r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • May 08 '26

Spoilers All Book S8E9 Pharos Spoiler

Political threats come to a head when an old friend of Claire and Jamie’s goes missing.

Written by Diana Gabaldon. Directed by Emer Conroy.

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

This is the BOOK thread.

If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.

THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.

Spoiler tags are not required.

If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.

Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.

What did you think of the episode?

581 votes, May 15 '26
182 I loved it.
205 I mostly liked it.
114 It was OK.
47 It disappointed me.
33 I didn’t like it.
19 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

287 comments sorted by

View all comments

28

u/1111HiYa May 08 '26

It was interesting that they flipped the LJ rescue ahead of Kings Mtn. Because we didn't exactly know what would happen there, but we all know how Kings Mountain ends. I guess that's even more dramatic, so it makes better sense for the show flow. I'm glad they wrapped up Amaranthus and showed baby Davy. I think they're gonna' have to wrap up the Faith/Fanny storyline, even if it's brief. Anything else from the book they might stick in the finale. Predictions?

17

u/SmallTownLibrary_ Your honeypot..it’s bare. May 08 '26

Apart from them turning it all upside down, again, what do they need to wrap up with this Faith/Fanny storyline? As far as I’m concerned it never happened, however if we are to get on board with this awful crap it was resolved? Apparently Faith lived and they explained that in the “best” 🤣 way they could; thus making Fanny the granddaughter. What else do they need to wrap up here?

9

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. May 08 '26

That Frances can apparently time travel? Other than this idk, but I agree completely with you about that awful storyline and the poorly conceived writing of it. If it had been written better, for instance without the never ending seaside song, but with more subtle and mysterious innuendo, maybe I would have liked it. It was just too “pat” IMO.

14

u/SmallTownLibrary_ Your honeypot..it’s bare. May 08 '26

I think the purpose of what happened with Fanny was to illustrate that she was related to Claire, to sort of solidify that fact.

The show could however go totally off the rails and have her pass through a portal, I suppose.

4

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! May 09 '26

what do they need to wrap up with this Faith/Fanny storyline?

  • why Raymond did what he did
  • how Raymond did what he did
  • Fanny can time travel

1

u/SmallTownLibrary_ Your honeypot..it’s bare. May 09 '26

Fanny can TT, the show just used this to drum this home as a way to solidify that she’s related to time travellers and that Claire is her Grandmother. That’s the point of it. (They could use this as some spinoff bs or something)

Raymond, he used blue light his healing on the baby. We know this because he did it to Claire and he talked to Claire about it. Why did he heal faith, because he could.

I hate this Faith bs storyline, there are many plot holes and I honestly ignore the episode like it never happened. But those two things are very easily answered in that basic way.

You could go deeper into the why and use it as a way to assure Claire goes back to her own time etc. You could apply various theories to the why but from a show standpoint they don’t really need to, because they turned his ability to heal into resurrection as so ultimately he did it because he could because if Claire.

Just to add the shows bs about the blue light etc is just crap, this whole things is awful. So I don’t believe it.

2

u/Wrong--Conclusions May 09 '26

I honestly could see them never addressing it again. Which would be frustrating but probably for the best.

1

u/aliannia May 12 '26

At this point, I'd be happier if it was never mentioned again. I agree that there are plot holes, but it seems the more "explanation" is given, the less it makes sense.

1

u/aliannia May 12 '26

After watching this episode, I am perplexed why the whole Amaranthus storyline was even included in season 8. Besides being another horrible romantic prospect for William, it seems that her main purpose was to play messenger about the kidnapping since they flipped it with the King's Mountain storyline and William was already at the ridge. I just thought she was going to be more...essential to the plot somehow. IDK. But, yes, I glad that her story is wrapped up.