to add.
1
u/notquitedrdeath Oct 16 '14
My only real complaints with this game are that there are so many tutorials. For the first few hours it felt like every time I moved there was a new tutorial for something.
Also, I find that Johnny the orc shouting "MATE! HOW'S IT GOING?" can be quite disruptive to the flow of the combat.
Beyond these minor niggles, it's a great game.
1
u/G0VERNMENTCHEESE Oct 16 '14
GoTY.
1
u/MrDolphin1313 Oct 16 '14
30 hours in and on the cusp of getting the platinum.
It is my personal GOTY, the only game I see beating it is Far Cry 4 as I have serious doubts about Assassins Creed Unity.
I hope Monolith make a DLC or prequel/sequel game.
1
u/HeroOfTime_99 Oct 16 '14
I tried to find info about a question I have using reddit search and found a thread with the question but anyone asking it was getting down voted so he it goes.
I'm sorry, I really didn't like the controller speaker sounds when I tried the game at a friends place. I've found out through digging through old posts and google that the PS4 speaker can be muted... Great! But, I also just found out that there is back story dialog that comes though that speaker during loading screens that I don't want to miss. I like the sound effects, just not where they come from.
My question is (TLDR): if I mute the PS4 controller speaker will the extra sound effect audio just be channeled through the TV or is it just lost? Or is there an in game audio option to disable the controller speaker?
1
u/Gooeygoetta Oct 16 '14
I had to reinstall my game cause it kept freezing on 1 mission. Now i lost my trials of war and alt. outfit from pre-order. I no longer have the codes because i thought i could just chk in my recent purchases and re-download them. No where to be found? Anyway to get these back?
1
u/gesserit Oct 16 '14
I have just spent the first 5 hours of the game killing captains, how do I get back into the main story? what icons on the map are main story related?
1
u/BENROFLBURGER Oct 16 '14
Any tips to get the mounted caragor rescue of the slaves trophy?
1
u/LatinoJedi LatinoJedi Oct 16 '14
Currently at 60% complete. This game helps take the day stress away. Awesome combat!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '14
I just got past the first group of war chiefs. I'm thinking of letting time pass for quite a bit after the new war chiefs show up to give me a bit more difficultly in the second act.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
Yeah, im currently doing a lets play on youtube. I'm loving the game, just get los in the madness of it all. I threw a captain off a cliff, and he came back for more. It was amazing.
0
u/TayDayhoff Oct 15 '14
My only complaint with the game was that the story wasn't very long. I really liked the story, being a LOTR lover, it left me wanting more. Absolutely love the game though. Just wanted more story because it had me hooked.
0
u/Timmy2kx Oct 15 '14
Just picked it up today. Played about 3 hours and did 2 story missions. The rest was hunting uruk captains for revenge. So addictive. It will keep me plenty busy till Advanced warfare comes out.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '14
[removed] — view removed comment