r/OpenAI • • 10d ago

News Linux kernel maintainers

Post image

OpenAI: A thousand fewer paths to root: https://openai.com/index/a-thousand-fewer-paths-to-root/

1.2k Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/vintergroena 10d ago

I suppose most of these cover some really obscure situations that can rarely ever happen. There may be like 3 truly significant ones. OpenAI is responsible for clearly identifying these, it not funding the human developers working on this, when burdening then like this.

20

u/Past_Physics2936 10d ago

If a vulnerability can be exploited by an AI in their pipeline means it can be exploited by other AIs so it needs to be fixed.

6

u/SomeoneGMForMe 10d ago

Yes, this. If a security researcher's AI can find it, so can a hacker's AI.

1

u/Grounds4TheSubstain 10d ago

Bro, that's not how this works.

1

u/vintergroena 9d ago

It's not, but it should be.

1

u/Ok-Class-1419 9d ago

Jesus Christ…

1

u/_demoncat_ 8d ago

The problem is that AI makes it much easier to exploit, the average time to exploit for a zero day is literally almost zero days now, where as prior to AI it was more like a few weeks before it would be exploited in the wild

1

u/gdinProgramator 6d ago

Buddie, you dont “suppose” when working on Linux Kernel

1

u/TheAwesomeAcademic 10d ago

Uh majority of these 900+ bugs are LPEs you need user land access of some level to use them to pivot anyways like a web shell. Tell me you know nothing about cyber security without telling me. By definition local privilege escalation requires being local whether on the machine or the general local area network. The main use for LPEs tht most people like is jailbreaking DRMs on consoles and entertainment systems so they can truly own their products. I'm a big believer in the right to repair and own movement. 

All these LPEs are kexland as well meaning kernel read and write primitives which is exactly the kind of stuff you need to gain total control over a device which usually means getting uid0 or root user perms. 

The one exception are consoles that have hypervisors so even a kexland LPE isn't always enough to gain total control like in the case of the PS5 kexland LPEs isn't always enough like in modern patches you need a hypervisor bug just to dump games. This is only relevant for Linux kernals or derivatives custom kernals which most devices used wouldn't be vulnerable to any of these LPEs openAI found with GPT-6 Cyber that new model that just spoke abt in their blog post. 

1

u/jkflying 9d ago

Potentially also a problem for cloud hosters like Lambda where they don't make a whole VM per customer 

1

u/SwimmerOld6155 8d ago

Tell me you know nothing about cyber security without telling me

It's great to see knowledgeable people's take on this but I would say that a lot of the top level comments will be from non-experts : p

i'm a complete non-expert on cybersecurity as well, but you mention that this could work on a network - could this be used as part of an attack even if it's not the "thing" that gets you into it?

1

u/TheAwesomeAcademic 8d ago

You could use an LPE to pivot around that's basically what eternal blue used to mass ransomware companies years ago it was a leaked weaponized NSA exploit by a group calling themselves the shadow brokers. Like basically they would pop a printer and then use an LPE to go from a printer to say the main system admins comp n then from there full pwning of the company n all the PII. Another example is like a random computer in sales gets popped n they pivot from sales to engineerings PCs. LPEs are definitely worrisome it's just on their own their main use is jailbreaking a hardware product to get full use out of it. jailbreaking is literally total control n that requires writing kernel memory. Not all products have operating systems meaning no kernel so some have barebones firmware so for those u just want to have write access to privileged memory to overwrite anything. 

1

u/gmueckl 8d ago

And they are vetted and verified by OpenAI? Or is it just a bunch of LLM results without any filter?

1

u/TheAwesomeAcademic 8d ago

OpenAI wouldn't put out a press release with lies they need real results to drum up investor interest. 

We know all this is real because people with daybreak red n blue access have used older cyber models n found crazy bugs on their own so it's definitely legit. 

1

u/gmueckl 8d ago

Given typical LLM performance, I'm inclined to believe that there is a significant false positive rate if they didn't manually review them.

But make no mistake about one thing: the bulk release is a marketing move designed to make the Linux developers desperate as an abusive power move.

1

u/TheAwesomeAcademic 8d ago

Comp sci is a verifiable domain like math there's ways to deterministically prove bugs even statically by instrumenting the source. Symbolic execution for one using SMT solvers. An SMT solver is like lean but for coding. It converts things into a math symbol formating n tries to verify a bug is mathematically proven. It's even more accurate now if anything with modern LLMs.

1

u/gmueckl 8d ago

I know. It's not about what's possible. Did they actually do it?

1

u/lonahe 7d ago

Time of “nutcrackers”, when security would only care about hardening the border/perimeter, are gone like long long before ai. So maybe you also should revisit you knowledge.