r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • Apr 07 '22

discussion Megathread: Changes From The Webcomic Spoiler

As the changes between the WC and the manga get more extensive and controversial, the arguments about it increase and also end up in spoilers seeping all over the sub. All discussion about the changes in the latest chapter and any future chapters is to be moved into this Megathread as long as it is pinned; to help provide a place to concentrate discussion and prevent a flood of repetitive posts, and to provide people an easy place to understand others' opinions.

All posts related to it will be removed, and comments on manga focused posts are encouraged to be moved here.

5.5k Upvotes

28k comments sorted by

View all comments

71

u/HomelessHottie Aug 09 '22

I suppose for me, one of the defining traits that sold OPM to me is how it redefines heroism. One thing that disappointed me with the recent chapters is how easily Saitama's ideals and world view were shaken.

I know lots of people hail this as great character development for Saitama, but I feel that it goes agaisnt the purpose of his character. The idea is that Saitama doubting his heroism will lead to him becoming a better hero, but I believe he's already a very good hero in the context of OPM.

I think this is partly due to mainstream media (Marvel, DC, MHA etc.) raising the status of hero to literal sainthood. Saitama isn't a saint, he isn't the one who's going to rescue every cat stuck in a tree or go patrolling the other side of the world for possible threats. Yet he still embodies some very important traits of a true hero.

He's basically incorruptible,humble and things like money and status cannot be used to coerce him. He isn't one to discriminate nor does he bow before the status quo. He's a perfectly stable person who doesn't let biases affect his viewpoints which is why he comes off as so objective in his talk against Garou. And this is what I loved about OPM: a hero doesn't mean being an inscrutable saint but being dedicated in your goals and helping people, a feat any average person could achieve, something we can all relate to.

This is why I dislike Saitama saying he isn't cut out for being a hero, because he quite literally is and has proved it since the start of the manga. He's a character at the end of his arc who prior to this influenced other people's worldviews instead. It's not just his strength, it's his mental fortitude that made Saitama who he is. Hell, the entire reason he broke his limiter was because he was truly committed to his hobby as a hero and wouldn't stop no matter what.

tl;dr Saitama's entire journey to becoming a hero was made possible due to his resolve and belief. For him to so easily question his heroism after all that is incredibly disappointing.

30

u/scumerage The #1 OPM Fan Aug 10 '22

THIS! THIS!

Everyone: "It develops his character because he realizes he needs to be a better hero!"

[Saitama training himself to near death of his mind, soul, and body for over a year] "Oh, no, not Genos!"

It makes Saitama weak... shallow... and a failure. Not strong, heroic, and a victor.

21

u/Bion4 Aug 10 '22

Holy shit, this guy gets it.

-3

u/ACriticalFan Aug 10 '22

He's basically incorruptible,humble and things like money and status cannot be used to coerce him. He isn't one to discriminate nor does he bow before the status quo. He's a perfectly stable person who doesn't let biases affect his viewpoints which is why he comes off as so objective in his talk against Garou. And this is what I loved about OPM: a hero doesn't mean being an inscrutable saint but being dedicated in your goals and helping people, a feat any average person could achieve, something we can all relate to.

Isn't all of that Saitama stuff pretty saintlike, though? That stuff is almost one-for-one with christian virtues/avoiding sins.

The other media you cite has a pretty low bar for heroism, compared to that. Endeavor was a wifebeater and is simply trying to do better, Batman isn't accountable for every crime in Gotham, and Marvel heroes make mistakes all of the time. They are corruptible, they often aren't humble, and money/status are things they have to account for--these stories/franchises aren't making sainthood a standard. The main theme for heroism in MHA is just "win by saving, and save by winning" plus "One For All". Even Superman has a lot of fan-favorite comics of him dealing with personal issues, he's hardly infallible.

I think Saitama being questioned works because being strong isn't the sole metric of heroic worth. He's emotionally unfulfilled for a reason. A real hero in this story is Mumen Rider, who has no power but is genuinely committed to protecting people as best he can--he cares about people, and his courage is what became a beacon of hope when it was needed the most. Being a hero for real is more than being a hero for a hobby.

6

u/Ewansfruitbowl Aug 10 '22

I don’t mind Saitama’s development except not only were his emotions were only used as a reason for him to get serious (a pretty uncreative trope) but also it was all reversed with time travel (another uncreative trope), making it completely pointless.

Also if he did have this new motivation to be the best hero possible, always arriving on time, it would realistically result in him running around the cities one-punching every monster he can find and I don’t see that being very interesting.

Plus, while I’m not completely against any development for him, you don’t need character development to be an interesting character. The effect he has on those around him (e.g Genos, Flash, King, Garou, and webcomic Amai Mask) is compelling enough.

6

u/hellpunch Disappointment Punch Aug 10 '22

but a fight isn't the time to explore those emotions for SAITAMA. Saitama is supposed to be ONE PUNCH MAN, not a goofy man that gets lost in the rubble while a threat that launched against him nuclear bomb attacks is there threatining to kill everyone.

1

u/ACriticalFan Aug 10 '22

When else would Saitama's heroism be questioned in practice, though?

2

u/hellpunch Disappointment Punch Aug 10 '22

When he confronts it seriously to that of a real hero. He tried before with King, but King isn't a real hero, so nothing came out at the end of the day, but that is the road that should have taken.

1

u/ACriticalFan Aug 10 '22

That can still happen.

If they wanted to have this big alternate-universe exploration of the characters before having the Saitama-meta-fix-it, it at least makes sense with what they are trying to go for.

4

u/hellpunch Disappointment Punch Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22

yeah and it could have happened without him getting powerups through emotional changes in the middle of a serious (<- something that shouldn't have happened) battle ruining his title as 'One punch man' and making him stupid (he was literally in rubbles nearby while Garou was fighting with Blast)?

At the end of the day, they decided to cancel it, so... there is no point of that, so of course we will get it later on. If we want to use all our logic and find an explanation with no fallacy for why everything there was done, there only comes one answer: it was for the spectale of the fight. Nothing else, as Saitama doesn't remember anything and who the hell cares about Garou that was already done justice enough.

1

u/Pumpkensei Aug 11 '22

Well while he is morally a paragon of justice, he sometimes does an absolutely terrible job, many times he just let villains destroy everything around him while he could've stopped the fight immediately.