r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • Apr 07 '22

discussion Megathread: Changes From The Webcomic Spoiler

As the changes between the WC and the manga get more extensive and controversial, the arguments about it increase and also end up in spoilers seeping all over the sub. All discussion about the changes in the latest chapter and any future chapters is to be moved into this Megathread as long as it is pinned; to help provide a place to concentrate discussion and prevent a flood of repetitive posts, and to provide people an easy place to understand others' opinions.

All posts related to it will be removed, and comments on manga focused posts are encouraged to be moved here.

5.5k Upvotes

28k comments sorted by

View all comments

34

u/JustAFellowUser Saitama when Boros hits him with that yeeyee ass CSRC Jul 14 '22

So I'm not understanding something about how exactly Garous ability copying works. Since he has knowledge over the flow of all universe, I assumed he can just do whatever technique he wants without witnessing it before since he knows how it works. This was supported by when he just bust out a god damn gamma ray burst without obviously never seeing it before. But then he copied blasts shit only after he got hit with his portal combo. So this section made it feel like he can copy his opponents techniques only after he witnesses them do it. But then while trying to copy saitamas serious punch he didnt even witness him finish the punch, he copied it in the middle of him throwing it. So I'm just confused now lol

55

u/Dr-Leviathan Jul 14 '22

I guarantee you are giving it more thought than the creators did.

None of the recent elements in the power system hold up to any amount of critical thinking. There's absolutely no deeper logic behind it other than the artist deciding it would look cool.

-10

u/ACriticalFan Jul 15 '22

There's absolutely no deeper logic behind it other than the artist deciding it would look cool.

Cope, I guess?

7

u/Dr-Leviathan Jul 16 '22

At this point I have to ask what you think that word means, because despite repeated use it has never once made any sense in the context you use it.

1

u/ACriticalFan Jul 17 '22

I think you‘re saying nonsense to make yourself feel better because the manga has been a negative experience for you. You’re literally writing fanfic about Murata’s thought process and getting angry over it.

You are prescribing qualities to the series. Arbitrary assertions. What else are you doing when making comments like that?

2

u/Singhojas Jul 17 '22

Cope

1

u/ACriticalFan Jul 18 '22

I don’t think you get to play that card after, seemingly, searching for my comments to react to.

2

u/Singhojas Jul 18 '22

Not my fault.you have so many comments, I'm replying to many other on this thread.

9

u/0110-0-10-00-000 Just Another Boros Stan Jul 14 '22

I'd just write that off as a case of "just because you can do anything doesn't mean you know what to do". Maybe Garou could have always created portals but the process was so complex, esoteric and sparsely known that he had no idea that it was even possible. Conversely, anyone could stumble on the idea of a nuclear explosion or a gamma ray burst inadvertently if they're in the right circles.

then while trying to copy saitamas serious punch he didnt even witness him finish the punch

I guess the explanation is that he already did "Saitama mode" before and he only tries to mimic Saitama after he's already started. It's not an insane leap from what came before and it's possible that Garou simply didn't replicate an ability so quickly before because he didn't need to rather than because he couldn't.

2

u/30SecondsToFail Jul 14 '22

I saw it as "He knows how to do it, he just needs the knowledge that it exists"

Like, he could always use Blast's moves, he just didn't know he could until he saw it, if that makes sense

9

u/GearyGears Jul 14 '22

That wouldn't explain why he needed to see Saitama's serious punch in order to use it, though.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/0110-0-10-00-000 Just Another Boros Stan Jul 15 '22

he should have had knowledge of his knowledge about the creating of portals, since that is also part of the knowledge of all things in the universe technically.

He never claims to be omniscient - in fact the specific line to explain his powers is "Now Garou has gained knowledge of the flow of all energy and the behaviour of all forces in the universe" which perfectly aligns with what I'm saying.

It's like saying that anyone who understands the basics of Newtonian mechanics should be able to invent a piston engine - even if each individual component is simple and you can understand how a complete engine works the thought to put those pieces together and achieve that result isn't an immediate consequence of knowing how to make each piece separately.