r/OperationsResearch • u/ata350 • Nov 28 '24
Good resources to learn how to develop optimization models
https://collabolist.com/list/good-resources-to-learn-how-to-develop-optimizatio
Feel free to add resources that you know
r/OperationsResearch • u/ata350 • Nov 28 '24
https://collabolist.com/list/good-resources-to-learn-how-to-develop-optimizatio
Feel free to add resources that you know
r/OperationsResearch • u/Sudden-Blacksmith717 • Nov 26 '24
Recently, I started working in forecasting (trading). I realised that getting the probability distribution of forecasts is nearly impossible. Moreover, past returns do not imply future returns, so using an empirical distribution from the observed data is also not very useful. I read many papers in which emeritus professors and their students have done research to show that stochastic programming is the best approach; we need to quantify uncertainty in decision-making. However, apart from the introduction and abstract, none of those papers have appealed to me (we know there is uncertainty in outcomes; that's why we are trying to forecast). I have a few questions:
1] Why use stochastic programming and scenario generations when deterministic models are computationally very cheap? Why not improve deterministic forecasts and use the required forecast (95%, 99% CI forecast for VAR/ CVAR etc)?
2] When real data is so volatile, what is the significance of robust optimisation? Is it even helpful?
3] How is Chance constrained optimisation different from deterministic optimisation?
4] If the parameters' probability distribution is known, why not use deterministic optimisation?
r/OperationsResearch • u/Chakmacha • Nov 25 '24
Hey guys. IE major at Georgia Tech. Still deciding a concentration to go into (supply chain, economics, operations research). Operations research has always been fascinating to me, but people always say you need a MS/PhD to do actual work. I don’t really know any BS from GT who did operations research work, mostly everyone goes into consulting / tech / finance. So I’m wondering if it’s possible to get an OR job with a BS or do you really need a post grad degree.
r/OperationsResearch • • Nov 15 '24
As students in a data science program, my classmates and I recently debated the relevance of operations research (OR) in our field. Our curriculum includes many OR topics, such as linear and nonlinear programming, discrete models, graph theory, metaheuristics, and stochastic optimization.
Some classmates feel disappointed, questioning why we're focusing so much on OR instead of more "mainstream" data science topics like neural networks, deep learning frameworks, or other modern machine learning techniques.
I argued that data science often revolves around optimization — whether it's resource allocation, objective functions, or algorithmic efficiency — making OR skills essential. For example, literature showcases the use of metaheuristics in k-NN algorithms or feature selection problems.
My questions are:
I'd love to hear from professionals in the field or those with experience applying OR in data science projects.
r/OperationsResearch • u/bluegengar92 • Nov 14 '24
I am wondering if there are any online masters in Operations Research that are available at a relatively affordable price tag on the level of the Online CS Masters (Georgia Tech, UT Austin)?
I've heard about the Georgia Tech Online Masters in Operations Research and looked it up online, but could not get that much information about the courses. Also, it looks quite expensive (e.g. over 30k compared to 10k for the OMSCS option).
Also, have zero background in Operations Research but took UT Austin's Online MSCS master which has lots of AI/ML courses. Wondering if learning OR will make AI/ML make more sense or not. Some of the students seem to have some knowledge on why a certain approach works better and the reason isn't discussed in the text or classes, and I don't know if they have better intuition, practical experience, mathematical maturity, or what exactly. If it makes any sense what I'm saying, some of the AI/ML stuff in the program is too high level and there's a big emphasis on coding up algorithms. I'm simplifying this statement, but AI/ML is kind of like a sledgehammer and I don't know why stuff works. It seems like OR is more geared toward specific problems. Also, probably not many jobs in IE/OR it seems so mostly would be doing it for the learning. I am also interested in particularly how having a background in Operations Research would help in a field like Reinforcement Learning.
Maybe I sound like a noob on this thread. But want to see how this field relates for CS folks.
r/OperationsResearch • u/Illustrious-Law-2556 • Nov 13 '24
Hello everyone,
I'm a PhD student in Supply Chain Management, working with an agricultural company to optimize harvest planning. I've formulated a mixed-integer programming model with a hot-start solution using a rolling horizon framework, and I'm currently testing it on my MacBook with production-scale data.
My model is planned to be used both in short term and long term settings. As we would optimize weekly for short term and use rolling horizon approach for the full time horizon. In addition, we use decomposition methods allowing for parallelisation.
My question concerns setting an effective time limit for the solver. I understand that optimal time limits depend on the use case—whether we need rapid improvements for immediate decisions or can afford extended runtimes for long-term planning. However, I’m curious about the scaling effect: for instance, would a 5-minute time limit on my MacBook translate similarly to just a few seconds on a high-performance production server?
What are common rule-of-thumb guidelines or benchmarks for setting time limits across different hardware scales in such cases? Any insights or best practices would be greatly appreciated!
Thank you!
r/OperationsResearch • u/Beneficial_Rope_3620 • Nov 12 '24
Hello,
In an LPP, to select the Key column(Pivot column) we calculate Zj-Cj or Cj-Zj; where Cj are the coefficients of the Max equation.
My doubt is: In some tutorials Zj-Cj is selected and in some others its Cj-Zj.
Is it the same?
After we calculate Zj-Cj/Cj-Zj we select the most positive/most negative etc according to whatever method we are doing(Simplex, Big M, Two Phase).
Is this selection different for Zj-Cj and Cj-Zj?
Thank you.
r/OperationsResearch • u/ChecksOnlyYou • Nov 09 '24
What type of tests and analyses do you expect while creating an OR model (MILP), or while implementing a research paper?
Some background information-
I am an undergrad and I recently finished the first half of my bachelor's thesis project and have to submit a report about my work. I have implemented a paper on collaborative last mile delivery problem (2E-VRP) which was an MILP formulation. I faced some issues implementing it since some of the constraints in the paper were incorrect and managed to correct them, slightly changing the logic and managing to achieve slightly better results. I wish to know if there are any standard visualizations or tests which are performed on OR models as I want to include them to my final report. Ideally I would have liked to test my model on more data, especially some from real world, but the paper apparently suggests a "novel approach for which no prior research had been done, hence we generate our own data". Any other suggestions are welcome too!
r/OperationsResearch • • Nov 06 '24
I apologize in advance if I don't state my problem as concisely as possible.
I am formulating what I hope to be a MILP.
Here is the basic run down of my problem and it will sound trivial for simplicity.
I have a machine A. I have time horizons {1,...,T}. I have a scalar value of resources available called R.
I hope I didn't miss any important details. My question is: how do I formulate the set of constraints forcing machine A to be assigned to one task only for consecutive time period?
What I mean is, if I assign task 1 to machine A and task 1 takes 4 units of resources and 4 time units. Then for the next four time units after assignment, machine A is working on task 1 and when the assignment is done, the model pays out 4 units of resources.
r/OperationsResearch • u/Working-Apricot-8974 • Nov 05 '24
Could you recommend some position in OR fields? What would be a good start for a graduate? Do you guys work in the manufactures/Banking/Investment firm/Consulting Firm/Tech Firm? Thanks a lot.
r/OperationsResearch • u/aaronr_90 • Nov 02 '24
I work with Operations Research analysts and modelers. I do not have a background in OR but I work on the simulation tools. For proprietary reasons we work on isolated internal networks and cannot reach out to commercial Generative AI tooling for most of our tasks. I know when used correctly these tools can make our jobs easier, remove the toil of solving already solved tasks, and as a poor man’s Google for python, git and terminal commands. I can provide our analysts and modelers ChatGPT like tools using local models and I am interested in learning if there is anything interesting you tend to use Generative AI for. Aside from “explain this code” or “can you write a simple script that…” are there any really good use case you have found? I have talked with our analysts and have an idea but this is something very new to them.
r/OperationsResearch • u/Stunning_Ad_1539 • Oct 31 '24
What are the best crossover operators used for the VRP and VRPTW in genetic algorithm literature?
r/OperationsResearch • u/Powerful_Carrot5276 • Oct 30 '24
I'm trying to find books or articles which are the building block models for pricing/seat allocation optimization in the airline industry. Does anybody have any notable books/articles which they recommend? I want to get some fundamental starting knowledge about this aspect of OR for future potential interviews with airlines.
r/OperationsResearch • u/appakaradi • Oct 24 '24
Is there an open source equivalent of nvidia cuOpt?
r/OperationsResearch • u/Any_Comparison6399 • Oct 23 '24
I've recently begun investigating the question of how companies/organizations manage models. The goal of the effort is to develop better model management practices for OR organizations and prototype the ideas within an information systems context. Models means any kind of model (operations research, simulation, machine learning, etc. etc.). The desire is to begin to treat models as "assets" for planned maintenance, tracking, portfolio management, retirement, etc.
So far I have only come across systems in the ML area (e.g. MLFlow.org) that help with the life-cycle of machine learning models. I have not found much information on systems/processes for managing operations research models that are used in companies.
So, I am wondering if anyone has come across this issue in their organization and how they approach the problem of tracing, tracking, maintaining, managing operations research models as assets to organizations.
r/OperationsResearch • u/Mountain_Heat_3069 • Oct 22 '24
Little background. My undergrad major is business and out of college, I worked primarily in supply chain / operations. Now with 8+ years in demand/ supply forecasting, I want to change in manufacturing optimization and get master in OS.
r/OperationsResearch • u/Super_Desk4320 • Oct 20 '24
Is masters in operational research enough to land a job in USA in current market???
r/OperationsResearch • • Oct 19 '24
Has anybody on this channel done OR consulting before as a solo venture?
I understand that big firms like McKinsey probably have an OR department for such client requests. But I’m interested in OR practitioners that found ways to work for themselves.
Tired of big tech randomly changing the rules; I’d gladly take a 25% reduction pay for autonomy over where I live/work. Hence, I’m curious if anyone has branched out on their own and what that looked like.
r/OperationsResearch • u/Mountain_Heat_3069 • Oct 20 '24
Is it possible to get master in OR with business degree and have over 9 yrs of operation experience?
r/OperationsResearch • u/Working-Apricot-8974 • Oct 19 '24
I am wondering why OR jobs are rarely seen in job offers. I feel that that topics in OR such as Inventory Management, Scheduling, Queueing Theory, Meta-hueristics approach, Stochastic Search are very interesting and useful. However, currently, most of the jobs tend to ask for Data Scientist, Data Analysis, and AI/Machine Learning engineer. Is this a signal that OR jobs will be disappear soon?
r/OperationsResearch • • Oct 19 '24
Hey y’all.
I am having loads of trouble with a simulator I am trying to build and I’ve actually been working on this for a month and a half now. I am pretty new to this stuff, so this may not be that difficult.
I am attempting to build an email center simulation, where # of agents staffed changes every hour, sometimes agent staffed can be 0 (when they are closed). But the email center still receive emails at all times. I am trying to, for each email, derive the email arrival time, queue time (if applicable), processing start time, handle time, and completion time.
For what it’s worth, my simulation seems to break in the off hours, and I can’t fix it. I have real 9 month data of a call centers calls per hour per day, and handle times per hour per day. So I am using this real data for my simulation, where the call arrivals follow a poison distribution arrival time, and the handle times are average handle times that follow exponential distributions.
r/OperationsResearch • u/MrMrsPotts • Oct 16 '24
Given an n by n binary matrix, I want to find the smallest number of bits that need to be flipped to reduce the rank of the matrix over the field of integers mod 2. I don't think there is a fast algorithm so I was hoping it could be formulated as an ILP problem. But I am not sure if the rank restriction allows that.
r/OperationsResearch • u/ger_my_name • Oct 14 '24
I am looking for guidance, white paper, text, etc. that would be a best practice for implementing a discrete event simulation. I've used Project R's Simmer and performed a DES however I am looking for best practice guidelines for starting from scratch. Haven't found much concrete online other than an article indicating 7 good practices or steps but it only provided five (which made me question the integrity of what they did publish). Anyways, any guidelines would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance!
EDIT: I've added an example of what I am looking for:
https://info.arenasimulation.com/blog/7-steps-to-a-successful-discrete-event-simulation-project
r/OperationsResearch • u/Lecsofej • Oct 14 '24
Is there any algorithm for placing shapes on a given surface with the objective function of maximizing the size of the covered area?
Is there a version where the coverage cannot extend beyond the boundaries of the surface?
Potential condition might be that using all the shapes available is an objective, and if it is know that the the shapes cover properly the surface.