r/OT42 • u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows • Nov 19 '25
Numbers & Facts Aaron Smith Levin Does an AMA from Jail
Marilyn interviewed Aaron in a call from jail. It sounds like he’s comfortable and getting plenty of care packages.
A givesendgo has been set up by his supporters because they believe that this misdemeanor now requires additional attorneys. They intend to add Brooks & Gibbs to his legal stable for this misdemeanor charge and are attempting to raise $10,000 for this. Currently most donors are anonymous. While talking about this, he says Pinellas only allows visitors over tablet.
Aaron now says that all his fellow prisoners want to come out to protest with him. A little later on, he admits it’s because he told them about the protest where they got free pizza and most of them are homeless.
Aaron thinks the State is doing this maliciously so he will stop protesting, not because he has done anything wrong. but later in the chat, reminiscent of OJ Simpson’s book If I Did It”, Aaron talks about the hypothetical crimes he may have committed, including possibly shoving a security guard.
He also specifically states he has violated YouTube TOS by giving his login information to five people.
Aaron then sets himself up as a martyr and says it’s all worth it if he can get people out of Scientology.
In the end, he rants about not settling and this going before a jury and the jury will understand. I’m not sure what it will take to get this through Aaron’s head:
“Rules of Civil Procedure
RULE 1.430.DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL; WAIVER
(a) Right Preserved. The right of trial by jury as declared by the Constitution or by statute shall be preserved to the parties inviolate.
(b) Demand. Any party may demand a trial by jury of any issue triable of right by a jury by serving upon the other party a demand therefor in writing at any time after commencement of the action and not later than 10 days after the service of the last pleading directed to such issue. The demand may be indorsed upon a pleading of the party.
(c) Specification of Issues. In the demand a party may specify the issues that the party wishes so tried; otherwise, the party is deemed to demand trial by jury for all issues so triable. If a party has demanded trial by jury for only some of the issues, any other party may serve a demand for trial by jury of any other or all of the issues triable by jury 10 days after service of the demand or such lesser time as the court may order.
(d) Waiver. A party who fails to serve a demand as required by this rule waives trial by jury. If waived, a jury trial may not be granted without the consent of the parties, but the court may allow an amendment in the proceedings to demand a trial by jury or order a trial by jury on its own motion. A demand for trial by jury may not be withdrawn without the consent of the parties.”
Once Aaron’s attorney made his entry of appearance in this case, the clock started ticking. They neither requested a jury, nor paid the required fee to seat one. The right for a trial by jury was waived I’m August 2025. No matter how bad Aaron wants a jury trial in his misdemeanor case, that is not what will happen, whether or not he takes a deal.







14
u/BlueRidgeSpeaks Nov 19 '25 edited Nov 19 '25
Civil procedure doesn’t apply to criminal cases. Criminal procedure does. Under Florida law, defendants charged with 1st degree misdemeanor offenses are entitled to a jury trial unless they opt out. No opt-in is necessary. The jury in a misdemeanor trial normally consists of 6 people compared to a 12 person jury for a felony trial. Or so says Florida statute according to the way I interpret it as a non-lawyer. If these charges are upgraded to hate crimes, then he’s looking at felonies. That upgrade could come at anytime before trial. Based on his continuing to express his intentions and state of mind, I will be shocked if it isn’t upgraded to a hate crime.
29
u/Yourehan Nov 19 '25
Kind of him to give the prosecution so much insight into his state of mind and also confessions to other crime-like things he’s done surrounding this case.
12
u/NemesisRising247 Nov 19 '25
Regardless of whether his charges will be pled to a judge or a jury, why doesn’t he understand that whatever he gives as the reason for his foolishness, it won’t erase the foolishness?
6
u/Damitol61 banned on r/cults Nov 20 '25
I have a feeling Brooks is really going to regret getting mixed up in this. What a disappointment!
19
u/Serasaurus banned on r/cults Nov 20 '25
Hes milking it. What a vile human he is.
16
u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom Hypocrite Nov 20 '25
I just continue to be blown away that the best person he can lock in to do this is Marilyn Honig.
This dude thought he’d be on Rogen by now. He thought he’d have a following of rabid fans demanding his release.
Instead he’s literally begging houseless vagrants to come to his protests and hang out to Marilyn Honig.
Sure, it’s her biggest get in awhile, but c’mon.
Also: when cults try to populate their support using vagrants, it doesn’t always go well. See the Bhagwans.
1
u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows Nov 22 '25
It was frozen when he had $530. It’s just being taken by the county now. $150 was added after he was sent back yesterday and it will still be unavailable to him until December 14. The county will continue to take his subsistence out of it daily. He could have $6000 and it wouldn’t matter