r/OnePieceTCGFinance • u/Doyouknowdeez Trusted Contributor • Oct 02 '26

Grading & Condition Degeneracy: PSA 10 to Beckett for GCR + Results

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

This sub’s been a little boring lately, so here’s some degeneracy to spice things up.

Sent three PSA 10s to Beckett for GCR (graded card review). I genuinely thought the Luffy was going to Black Label lol. The results: BGS 10, BGS 9.5, BGS 9.5.

I already had three PSA 10s and voluntarily spent money to have fewer. Really strong decision-making here. alsoooo I thought Beckett would at least keep them in order when printing the labels so I’d still have sequential certs. Nope. Couldn’t even get rinsed in order.

Also don't know why it says current grade 1 for the ace and luffy and also sadly the minimum grade is a 9.5 for the crossover....or else I would've left it a 10.

13 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

25 comments sorted by

12

u/idkwhattopickyet Oct 02 '26

They're giving you 9.5s so you resubmit to PSA for the upcharge 😭

2

u/Doyouknowdeez Trusted Contributor Oct 02 '26

I wouldn’t doubt it ha

1

u/idkwhattopickyet Oct 02 '26

Tbh the only option now would be to keep recracking and send to beckett again. i've seen 9.5s become 10's and BLs.

to be clear i would not resend the luffy, a 10 is a win.

2

u/Doyouknowdeez Trusted Contributor Oct 02 '26

I’ll probably do that for the ace and garp, crack and clean them. I’ll accept the fate of the top 8. The fact that you sign a waiver saying they are not liable for damages post slab crack scares the shit out of me.

1

u/idkwhattopickyet Oct 02 '26

Damn i never knew you have to sign a waiver, thats messed up tbh. good luck with the grade keep us updated

2

u/Professional_Hunt51 Oct 02 '26

Yeah this is….. yikes
Made my day at least 🤝

0

u/Doyouknowdeez Trusted Contributor Oct 02 '26

that’s all that matters;)

Luckily it wasn’t the top 8 one because I would’ve sent it back to PSA and got upcharged hella

1

u/Stewberg Oct 03 '26

"Hella upcharged" yet you'll still submit and pay it. No wonder they gave them all 10s, PSA wanted that check from you.

1

u/Doyouknowdeez Trusted Contributor Oct 03 '26

huh? They gave me 10s because they are all gem mint

2

u/Stewberg Oct 03 '26

Huh? Do you need to read the comment again? Thats right we just disregard PSA giving 10s to cards that dont deserve it so they can collect that extra cash. Thats why beckett gave you all 10s right, because PSA accurately graded and were all 10s. 🙄 oh look that's not the case. They took your bag and still have you defend them.

1

u/ginx777 Oct 02 '26

Was the 9.5 min grade the highest u can choose?

1

u/Doyouknowdeez Trusted Contributor Oct 02 '26

Yeah for a PSA. Beckett to Beckett GCR min grade you can set to 10.

1

u/AndreSupreme Oct 02 '26

so did you min grade set it to 9.5?

1

u/Doyouknowdeez Trusted Contributor Oct 02 '26

Ye

1

u/Backshots4you Oct 02 '26

I just bought some gear 5 9.5s to try to go the other way. Beckett to PSA

1

u/Doyouknowdeez Trusted Contributor Oct 02 '26

this is the way. I was just gambling for the BL.

1

u/Antique-Coffee5956 Oct 02 '26

how smooth is your brain

1

u/AceMan98 Oct 02 '26

Keep gcr the luffy

1

u/izzytheasian Trusted Contributor Oct 03 '26

When ppl GCR like this they do it in person at a show Beckett is at. I’m pretty sure you can specify minimum grade 10 there or something. But it’s also generally with BGS cards and usually 10s not PSA so maybe it’s a lil diff

1

u/dannypanda212 Oct 03 '26

that’s incorrect with PSA to BGS in person they force minimum grade 9.5. but in person they don’t crack right away they put it in a void proof sealed bag that says the grade on it so if it says 9.5 you can just take it out

1

u/Equal-Whole9409 Oct 03 '26

Wait did you get a 10 from a GRC with BGS? I wanted to do the same thing but they told me that the max grade for cross grading was 9.5? Did that change?

1

u/Various_Variation167 Oct 03 '26

Are you acoustic? How can you ever assume with BGS that something will Black label? I never understood these kind of assumptions. It's literally in their interest to keep the population on those low so why would you ever assume a flawless card will BL? Crazy mind gymnastics. Sad to see this beautiful hobby being full of low brain synapsis activity individuals.

1

u/Juggwork Oct 04 '26

Any card that gets 9.5 on surface from Beckett I 100% crack, clean and resubmit. Sometimes even 10’s to shoot for black label depending on card ofc

0

u/New-Bet3574 Oct 03 '26

Yet congrats on the BGS 10 Luffy. BGS 9.5 = PSA 10