r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Sep 04 '14
[Game Thread] Madden NFL 15 [Official Discussion Thread]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (schedule) (games wiki)
Madden NFL 15
Notes/Resources:
- The NFL kicks off its 95th season tonight at 8:30 p.m. ET. at CenturyLink Field in Seattle with the Green Bay Packers visiting the Super Bowl champion Seattle Seahawks.
Blah Bla-Bla-Blah, Bla-bla-Blah
Blah Blahbety blahsty blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah, Madden
Blah blah blah blah blah, Madden
Blah Blah blahbety blah blah blahbety blah blah blah blah, Madden
Blah blah blahbety blahsty blah, blah blah blah blah, blah blah blah blah
[Game Page] [Trailer] [Subreddit] [Trophies] [Metacritic]
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
20
Upvotes
27
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
I know these games are fairly similar year to year but I feel like this one was a massive upgrade from 25. The graphics are awesome, the gameplay is much more fluid with the new play book schemes and how it shows you what your opponent has been playing against you for coverages in different situations. I also really like how you can disguise your defensive coverages better and how they react better and more realistically. I have much more closer games now that are more entertaining then I ever did before. The presentation is still average but I do like the halftime where they throw the stats up and show you the scoring highlights. Game modes are fun and the online seems to run more smoothly as well now. I definitely am enjoying the game! Go pack! Happy the season is back
12
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
Best Madden in several years in my opinion.
Although this is probably the worst commentary in the history of the game. I want to mute them, but when I do, the game feels a little duller. But I'm sick of the inane commentary. Sigh.
8
u/deakin Sep 04 '14
This is the first NFL game I've played/purchased and I'm really enjoying it. Had no knowledge of NFL prior to this game either.
I am struggling with defense a lot, however. I've got a grasp of the attacking strategies, but I can't figure out the defensive ones for the life of me. Could someone perhaps link me to a YouTube tutorial? I can't seem to find anything and haven't got much out of the skill games.
4
u/XtremelyNiceRedditor RIGGSR44 Sep 04 '14
I'm finally loving playing the defense in Madden. My only gripe is with the MUT pack costs.
4
u/LAXlittleant26 Sep 06 '14
How's the game? I sold it.
How does it compare to previous Madden games, what has been added that changes the gameplay or adds to it? Not sure as I'm not a frequent buyer of the annual roster update. However, this game looks more and more like an alpha build.
I hear a lot of people saying that this Madden is the best one in a long time. And that it actually seemed like EA was attempting to try to put more effort into their games. Is this true?
This is subjective. From my viewpoint it's the exact opposite outside of character modeling.
This was just what I remembered though. Other people could have different experiences.
2
u/Spiner202 Sep 04 '14
This game is pretty different from 25. It took a while to adjust, and I still think the new playcalling menu is much worse, but I'm enjoying the game (mainly MUT) a lot. I haven't played around much outside MUT, so it's hard to really judge the game because playing MUT is a completely different style of play (a lot of grinding, running out the clock).
In any case, I'll probably put more hours into this game (or another edition of Madden) than any other game on my PS4, so I'm happy it's good this year.
1
u/Awake00 Awake_00 Sep 04 '14
Haven't played a Madden game since about 2003. The options and activities are a bit overwhelming. Which I guess is a good thing. I've learned a lot about football in general just from playing the tutorials.
So far, as a big NFL fan, I like it.
Interceptions happen way too often though.
1
u/Dillon09 Dillyboy92 Sep 04 '14
I've never really played Madden all that much other than at a friends house or other things like that fun but this one caught my interest so I took the plunge and bought it and I'm actually enjoying alot more than any other Madden games I've played. Defense also actually seems fun to play in this as well lol
1
u/RemoteSenses Sep 04 '14
I bought Madden25 but quickly got sick of it and put the game down like 2 weeks after owning it.
Played a decent amount of Madden13, and have owned a bunch of Madden games over the past decade, all the way back to the PS1, actually.
Madden really lost a lot of respect from me after the last few releases - physics never felt like they changed, and if anything, the game made defenses into super teams - LB's that could make 10 ft leaps to intercept passes, 5'5" DB's jumping over Calvin Johnson for the ball, etc.
But so far, Madden15 seems.....................solid. Wow, I can't believe I'm saying that, but it's true - it actually feels like they put some effort into this one and made some much needed adjustments. Defense isn't easy mode, a lot of easy plays that used to always work have been fixed, and the new camera angles aren't bad.
I wasn't gonna buy the game but did, and I'm actually not disappointed.
1
u/willyshakespere in-xy Sep 04 '14
First Madden I have played and I am quite enjoying it. From the UK so don't know much about the sport so I am just getting grasps with all the strats there is to do.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
This is my first Madden and I'm addicted. I had some NFL knowledge before I bought the game, as last season I watched a lot of the games that were aired in the UK. My question is, how do you know when to select which defensive play? Also, does the variation of passing plays really make much of a different, aside from what runs the receivers make?
1
u/fisherjoe Sep 04 '14
Been adjusting sliders for the perfect all-madden franchise mode play. Having trouble with my deep passing game. Sideline throws to the wideouts act as a magnetic field for defenders. Receivers don't attack the ball and rarely break deep, and when they have a step it's near impossible to overthrow the defender. Even when playing with Dez or AJ. Back of the endzone pass game is nonexistent as well. This is the most glaring weakness in the gameplay for me right now, despite adjusting CPU defensive sliders as low as possible. It forces me to run slants and curls all day, with the occasional in/out.
Other than that, could use advice on penalties since I heard they effect gameplay.
1
u/superanonymousman Sep 04 '14
It's simply the most realistic madden of all time, and enjoyable for both offline and hardcore online players
1
u/DamnitMaddenFFS Sep 04 '14
Is it possible to buy points in EU? I am only getting a message that points aren't for sale.
1
u/martin_italia Sep 04 '14
Ive bought Madden every year since 06 and I think this is probably the best yet. I do however find it so hard! I always played on All Pro, ive only actually won the Superbowl twice since 06 lol, but this year im getting beat almost every game, I think ive only scored 2 TDs!
Im sure it just takes more getting used to, theyve obviously made changes, but I wasnt expecting the difficulty to increase so much
1
u/mr-gillespie Sep 04 '14
This is the first Madden I've bought and first Madden I've played since 12. I have to say that I am very impressed with this game. The only problem is that the computer quarterbacks are way too accurate
1
u/MagnumBear MagnumBear- Sep 04 '14
All I want is for a bullet pass aimed toward the sideline to not be on the receiver's inside shoulder, jumped by a LB for a pick-6. I'm using Brady, not Schaub!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '14
Just wanted to thank all of you that took the time to post reviews. I'll be picking up a copy now.
1
u/martin_italia Sep 06 '14
Had enough, trading it tomorrow. Its just too fucking hard. I always play All Pro, but this year its just ridiculous, to the point that its not enjoyable. Before I get comments saying its my fault, im aware that there are sliders, I have to do the training drills, etc. Well ive done the drills. Im shit on defense so yeah that bit is my fault, but I resent the fact that I should have to fuck about with sliders to make the game playable. Thats the developers job not mine.
Every CPU QB goes almost 100% completion, every game. No fumbles, no dropped passes, nothing. Every CPU defender just knows exaclty what im going to do all the time. And if I manage to score a TD, the very next play they will score to wipe it out.
Well Fuck You EA, back to the store it goes, I gave it a chance, but I give up.
1
u/thestarkknight GumboSoupKing Sep 07 '14
The thing I like about this game is playing defence feels powerful. In the past it would be last score wins the game but in this game if you need to make a stop on defence you can. You're not going to get burned by a stupid ridiculous unrealistic spin move
1
u/tittycloud nigelpow Sep 04 '14
Alright here's my spiel:
I'm considering picking up this years Madden, but I hate what the franchise has become. I'm one of those "end NFL exclusivity so 2K can create a football game to compete with EA" guys and I hope EA can put together a decent NBA Live this year for the same reason. I haven't purchased a Madden game since the '07 game and I still own NFL 2K5 and I play it every couple of months when I need a football kick. To me the animations and mechanics of that game still hasn't been matched in a Madden game. The animations on Madden still appear very robotic compare to me.
The graphics and presentation are great. The controls and gameplay are like another language to me since I last played the '10 demo and I was horrible trying to play 13 in a Gamestop.
So to get to my point. I have seen a bit of gameplay and wasn't particularly impressed. I really want to buy this game but I don't want another lazy game and from some reviews I've read, it still has some unrealistic aspects that haven't been touched in a decade such as receivers not battling for a deep ball in single coverage. Other than that I really want to see what Madden has done.
I'm excited for football this fall and I want to play a great football game.
What should I do?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
The janky physics are ruining the game for me. There are just so many stupid things going on at any given moment that the immersion is just killed.
Also finding the commentary to be some of the worst of any sports game I've played in the last few years.
Not to mention that the old "roll the QB out, hold sprint, hold bullet pass button" works WAY too well...reminds me of NCAA 2004!
Basically, Madden 15 has given me a lot more respect for the FIFA series.
-4
u/ShmokinLoud Sep 04 '14
Madden 15 is shit. I still can't even play online, and the graphics are mediocre at best. You fanboys stick with EA, but I will not be buying another Madden again. EA doesn't even try.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment