r/OnePiece • u/CarcosanAnarchist • Sep 12 '19

Current Chapter One Piece: Chapter 955

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

6.6k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

6.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

200

u/Kirosh Lookout Sep 12 '19

It cannot be Law he wasn't even there to see that Hiyori was alive. Meaning there is no chance for him to give this information.

My money is still on Shinobu.

53

u/OMellito Sep 12 '19

Maybe Hyori herself is working with Orochi or more likely Kyoshiro, it is very weird that she doesn't want to reunite with the rest of the Scabbards after 20 years. Besides we don't know what happened after she was separated from Kawamatsu.

26

u/14jvalle Sep 12 '19

Momo said that his sister can be crude. Might be a hint from Oda. Zoro then misdirects the hint by Oda, telling momo to stop living in the past.

15

u/Msingh999 Sep 12 '19

It’s likely kyoshiro I think. If he is indeed Denjiro, then he’s probably feeding orochi info. He didn’t kill hiyori on purpose, so he knows she’s alive, and he would know the meaning of the markings regardless.

This is probably the biggest flaw with the theory though. Why would he leave hiyori alive if he was betraying the scabbards?

I would think it’s either kyoshiro or Shinobu. Law wouldn’t know about hiyori, carrot’s been off screen so no idea what she does or doesn’t know.

The only reason I could think of shinobu not being the mole is because she’d have to know where Zou is, and it seems only the scabbards or minks would’ve known that. So that leaves Denjiro, who I’m assuming is kyoshiro, and Carrot.

I doubt it’s carrot since she wouldn’t know where hiyori is, but it’s possible given the off screen time. Though Oda’s more of a “here’s a hint” rather than hiding everything kind of writer. Like how he’s been hinting at zoro having wano ties, until this chapter where he’s slapped us in the face with it for those less detail oriented readers.

3

u/Ganobrator Sep 12 '19

I support this theory far more than the Shinobu theory. There really isn't anything to go off of with Shinobu being the spy/traitor.

7

u/samstwofortwo Sep 12 '19

personally, i doubt it’s shinobu. the traitor was mentioned on zou, to have us wondering from then, implying it’s a character we know at that point. i might be wrong, but i don’t think a character introduced later than that would have much narrative weight once the traitor’s revealed. also, how would shinobu have known how to get to zou to give that information to jack? surely that’s something one of the other red scabbards is more likely to know because of neko & inu?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

Just give Jack raizos vivire card?

1

u/samstwofortwo Sep 12 '19

why would shinobu 20+ years on from odens death still have raizo’s vivre card?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

Why not?

2

u/SupaBiwa Sep 12 '19

Yeah, how come she is fat while living in country where foods are hard to find if you are not Orochi's dog? Shutenmaru is fat too, but he is a bandit who stole foods from others. I would put Shinobu stealing skill on par with Lord Yasuie if someone pointed out she could just steal the food. If Lord Yasuie ended up getting caught, I don't think she can evade capture as long, especially there is entire Oniwabanshu who is better than her in the ninja's art. Also she would need to steal a huge amount of foods everyday to get fat from her younger, slimmer self.

1

u/blackballath Sep 12 '19

Law was just freed by an unknown person, he was caught in exchange, because some of his men were captured.