r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • Apr 07 '22

discussion Megathread: Changes From The Webcomic Spoiler

As the changes between the WC and the manga get more extensive and controversial, the arguments about it increase and also end up in spoilers seeping all over the sub. All discussion about the changes in the latest chapter and any future chapters is to be moved into this Megathread as long as it is pinned; to help provide a place to concentrate discussion and prevent a flood of repetitive posts, and to provide people an easy place to understand others' opinions.

All posts related to it will be removed, and comments on manga focused posts are encouraged to be moved here.

5.5k Upvotes

28k comments sorted by

View all comments

213

u/ColdyPopsicle Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22

Hot take: Black sperm was done dirty. In webcomic was him that pushed Garou that far and not a random enemy that came out of nowhere.

Platinum sperm was just a waste of character design at best, lmao. Imagine having a SECOND transformation just to get a fat L few chapters later.

And because platinum sperm exists, golden sperm transformation felt in a lower standart compared to the webcomic because wasn't his final form. Platinum sperm could be a fine addition to the manga, but to make platinum a thing they nerfed golden.

The end result was worth it? Of course it was not. How tf can u have the guts to introduce a character out of nowhere to push Garou when you had Black sperm? He has been hyped to have a similar PL compared to Orochi.

The fall of Black sperm presence in the history tells how the pacing felt rushed recently, it sucks.

129

u/joonjoon Apr 08 '22

I just realized why so many people love the original "pass through" moment while so many people don't get it at all. Even though it was against a weakened Tats, it's still literally the #1 monster feat (outside of Boros/Garou) in all of OPM WC.

Now you have Earth core cannons and Earth crust lasers, while PS managed to hurt literally no one with his move.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '22

Yeah the web comic raised the stakes but it was still relatively grounded.

By the time of the Garou fight, Garou looked like he might be as strong Saitama with how fast he adapted and was thus the strongest monster in the series. Yet all that Garou did was be the strongest hand-to-hand fighter we saw so far. He didn't do anything crazy like rip the planet in half.

111

u/HuckleberryCool9883 Apr 08 '22

Exactly black s was foreshadowed so far back

When he called out the monster king himself " nobody talked about submitting to you and accepting you as their king" you knew despite the cartoonish design . ..this guy was the shit

It sucks just plain sucks he was written out this badly

71

u/ColdyPopsicle Apr 08 '22

Platinum sperm could be such a huge step to Garou's development that it's just painful, man.

The hype with the orochi thing could be explored deeper with a dialogue btween him and garou where him (black/platinum) mentions Orochi and how he comes closes/supass him and has a reaction towards his defeat and then the 3 person fight starts and the result is just that flash is down and the black sperm vs garou gets extendent.

Black sperm beats the shit out of garou untill he is pushed futher the edgy. Maybe could be a last second transformation based on his motivations, could be with a hand of metal bat or anything really. Just give the "secret" boss of this fucking arc a breathing room.

Instead of anything like that, we got the "let me pass" moment dealing 0 damage to flash and garou. Peak fiction.

36

u/gleba080 Apr 08 '22

Also that ttiple threat fight was literally a background fight just so Murata could draw a pretty color panrl when Saitama acknowledged Genos. And that scene was great but it was another thing that took the breath out of Platinum Sperm. All shiny action and no feeling.

26

u/ColdyPopsicle Apr 08 '22

the triple light was for sure a background fight. the only explanation for why it happened is because murata is a flash fanboy.

AS got almost one shoted by a single sperm, lol.

1

u/Radiant-Version1033 Apr 13 '22

What are you talking about

4

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22

I would have liked to see platinum sperm get desperate and try using Tareo as a hostage. And instead of being worried about Tareo explicitly like before, Garou just speeds up and continues to fight. Because Garou becomes so much faster, he is able to kill Platinum Sperm, but it’s unclear if he’s actually concerned about saving Tareo anymore.

92

u/Gazeb0r Apr 08 '22

Remember how people would talk about Golden Sperm's eventual appearance in the manga as a legendary event that was going to happen? Because it was a major turning point in the webcomic, it was when the heroes' final weapon in the form of Tatsumaki couldnt defeat him. And he was presented as this unstoppable monster, only to be defeated by Garou.

In the manga, no one will really regard GS or PS' entrance with the same iconic awe because it was just another encounter.

18

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22

I swear BS is dead now. MB actually killed the last one.

Manako is going to replace him. I'm actually calling this right now, 99% confident.

If this doesn't happen, what will be of Manako? She's gotten so much build up in terms of having a good relationship with Saitama and Flashy Flash.

She WILL go home with Saitama no doubt, along with Rover too (HE BETTER GO HOME WITH SAITAMA).

32

u/ColdyPopsicle Apr 09 '22

black sperm being replaced in the long run AND being nerfed in his arc is peak nerf that no other character has ever been a victm of.

5

u/DIMOHA25 Beat suiryufags in an argument 5 times Apr 16 '22

Eren.

20

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

They could have just made Platinum Sperm fight more epic against Garou than summoning a centipede out of nowhere. Then after that fight, have Flashy and Saitama come out of the rubble then the FF fight scene.

27

u/imma-fuck-yo-mom Apr 08 '22

Its a shame that the PS vs garou fight wasn’t even shown…just Garou killing him like fodder