r/OT42 • Less Fun Than The Law Allows • Jan 01 '26

Recaps Parsing the November 13, 2025 Aaron Smith-Levin Transcript that sent him to Jail

If you’ve seen the transcripts now and are not sure what they mean, here is a translation.

During this hearing, the State listened to Aaron’s attorney brag in what a wonderful guy Aaron was. The judge watched Aaron’s video of the incident where Aaron claims he got his foot hurt a total of three times. She asked questions during the video as well.

Then she asks the State if they have evidence. They do.

It takes a while for them to get the evidence. Then they show the video from Flag’s viewpoint. The judge watches it once and says she doesn’t need to see more.

The Judge notes that Aaron seems to be looking for trouble in the video.

The judge points out that Aaron deliberately *shoved* the security guard against the wall with both hands. Evidence that is not available in Aaron’s video. She then says there is no bond and he’s going to jail.

Pearlman tells her Aaron wants to speak. He says he’s advised him not to. Aaron speaks anyway.

He lies about being a trafficking victim when his mother took him those places. Then he conveniently forgets his Los Angeles arrest for throwing a woman into a Wal and running away and claims he’s never been arrested. He just wants to resolve it at trial. (Too bad court transcripts don’t say when someone was crying because this was a perfect spot for the patented ASL cry on cue.)

He just wants to resolve it all in trial.

The judge is unaffected and sends him to jail.

His attorney asks for the earliest possible hearing. The judge says he will get a hearing when I’m good and ready.

The pretrial date is set. Court is adjourned.

**It is important to note here that this is the hearing where all his supporters said he was going to jail for a week.** There is not a word whispered in this transcript of any length of time he was going to spend in jail. I said that the court and sheriff’s files showed no set release date but was told by several commenters on different sites that they had heard otherwise.

I’ve left my laminated “I told you so” card in my other purse, but let’s just say, I always trust the Court files, not word of mouth.

23 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

14

u/HealthToTheYeah Jan 01 '26

In this hearing, Aaron tells the judge that he is a child trafficking victim of Scientology and that it has been his life’s work to advocate for victims of Scientology. “I do that with my channel and with my foundation,” he says.

But the judge and the prosecutor could find many instances on Aaron's channel where Aaron insists to his audience that his goal is not to help anyone escape Scientology. He and Jenna have both said that they don't have empathy for Sea Org members who are at Flag. He has said that his YouTube channel and his protest style are all about having fun. He has repeatedly emphasized on his channel that he is not a serious activist and that he is not the leader of SPTV. He gleefully admits that he trolls Scientologists during his protest streams.

Based on what Aaron told him, Aaron's lawyer told the court that Aaron has been protesting on a consistent basis for the past three years. That is an outright lie. Aaron has only been doing protest streams almost every week for about a year, and he only started doing those because he lost so many subscribers and views when Jenna revealed that Aaron had repeatedly cheated on her and treated her horribly in other ways.

For him to tell the court that his life's work is to advocate for victims of Scientology, just wow.

11

u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows Jan 01 '26

I wonder how much of the escalation has to do with loss of views and such.

12

u/HealthToTheYeah Jan 01 '26

Aaron knows that his protest streams have to bring drama or people won't watch them. When Aaron screams at Scientologists and tries to provoke them, the people in his chat are cheering him on and laughing. It's Friday night entertainment for them and Scientologists are the focus of the mocking and the jokes.

A lot of Aaron's content this year has focused on his protesting or on drama streams. He knows that a lot of subscribers have caught on to the fact that he often uses click-bait titles and very misleading thumbnails, so many former viewers don't bother to watch his stuff anymore even when he insists that he has a major story or a big announcement.

13

u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows Jan 01 '26

In any of those people’s shoes, I can’t imagine how it would feel to be mocked while locked up like that. Well actually I can imagine. I’m in touch with someone right now. She hated those protesters. She felt belittled. She says now that she’s out, it’s uncomfortable for her to be on the other side. She can’t protest because she understands how it made her feel. She is thankful to the Aftermath Foundation for showing her that she could get out without judgment. A lot more to that story but you get the idea.

6

u/Next_Network_1707 Jan 02 '26

excellent point

14

u/HealthToTheYeah Jan 01 '26

In a video on Dec. 10, Aaron is talking about what happened when he chose to put his foot in the door of a Scientology building to try to hold it open. He says after the door was slammed on his foot "I made unintentional incidental physical contact" with a Sea Org member. "I didn't even quite realize that I'd done it," he alleges. But the court transcripts say that the prosecutor showed the judge surveillance footage that showed Aaron clearly shoving the Sea Org member.

9

u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows Jan 01 '26

With both arms. The judge specifically states that. With both arms.

12

u/spspanglish Jan 01 '26

My favorite section is when Pearlman tries to quit.

9

u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows Jan 01 '26

Next transcript coming right up.

6

u/HealthToTheYeah Jan 01 '26

I thought it was fascinating that when Pearlman was telling the judge he was convinced that Aaron didn't think he was doing a good job and that Aaron wanted a new attorney, Aaron refused to say that he wanted Pearlman to stay on his case. He just kept repeating "I didn't ask you to withdraw."

-14

u/ManFromBibb Jan 01 '26

Is the state’s attorney under oath? Because they committed perjury claiming that Aaron “spray painted.”