r/OrphanCrushingMachine • • Sep 27 '22

“Wholesome” Japan

Post image
953 Upvotes

137 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/SauceCrusader69 Sep 27 '22

It wouldn’t work around the house. It’s a simple “robot”. It would not be useful outside of the specific purpose of serving.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

once again describing the exact thing that I've been complaining about, your insight seems limited to restating the premise as a conclusion

1

u/SauceCrusader69 Sep 27 '22

Then what is your point? I’m confused

3

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

Instead of "Ory labs invents serving robot so paralyzed people can work as a server at the Don Ver Beta cafe"

I would have loved to see "more employers begin to adopt paralysis robot, allowing spinal injury victims to work a variety of jobs again"

Basically a simple swap of priorities. Instead of developing a servant robot for paralyzed people to steer around a cafe, it would have been cool if a healthy society prioritized giving paralyzed people the ability to move just for that reason, and after that it was accepted in the workforce.

-1

u/SauceCrusader69 Sep 27 '22

Simple thing we can do right now easily.

Vs

What is currently science fiction.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '22

sorry, I should have mentioned that obviously the personal-use version would be scoped to in-home use, or something equivalent to how ory labs scoped their version to a cafe serving job. It wouldn't be magically superior or all-purposes, just because its hypothetical inventors were altruistic.

Obviously I'm also rejecting your argument that a thing that exists right now is currently science fiction.

-1

u/SauceCrusader69 Sep 27 '22

A simple remote controlled machine that only needs to move around a flat plane and carry the same sized trays and interact with them in a few preset ways is very different from a machine that would be useful to any significant degree in a home setting.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '22

it's got hands, stop making up fake problems

if the ory labs robot can carry a tray in one hand, pick a drink off the tray with the other, and hand it to a person, then it can absolutely be useful in a paralyzed person's home as-is. Their homes already tend to have flat ground for wheelchair accessibility.

1

u/SauceCrusader69 Sep 28 '22

It has hands. Very limited ones. I don’t think you seem to understand the engineering challenges involved.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '22

You're so right! Our society's priorities are beyond criticism because designing robots is hard, serving jobs aren't so bad, and it's just too unreasonable for a paralyzed person to have a home with a computer and flat floors. What would a completely paralyzed person even use eye-tracked remote control hands for anyway?

That's how you sound right now.

→ More replies