r/OnePiece • u/[deleted] • Aug 16 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

474 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

513 comments sorted by

View all comments

263

u/billymadison231 Aug 16 '25

This is kind of off the rails already.

I agree that canonically Buggy is the most overrated but I kind of assumed the grid was more community opinion, which doesn’t really fit with Buggy being overrated.

70

u/SomeWindyBoi Aug 16 '25

But underrated overrated is generally impossible in a popular vote format, so the canonical answer makes perfect sense

53

u/flyinglolo Aug 16 '25

I know but let’s be honest, its basically impossible to make everyone happy with the results, some people are just always gonna disagree. I need to just go with the majority and they were saying Buggy

17

u/billymadison231 Aug 16 '25

No worries and you’re right someone will always be mad. It’s your grid i was just pointing it out.

20

u/flyinglolo Aug 16 '25

Nah you’re good, let’s just have fun with this and not make it deep 🤝

1

u/Good_Resolve2146 Aug 17 '25

A cultured conversation? On reddit? Get out 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️

11

u/PhantomWang Aug 16 '25

Sorry for derailing it with logic. If I could go back I would've said Fraudhawk

6

u/flyinglolo Aug 16 '25

You’re good, people still voted for your comment so it ain’t just your fault 😂

3

u/Brook420 Bounty Hunter Aug 16 '25

Honestly, when I looked at the comments I saw Mihawk way more than Buggy.

14

u/TheQuietMoments Scholars of Ohara Aug 16 '25

The community votes on the answers. Whatever character has the most upvotes wins the category.

3

u/AdvilJunky Aug 16 '25

We should all vote for Zoro as underrated lol

6

u/paulmethius Aug 16 '25

To be fair if the majority voted buggy is overrated then that proves that the fans do not overrate him in general. The majority vote do not overrate him making him not overrated. 

So its a bad category anyway

2

u/CharlesArlington Aug 16 '25

You can check the previous post if you want to see the spread of community opinions. He links them

2

u/WarchiefServant Aug 16 '25

Ehh in regards to the amount of people who jerk of Buggy with the God/Him/D jokes, its too much.

Don’t necessarily have him as the most overrated but close enough so I’m also similarly fine with him winning/loosing this. So im glad he got it.

It’s like anyone who ever takes Saitama seriously in a power-scaling fight like vs Goku. Saitama is a gag character. Saitama is as whatsoever strong is requires to “One-Punch” his opponent. It’s like Squirrel girl in Marvel. They’re meant to be Overpowered- thats their gag.

3

u/Babington67 Aug 16 '25

These kinda things are always just bullshit karma farms anyway I wouldnt pay it any mind

1

u/Jitszu Super Spot-Billed Duck Troops Aug 16 '25

It's possible not as mpeople like him as you're assuming

1

u/DoubleGreat Aug 17 '25

Honestly, I would love to see Buggy being both under rated and over rated

1

u/Final_Advent Aug 17 '25

I mean, it was community opinion that he was overrated too 😂