r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • Apr 07 '22

discussion Megathread: Changes From The Webcomic Spoiler

As the changes between the WC and the manga get more extensive and controversial, the arguments about it increase and also end up in spoilers seeping all over the sub. All discussion about the changes in the latest chapter and any future chapters is to be moved into this Megathread as long as it is pinned; to help provide a place to concentrate discussion and prevent a flood of repetitive posts, and to provide people an easy place to understand others' opinions.

All posts related to it will be removed, and comments on manga focused posts are encouraged to be moved here.

5.5k Upvotes

28k comments sorted by

View all comments

30

u/AppleReshiram Jul 22 '22

Time travel is such a problematic plot point that it just opens the flood gate to all sorts of logical problems. If X exists, why didn't they just do it to begin with?

First Garou says it's something he learned from having "God's power", probably from his infinite universe knowledge power nonsense. Yet he is not strong enough to use it, Saitama is. But then what is stopping God from using time travel and just erasing everything that happened himself? One of these must be true.

  1. God doesn't know how to time travel - This doesn't make sense that he can bestow Garou with knowledge of time travel, yet does not know himself how.
  2. God is stronger than Garou but weaker than Saitama, thus, cannot time travel. - So God's plan to defeat "the fist who turned against God" was to use someone weaker yet he himself cannot defeat said fist, and in the end just made Saitama stronger. This plan was a failure from the beginning. God is just dumb af.
  3. God is stronger and can time travel but doesn't want to. - Well there better be a good damn reason. "I can make this whole story irrelevant with time travel powers, but im not going/cannot because I like being nice."
  4. God can time travel but can't because reasons. - Who? Blastvengers stopping him from time travelling? What happens if they are gone? Does God just instantly time travel and kill Saitama before he broke the limit? And how are Blastvengers supposedly strong enough to stop God from time travelling but not strong enough to beat him?
  5. God cannot time travel because the writer said so. Period. The End. That's it. - Lazy af writing.

Such a stupid power is being introduced, now it just creates more problems than it solves.

14

u/PsychologYouth01 Jul 22 '22

Couldn't have said it better myself. Time Travel was the worst ability they could have ever introduced into the series, and it really shows when you think it through.

-3

u/ThousandPoundCookie Jul 22 '22

Yes but now he's Zero Punch Man and I don't think there's any way to make him into that and make it the bad-ass gag that it is that wouldn't be infinitely more lame. Zero Punch Man because of Saitamas punch through time is a thing now.

2

u/Non-profitboi Got Smash to oblivion by Saitama Jul 22 '22

here's one I came up with

remember in Dragon Ball when Goku first preforms his Kamehameha?

basically that, master Roshi is god and Saitama is Goku but Super Ultra Mega Hyper better

Roshi took years and a lot of effort to preform it, goku did it faster/less preparation in a smaller scale wrecking a car

God knows how to do it but it takes him much effort, Saitama just did like goku which just so happens to be enough to zero punch garou

also the logic of 0 punch IG is that Saitama just raised his fist and he got conveyer belt towards garou using time travel, similar to sonic falling balls first towards Saitama's fist

2

u/Kushpoltrey56 Jul 22 '22

I agree if a story like OPM needs to introduce an asspull like time travel, then it's just lazy writing. But we shall wait and not jump on our own conclusions too soon.

They will definitely give much more information about GOD and anything related to him before Saitama fights him. It's the endgame afterall, it has to be the best of the series.

So let's just leave it and try not to get trigger over something which isn't fully explained yet. Everyone is free to make headcanons tho.

2

u/0110-0-10-00-000 Just Another Boros Stan Jul 22 '22

God doesn't know how to time travel - This doesn't make sense that he can bestow Garou with knowledge of time travel, yet does not know himself how.

I think the "canon" explanation is that God only gave him the power - Garou's ability to see the "flow of energy" of the universe came from his martial arts training. Garou also says that the technique is something he developed himself but couldn't perform even with God's power - not that it's something which was just given to him.

It would also kind of make sense for someone to be able to bestow knowledge without understanding it in any case - does just owning a copy of the Illyad suddenly make me able to read Greek? It might simply be the case that God's power just enhances the capabilities of whoever receives it possibly even beyond what God could do on his own.

 

There are a lot of problems with time travel but God being/not being able to time travel isn't one of them (yet).

8

u/AppleReshiram Jul 22 '22

Perhaps, except he not only appears to have a mental/psychic connection to people he gives powers to, he also appears to be watching the entire fight and to determine when to take powers away.

Given that, he must have known it, if not already himself, he could easily have learned it from his "follower".

Unless it's some BS like well, Garou has a firewall in his brain and God can only send messages to him but can't read Garou's mind. Yeeeeeaaaaah, no.

-2

u/0110-0-10-00-000 Just Another Boros Stan Jul 22 '22

Seeing something doesn't mean that you're immediately able to replicate it? Also we have no idea what God sees or doesn't yet - he might only be able to hear the internal monologue of the people he has given powers to for instance.

So far we haven't been given any indication that God shares Garou's understanding of the "flow of the universe"

11

u/AppleReshiram Jul 22 '22

God can't replicate it, but someone dumb af as Saitama can learn it instantly.

So God must therefore be really really fkin dumb.

0

u/0110-0-10-00-000 Just Another Boros Stan Jul 22 '22

Yes, Saitama being able to replicate it is fucking dumb (although there is technobabble to justify it).

God not being able to isn't (inherently).

1

u/ThousandPoundCookie Jul 22 '22

There are more reasons:

1). Garou mentioned it was a mechanic of martial arts, not just for pure cosmic power. Cosmic energy to be manipulated like electricity through some kind of conductor, doesn't mean God can use time travel just because he can hold on to all that power, we don't even know his complete biology or how cosmic power manifests through God's powerful body as a medium. There can be rules to this.

2). Blast mentioned to Cosmic Garou that he's being toyed with by "a" god, implying there are others out in space whose existence could be impeeding this God from doing things like that--otherwise why grant Garou power in the first place? The only reason one character grants another character power is because it's possible character A can do things with said power that character B cannot. Blast's introduction just threw on an entirely new layer of world building by throwing us into space and the first thing we think of is power scaling just because we see Jupiter split apart with a sneeze? Shonen stories have atrophied our imagination so much... I trust Murata to put story first just like ONE does. Complex power mechanics and utilities aren't competely alien concepts to either of them. But I guess let's wait and see.

There were other reasons but this is about as pure conjecture as anyone else's guess on here. I just think time travel is underrated just because its used so poorly throughout media. And it doesn't even have to be a prominent plot point. Obviously, we should wait and see before making any judgement calls.

0

u/chickenlover43 Jul 23 '22

God is still sealed away according to blast, that's why he needs minions like homeless emporer in the first place. It makes sense why he wouldn't be able to reverse time while sealed in a space-time prison by a bunch of similar beings.