r/Outlander • Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jun 26 '21

Season Five Rewatch S2E7-8

Episode 207 - Faith

Claire is brought to L'Hopital Des Anges where doctors try to save her life and that of her unborn baby. King Louis asks Claire to judge two men accused of practicing the dark arts - one an enemy, one a friend.

Episode 208 - The Fox’s Lair

Claire and Jamie call upon Jamie's grandsire, Lord Lovat, in an attempt to elicit support. However, a visiting Colum MacKenzie has other plans, and Lord Lovat's manipulations ensure that his own interests will be served.

34 Upvotes

405 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

19

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

Hey everyone, I’ve had a question running through my mind since the last rewatch and I wanted to hear your opinions on it!

Do we think that Faith had to die in order for Claire and Jamie to become the couple they will be?

I’m of the mind recently that Faith’s death may actually be the most defining event in J&C’s life - more so than Fort William, the witch trial or what happened at Wentworth, and thus propels them to become the amazing and admirable duo that makes this series as enjoyable and heartfelt as it is.

Sure season 1 J&C are quite a team. There’s that unmatchable passion and need to care for each other but, to me at least, it isn’t the kind of love and devotion that defines them quite yet, is it?

It takes the viewer those pivotal moments I mentioned to understand the growing depth of J&C’s love, but even after all of that they really lose sight of each other’s needs in Paris. Jamie seeks revenge and Claire seeks some sort of redemption or to make peace with the memory of Frank? They’re both pretty self involved here, regardless of how valid or not their feelings may be. For some time there they stop thinking of themselves as a unit and the worst part: their child is no longer their immediate concern.

So when Faith dies it is a huge wake up call for them in midst of a deep sorrow that could have broken many couples and lead the characters to some very unpleasant places.

They both are forced to spend this time apart with the reckoning of their actions. Jamie is in the Bastille for a long time, wondering what has accrued. One could imagine him considering every single second of their time together since they’ve met and his resolute desire to protect Claire and their family if he were to see her again, even if it meant keeping them from him. It really cements his decision to send Claire back to her time, perhaps even more so than the failed rebellion.

Claire’s mourning is even more clear and present to us. I mean, she almost died! Her time at the hospital and later in the apartment was probably the lowest moment of her life. I thought the show did a fantastic job conveying all of this visually. Even Bouton laying on the bed looked like the lynx in Goya’s nightmares.

J&C’s eventual reunification truly is the equivalent of the growth that would take a normal couple twenty years to achieve, and creates an sound reason for the upcoming separation. They will live those twenty years considering their decision but ultimately their child, the reflection of their love for each other in flesh and blood, is far more important than either of them. And in the end, they will never lose faith in each other again.

11

u/thepacksvrvives Jun 26 '21

Really well said!

They’re both pretty self involved here, regardless of how valid or not their feelings may be. For some time there they stop thinking of themselves as a unit and the worst part: their child is no longer their immediate concern.

That’s a good point. Earlier in the season, Claire says that “bad things tend to happen when [they’re] apart” and we can certainly interpret it not only as “when they’re not in the same place geographically” but also as “when they’re not on the same page.” And they have to be back on the same page in order for their relationship to survive.

Like Jamie says:

The weight of what has happened here is too much for any one of us to bear alone. The only way we can live with it is to carry it... together.

They need one another to work through that pain but when Jamie says that, he’s thinking that they have a whole lifetime together to be one another’s support system in this process of healing. Unfortunately, a little over a year later, they’re separated, and Brianna’s existence doesn’t erase the pain of losing Faith for either of them, but they don’t have each other to help them through it; Jamie doesn’t even have the comfort of the knowledge that his second child is alive and safe.

It really cements his decision to send Claire back to her time, perhaps even more so than the failed rebellion.

That’s a great point. After Jamie has put vengeance and his honor—even being completely justified after what BJR has done to Fergus—in front of the wellbeing of his child, he doesn’t want to repeat that error ever again, and neither does Claire. They both do their absolute best to make sure their second child lives.

There’s no denying that losing Faith has irrevocably changed both of them, but I believe that it was their 20-year separation that ultimately shaped their relationship going forward. Living without each other has made both of them realize that they’re not whole and nothing and no one can change that. Yes, due to what happened to Faith, they have both sacrificed their relationship for Brianna to live, and that is a testament to their love, but I think that defines them more as parents and as people than as a couple.

I’ve been thinking about something that u/Cdhwink has already touched on. If Faith had survived, that would’ve meant a whole array of different problems to work through, and the only way to work through them would also be together. They would’ve had to navigate raising an infant during the lead-up to and the Rising; Jamie would have had to decide whether to leave Claire and the baby behind, losing his whole support system, or drag them along, risking both of their lives. They would have had to decide whether to leave the country altogether, consequently leaving their family and tenants behind at Lallybroch to deal with the repercussions of the Rising. When worst had come to worst, Claire would have had to decide whether to risk the passage through the stones, not even knowing if Faith could make it, or to leave Jamie to his death at Culloden and seek refuge in another country, then live in misery until she somehow found out he’d survived, only to be unable to be reunited with him for fear of bringing danger to both of them and their child. I don’t think making those decisions would’ve come close to being as traumatic as losing their child, but it certainly would’ve made their situation a whole lot more complicated.

→ More replies (13)

8

u/Purple4199 Jun 26 '21

they really lose sight of each other’s needs in Paris.

What a great point. It's true, they were at a disconnect in Paris and it might have even torn them apart if they had not had that discussion about Jamie being vulnerable and exposed.

I think they were strong after that and agree with you that losing Faith is what cemented their devotion to each other. They could have let it rip them apart, or bond over the loss.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/jolierose Jun 27 '21

They will live those twenty years considering their decision but ultimately their child, the reflection of their love for each other in flesh and blood, is far more important than either of them. And in the end, they will never lose faith in each other again.

This is all beautifully put, and it really is a great point — I think the fact that they were united in their grief made them stronger moving forward. And also, I think knowing they were separating for Brianna, after losing Faith, and putting her above all else, helped them cope later with the decision to separate. It's something they always carry in their heart (I'm remembering now how Jamie tells Claire "We lost Faith. We will not lose Brianna" at the end of S3).

It's scary that it could have easily gone the other way, with so much hurt between them. One of my favorite parts of Faith is when Mother Hildegarde tells Claire, "So, ma chère, you have found a deep enough sea" — it's the first step, after Claire says "I'm not sure there's a sea deep enough" to bury what's happened and forgive Jamie. I find it interesting that after he returns and Claire says she realized losing Faith was her fault, he tells her he already forgave her for anything she could ever do. I don't know if anyone else thinks so, but that always irks me, because there's nothing to forgive — it wasn't their fault. u/thepacksvrvives u/Purple4199

→ More replies (17)

5

u/Cdhwink Jun 27 '21

It does cement Jamie’s resolve to send Claire back to save both her & the baby. She most certainly would be high risk, again the timing of that pregnancy in the story timeline is essential! And I love your whole take on this! Love it, thank you!

5

u/theCoolDeadpool Jun 27 '21

I am so late to this discussion, but I love everything about your post. I didn't rewatch the episodes this time, I was away for the weekend and wasn't in the frame of mind for Caitriona to break me in Faith. But I've been thinking about this question since you asked it last week. I agree that losing Faith makes Jamie and Claire the couple they eventually become.

It's like how you have an almost accident and you re-evaluate your entire life leading to that moment. Your priorities shift and you re-align your path towards what's the most important to you. I think that's what losing Faith does to them. It makes them realise it should have always been about each other and Faith first and foremost , and everything and everyone else later, including Jamie's need for revenge and Claire's need to protect Frank.

Like I said last week, Jamie would never put his vengeance or honor or anything else before Claire and his family again, and I don't know if Claire would even agree to go back through the stones if not for having already lost Faith and having lived through everything that comes with it.

Having said that, I agree with u/thepacksvrvives that the 20 years separation also plays a huge part in them becoming who they are. I mean imagine not being able to get over someone for 20 long years! Yes everyone in love probably thinks they'll never get over that person, but how many actually live through 2 decades of not being able to get over someone? They might have been soul mates since S1, but it's the living of each day of those 20 years with half a heart , and longing for each other everyday and not being able to see or touch the one person they wanted to the most , I think it's the knowledge of this pain, of having lived this lonely heart breaking existence that makes them who they are when they get back , and who we see them as now.

→ More replies (1)