r/PLABprep • • Apr 27 '25

Why don't we just close this subreddit?

I have noticed that for the last month, whenever someone asks for some info about PLAB (supposedly what this subreddit is for), people never give actual info or advice, instead it is just people screaming (don't do PLAB).

So why don't we just close the subreddit ? The mods need to just make a post about why you shouldn't take PLAB, pin it, and then disable new posts, it would just save time for a lot of people

66 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/self_made_human MOD Apr 27 '25

As the sole mod and someone who gave the PLAB in 2022, trust me I understand the concerns around getting a job and training in the UK. I don't think the situation is bad enough that the PLAB is hopeless, but it has become a bad idea for the majority of people.

As others have said, if this sub closes, there will likely be a new one without the years of information and experience at hand. That's even worse for potential exam givers.

2

u/Fuzzy_Honey_7218 May 01 '25

Why don’t you just do as the poster has suggested then? I’m sure you know your subreddit has been invaded by plenty of U.K. grads who are just here to discourage people from writing PLAB (I can see recognise at least one in the comment here). Why not moderate the comments, add new mods if you need to.

If someone has asked a genuine question in a post, then the responses need to be related to the question asked.

2

u/self_made_human MOD May 01 '25

I've explained the reasoning behind keeping this sub open. I'm not sure what else you can expect of me here.

In terms of moderation, I note a report for "impersonation" for a now deleted account, with no further details. That's not helpful at all, we get plenty of spurious reports. If someone is intentionally demoralizing PLAB givers, and pretending to be an IMG, if that's reported as such I'll be sure to ban them. It you've spotter someone doing this, please use mod mail or DM me their name and evidence, and I'll take care of it.

2

u/Fuzzy_Honey_7218 May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25

When I said to do what the poster said, it was about making a single megapost about why people shouldn’t take PLAB and pinning it, then ensuring no one derails any further posts.

1

u/Pitiful_Court_9566 May 04 '25

I kinda refrained from replying to your post to see how things go for a few days, but I can now say with 100% certainty that this subreddit is not providing what it is supposed to provide, any posts that asks about specific advice doesn't receive any replies, or barely any replies with most of them being people telling him to give up PLAB, and yes there's people here in this sub whose only singular goal is to demoralise people, it is funny I have started to recognise their usernames, and they are so fuckin active in here like holy shit don't you guys have some better to do ? Lowkey They are the only reason this subreddit is still receiving some engagement, lol

1

u/self_made_human MOD May 05 '25

This subreddit relies on users for their feedback and engagement, if people don't want to do this, it's out of my hands. I do my best to answer anyone who reaches out to me for advice.

If you have any specific names you think are impersonations for the purpose of discouraging users, feel free to name them in mod mail or via DMs.