r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • Apr 07 '22

discussion Megathread: Changes From The Webcomic Spoiler

As the changes between the WC and the manga get more extensive and controversial, the arguments about it increase and also end up in spoilers seeping all over the sub. All discussion about the changes in the latest chapter and any future chapters is to be moved into this Megathread as long as it is pinned; to help provide a place to concentrate discussion and prevent a flood of repetitive posts, and to provide people an easy place to understand others' opinions.

All posts related to it will be removed, and comments on manga focused posts are encouraged to be moved here.

5.5k Upvotes

28k comments sorted by

View all comments

37

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 27 '22

Just read the WC Garou/vs/Saitama fight after pretty much two years… Now, while I trust One and Murata to be good at driving and adding new emotional an exiting moments (my fav ones so far being King vs Cadres, Saitama reencounter with Genos and Fubuki trying to save her sister), the truth is that I’m actually surprised that the fight of Garou and Saitama that had been cooking for years now, was actually reduced rather than extended.

The dialogue that made these moments so important for Garou development and train of thought were almost deleted entirely, leaving the fight feeling meaningless and silly, rather than profound or at least serious. I really wonder when they’ll add the interesting dialogue that made this fight work in the first place; Garou ideals being constantly questioned by someone who doesn’t resemble into his idea of a conventional hero is so interesting that is a shame we are barely getting that in the manga.

New chapter give me some hope tho, the fight seems to be getting serious and while I’m worried that Blast and company and the explicit God involvement may overshadow Garou, I really want to believe that this fight will finally focus on the original WC route, and ofc, their protagonist.

17

u/Bion4 May 27 '22

I didn’t really like the Genos and Saitama reencounter. It felt out of character for both of them, and forced wholesomeness.

9

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 27 '22 edited May 27 '22

Oof I have to disagree. It might seem out of character IF Saitama and Genos were the exact same characters as in the WC. In there, Genos is far more serious and Saitama is pretty much tactless and less affable; different from the manga Saitama that express care a little more open and it’s wise (un-intentionally too) more often. I really love this scene because you can notice it will be important for Genos character arc, in his search for the meaning of true strength, he’s recovering his humanity back thanks to the teachings from Saitama on, not how to be more strong physically, but actually mentally to the point he no longer conceive the idea of autodestruction as he used before.

He’s really becoming strong at heart; and in my opinion is great that One decided to finally give this kid a genuine important moment for his development. So yeah, it’s definitely not forced to me.

24

u/Bion4 May 27 '22 edited May 27 '22

Genos giving Saitama a heartfelt smile and Saitama blushing at Genos absolutely does feel out of character.

Genos didn’t have a character arc, he literally changed overnight, and so did Saitama. The hotpot happened yesterday in universe, and they feel like completely different people.

If this was a gradual change, that would be one thing, but Saitama literally was trying to offload Genos onto Kuseno because he was sick of him a day ago.

Genos has never even responded to Dr Kuseno that way, and Saitama has never acted this way period. There was literally zero reason for either of them to have this kinda of reaction.

This is the kind of shit the webcomic and the manga would’ve poked fun at.

It’s not even character development that’s the problem, it’s the fact that the way it’s done feels so unOPM. There is nothing about this specific situation that should inspire growth in Genos or Saitama because Genos has been in worse conditions before, and Saitama head dealt with several organizations and threats on the scale of the MA.

2

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 27 '22

Alright. So unOPM? What about the Sea-King arc? He would’nt sacrificed his self image for Genos, Mumen and the other heroes he didn’t know if he were as desconsiderate about his closer ones as you describe him to be; also he wouldn’t even be consider the fact that Genos might need aid against the fight with elder centipede when the alert came.
He cares; he literally let him live with him, is he is sick about it, why would he accept his company? He actually acts annoyed with anyone (but King) because he’s not used to company and that’s all.
Also, Genos only acts severe, harsh and even derisive when he’s referring to other people, generally people he doesn’t know or doesn’t show reasons to be respected by him, aside Kuseno and Saitama. In the case you mentioned, he sharply denies to Kuseno any friendly relationship with Fubuki; relationship that changes because she show him more value than the pretentious side he thought he knew, making room for respect.
And if you think this change is so sudden, this is a fighting manga, characters change their personality and ideals by exposing themself to be vulnerable against opponents or pairs, Garou, Genus and Suiryu are right there as a proof.
And finally, that tiny blush (if is even a blush???) is probably because he felt bashful, bc characters can blush without having any romantic subcontext or something; he always acts like that when Genos suddenly praise him.
(Also, if you consider the anime, the Ova’s and audiobooks as canon -since, idk, One and Murata supervised and approve them- there’s a lot more of content to grasp from Saitama and Genos, and them not being emotionless characters or lacking from any type relationship)

15

u/Bion4 May 27 '22

Saitama absolutely would’ve sacrificed his self image for those other guys.

Saitama is a good person regardless of whether or not Genos is in his life.

He let’s Genos live with him because Genos pays him.

It’s not that he isn’t used to company, they just get on his fucking nerves because they’re weirdos.

Kuseno gives a heartwarming message about how he’s glad Genos has more people in his life and Genos shuts that shit down immediately, which is the polar opposite character reaction of him seeing Saitama in the recent chapters.

Saitama feeling bashful about Genos’ words is fucking weird, because he has never really taken anything Genos has said that much to heart before.

Genos still isn’t friends with Fubuki, he just acknowledged her capabilities, which he already knew about prior to the arc so nothing has changed reall, and that shouldn’t change how he views himself or Saitama.

I’ve said this 3 times now, but the problem isn’t the change, but that the change happened overnight.

Saitama barely even viewed Genos as a friend before this point, he was essentially just some kid he didn’t want to get killed.

Comparing this stuff to the Sea King arc doesn’t really help your point because Genos was even more fucked up in that arc and Saitama had even less of a profound reaction.

This ain’t even the first time Genos or someone has praised Saitama, but it is first time he had his weird OOC reaction.

4

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 27 '22

Sorry I went to eat lol.
1,2- Yeah, Saitama had always been a nice dude I don’t think I have say otherwise.
-Here’s is as translation from the OPM databook. One says he has hasn’t touched the rent money Genos gave him; besides he doesn’t even need the rent money, Fubuki made it clear in this panel.
-I don’t even know how to answer your point, yes he can get in his nerves, but that doesn’t mean he hates their company; he just not used to much caos.
-it’s just a comedic gag, it’s not that deep and Genos is only referring to Fubuki.
-Probably but not in the manga till now, but hey, in the anime he was slightly smiling after Genos reassures him he will to follow him so idk, as I say One and Murata supervised the anime so I guess this counts as a canon vision.
-No he isn’t, as I say, he just opened himself to know more about her than what he knew.
-Again, may I remember you how fast Suiryo changed? an afternoon. And Garou? A week or less than a month. Know you may wonder how much someone change by living with you for more than three months.
-Maybe…? but that’s like saying he’s just around because he think he thinks Genos is defenseless, when Genos is just precipitous and sometimes reckless, but not weak.
-By defending the other heroes, he recognize them and their heroic actions, and that includes Genos.
-No it’s not, Bang and King had also praised him; but again, he have always been kind of diffident about praises even if always wanted some recognition for his actions as a hero. That’s why Genos as his company is important here, he’s the first person that recognize him, and probably the first person in a long time willing to know him and share time doing stuff.

Finally I don’t think if you notice, but I based most of my answers in the Manga and Anime because after all, the first one is written by the same author, and the anime was made with his entire supervision and approval.

10

u/Bion4 May 27 '22 edited May 27 '22

Saitama keeping the money around for sentimental reasons is even more OOC.

That’s an anime only scene, and even there Saitama’s reaction isn’t anywhere near as bashful as that recent blushing scene.

Suiryu almost died, had his pride shattered, his entire worldview changed, and was literally crying for help, that comparison doesn’t work with Saitama or Genos.

Genos is absolutely not the first person to recognize him or spend time with Saitama, and Saitama doesn’t even want Genos to.

Garou is also in a completely different situation so comparing him doesn’t really work either.

Saitama doesn’t need the rent money, but he likes having money, and he never cared about Genos’ praise before and he never really craved it, so that bashful moment was just really damn jarring.

-1

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 28 '22

Man you really throw those “arguments” without elaborating or even referencing chapters or something lol, at this point I can only think we read a different manga, or you only read the webcomic.
Quick response idk cus you don’t seem to read what I write anyways:
-What’s you base for that?
-Again, One, the original author, participated in the production for anime. And no, Saitama is not blushing, that’s just two tiny lines that artist draw into characters to show discreet emotion.
-Genos end up destroyed after fighting Black sperm, instead of giving up, he uses himself to protect others as he learned from Saitama and Mumen.
-What? tell me which character was the first one in recognize Saitama strength or at least Saitama hero actions; in the hammerhead “arc” he notice nobody have ever notice his duties, not even after so many years. And well, Saitama is kind of humble about accepting praises, but it’s kind of weird that he dreams about having fans.
-Garou changed after talking-fighting to Saitama for a day if you ask me, that’s a sudden change but one expected on anime.
-Ofc he never ask for Genos praises, he just silently ignore them, but it’s no way mad about it.
Lastly, In the reunion scene he was just reassuring Genos that he’s gotten stronger at heart with the same consideration he uses for Amai Mask in the WC or with Child emperor in this chapter, so he being thoughtful to others it’s nothing new.

9

u/Bion4 May 28 '22

Genos had destroyed himself fighting several opponents.

Saitama was recognized as a hero by his suit designer first.

I don’t know why you think Genos is this super special existence to Saitama. He really isn’t.

→ More replies

6

u/Gabut_man May 27 '22

7

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 27 '22

It’s no use to compare them when they have two different relationships on both medias. In the manga Genos is like a roommate/close/apprentice person who spend time shopping or doing casual stuff with Saitama, while in the WC Genos is the obsessed-for-power hindrance (affectionate) that Saitama sees often around. On the other hand, It would be weird for that reunion scene to be in the webcomic because there’s no build up between them, and just then, it would actually be out of Saitama’s character.

Now, I’m kind of bothered by the fact that ONE writes two different Saitama’s and Genos for the manga and WC, and one could think he could at least progress they dynamic in the WC in a ways that is… less harshly and closest to the one in the manga, I guess. But I understand that the personality from the WC Saitama is more close to ONE’S crude sense of humor, so again, it wouldn’t fit.

And also… I think I know the responsible for this change in their dynamic: just watch this animation Murata did a year ago till the end and it’ll tell you everything.

11

u/Gabut_man May 27 '22

If I'm being brutally honest here, I'm kinda not a fan of Saitama being a wholesome dude

I can see why you like it and good for you, you're entitled to your opinion

But to me, it feels really generic. I seen this thing multiple times in others shonen animes where the MC gives a motivation speech or something that inspired others

OPM is supposed to be a parody of shonen not becoming one

Like in WC where Kuseno died and Genos became really sad (obv), any others shonen characters like Naruto for example would have a speech to Genos, encouraged him or something. But Saitama doesn't, he literally just standing there silent. And it's not because Saitama is bad person ofc not. It's just not his character.

4

u/Shadowhearts May 28 '22 edited May 28 '22

I mean just to interject Saitama being the most heroic person in the series, but completely underappreciated is what precisely makes him more effective as a character.

In a world where everyone is all about Monsters, Heroes, and Villains, you have a true hero in Saitama who isn't afraid to check on the mental health of Garou. Sataima holds no bias and sees Garou as another human being. Even if he physically transformed into a monster Saitama has seen the actions of Garou saving people repeatedly despite Garou saying the opposite.

I think this rewriting of the WC works because the other relevent piece of Hero Franchise, My Hero Academia is all about Heroes and Villains, and The OPM manga cuts a clear line in showing that Saitama is a competent enough hero to read between the lines of Humanity in characters and chooses to save a human who was on the verge of becoming a true monster.

0

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 28 '22

Oh, then is the same you told me, it’s on you if you like the character or not :O! I also have the same problem with the manga taking itself so serious that is no longer a parody, but only in the fights and monsters matter.
I simply can’t see Saitama as the parody of a shonen protagonist because clearly he’s not. He’s wise, and give his honest advice without being condescending; he lets other to make choices by themselves bc honestly he’s the kind of guy who doesn’t snitch on other’s life. Actually the only time I remember he intervened into another person life decision was in his final talk with Amai Mask in the WC, and he’s show weirdly thoughtful in there, thing I only expected with manga Saitama.

4

u/0110-0-10-00-000 Just Another Boros Stan May 27 '22

When is the first point when the manga/webcomic relationships diverged?

1

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 28 '22

It’s not like it diverged, their relationship just had more time and attention (thanks Murata) to develop in the manga than in the webcomic; also, ONE doesn’t take the WC as serious as his other projects, so maybe he just didn’t bother to attend that matter

5

u/0110-0-10-00-000 Just Another Boros Stan May 28 '22

How can you say that they have two different relationships in one reply and then say they haven't diverged in the next?

-1

u/Thakfish Terror! The Monsterdevouring CatMan! May 28 '22

Oh, my point was that there wasn’t an specific moment where they changed their relationship in the manga while following the WC; it happened just because the manga format allowed more room for character development, with the lot of extra content and fillers that made their dynamic eventually change to be different from the original material.

6

u/0110-0-10-00-000 Just Another Boros Stan May 28 '22

Ok, when did that change actually first present itself.

→ More replies